today's episode in bad taste! - Page 2

i agree with you. the problem is with the format of the show. this is not the first time it has happened also . The earlier seasons of Jhalak also had k serial bahus winning over the best dancers like in the first season where mona singh won over shweta salve where shweta was an excellent dancer than mona and used to get good scores and comments from the judges.The second season had prachi desai win over sandhya mridul so why blame karan alone this time. The judges knew what they were getting into so why create a scene on the day of the semi finals and demoralise the contestant who is popular.

what is this talk about respect?? Karan dont deserve to be in this show and thats the truth, Judges protested for this cause and I'm with them!

Originally posted by: preksha_forever

what is this talk about respect?? Karan dont deserve to be in this show and thats the truth, Judges protested for this cause and I'm with them!

ok there's no point in expecting anything else from u... have it ur way! u obviously feel there is nothing wrong with what happened today! the system is not wrong, insulting a human being is not wrong, demoralizing him is not wrong.. all that is wrong here is karan and his popularity.. cool!

but atleast dont go so far as to say he doesnt deserve respect. even a beggar on the street deserves respect, for he is human with feelings.. karan is a human being, who has definitely done something to come where he is today.. and i dont mean just in jhalak.. so for that he deserves respect..

I dont think he deserves respect!

Originally posted by: hope4u

ok there's no point in expecting anything else from u... have it ur way! u obviously feel there is nothing wrong with what happened today! the system is not wrong, insulting a human being is not wrong, demoralizing him is not wrong.. all that is wrong here is karan and his popularity.. cool!

but atleast dont go so far as to say he doesnt deserve respect. even a beggar on the street deserves respect, for he is human with feelings.. karan is a human being, who has definitely done something to come where he is today.. and i dont mean just in jhalak.. so for that he deserves respect..

ok well they might have gone a lil too far but u need to understand we are frustrated. This has been happening since JDJ started always the good dancer leaves and the popular one wins! It was time that the Judges took a stand and so they did. It wasn't meant to hurt Karans feelings but defn to let his fans know to wake up and vote for the best dancer not for ONLY karan.

Originally posted by: anna143

[
ok well they might have gone a lil too far but u need to understand we are frustrated. This has been happening since JDJ started always the good dancer leaves and the popular one wins! It was time that the Judges took a stand and so they did. It wasn't meant to hurt Karans feelings but defn to let his fans know to wake up and vote for the best dancer not for ONLY karan.<br><br>

i totally understand ur frustrated.. im equally frustrated because HK is out, and because i cannot support karan blindly..if he wins, i would want him to perform and win..
but what im trying to tell here is what's happening is not fair..we have seen unfair results in every reality show..so if the format had to be changed, it would've been changed by now..that aint happening.. in that case is it right to hurt the sentiments of the person involved?

Agree to a great extent on each point you made...i think Hard Kaur deserved to stay, and in her ouster, JDJ lost it's most consistent and most deserving performer for the title... i really do...and it was awful to watch her leave especially after her OSO performance, which was absolutely stunning...tw...

All i want to say is that Hard Kaur was the strongest contender and at no cost should she have been in the bottom two, let alone being eliminated. No point in watching this show now!!

I liked everyone who participated in this series of JDJ but i would only want the best dancer to win, and HK was and is the best dancer by far!!

Originally posted by: nandinidev

Agree to a great extent on each point you made...i think Hard Kaur deserved to stay, and in her ouster, JDJ lost it's most consistent and most deserving performer for the title... i really do...and it was awful to watch her leave especially after her OSO performance, which was absolutely stunning...tw...

but yes, the Judges confused me a little with the rather vociforous Strike issue, since the power to save HK had been in their own hands a couple of minutes ago...but then i guess they realised the full gravity of their decision when they saw HK and Savio perform so brilliantly...and they're human beings after all, and will express themselves when emotionally charged...but yes, i agree that some of the footage need not have been aired at all, and alot of it could have been avoided instead of sensationalising and dramatizing the issue, which Jhalak happens to be so good at, like airing Karan's face every time the word 'popularity' was mentioned...🤔

and i agree, i would want Karan to win only if he performs well enough to show everyone that he deserves to be where he is...that happened two weeks back, but the lull last night really cost him, even in these terms...he does have some part to play in bringing it onto himself by being inconsistent, but to corner him for the ouster of someone else on account of something he can't control is plain unfair, to say the least...i thought it was in really bad taste to pointedly refer to him...it may not have been meant that way, but it certainly was demoralising, as it would have been for anyone in his place...😔

i don't think it's fair to blame him for being in the Finale anyway, since the people chose to vote or not to vote for whom they like, and it's something neither the judges nor the contestants can control...and they were well aware of this when they signed up for the show...if they didn't like the format, they shouldn't have signed for it...since none of them are naive innocents here, and have all had enough experience of reality shows over the years to know what the voting pattern is usually like...especially Saroj ji and Vaibhavi since they've both judged reality shows like this before, and are not new to this predicament...🤔

i've always maintained neutrality here...and in the same spirit, i thought today's episode need not have turned out the way it did...that's really the bottomline...👎🏼

Agree with you word to word.

The best one is out now...and the remaining are all of the same level.....so sit back and watch their finals performance and then vote accordingly. no point blaming/humiliating anyone now. Whatever happened is because of the format and the Judges.

I m really sad 2 see a judge like SK behave in that way...she actually said that she was expecting Karan 2 go....how demoralizing is that....she can very well blame d system but why blame Karan for it....he was so sad...d way he hugged HK after her elimination showed how upset he was 2 see her go...