popularity vs talent!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: farislove
I understand that some popular people can't dance, but that doesn't mean all popular people cant dance, otherwise all actors in bollywood would not dance, example, Hrithik is very popular actor, he is a mind-blowing dancer too, so I think it's wrong to say popularity vs. talent, coz talent most of the time make people popular......
I know most of the time happen that popularity win over some better dancer in these dance reality shows, but I don't think it's always........

he become popular because of his dance

Quote

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: bloodline

infact i'd say contestants who are more populer are the one who is working hard....for exampla Karan and Parul...both of them are immensl popular and they are trying to maintain their own show and JDJ!!
unlike other "non-famous" celebrities who do nat have any projects other than JDJ to work on....they can easily spare their time for practise

i agree with you..they are really working hard to maintain their expectations from the fans.. and pressure will be more on them in comparison with others..

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rose

@Painted_Lady

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: farislove
I understand that some popular people can't dance, but that doesn't mean all popular people cant dance, otherwise all actors in bollywood would not dance, example, Hrithik is very popular actor, he is a mind-blowing dancer too, so I think it's wrong to say popularity vs. talent, coz talent most of the time make people popular......
I know most of the time happen that popularity win over some better dancer in these dance reality shows, but I don't think it's always........

I'm not saying that popular people are not talented..talent can be in anything...acting,speaking,singing,dancing..here in this show what we consider is the 'talent in dancing'..i also believe that its a mix of non-dancers, average dancers and good dancers in the show...so whoever survives in the show should ultimately win..we start voting for the contestants after seeing the performance..we should see if a particular contestant did full justice to the performance or not..not that if he/she is a good actor or model..

Quote

Guess who?

@R1U2K3

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: Disha60
Its definately Popularity which is overmastering talent in this show but that doesnt mean that the ones who r popular dont have talent. Not all but I like Parul, she is talented plus popular.
There are many other contestants who are becoming popular on basis of their dancing talent and they are Hard Kaur, Monica, Shilpa and they deserve every bit of it!! Sad that Gauhar is out but I hope she comes back in Wild Card round.

Thats what we all are saying .. That does not mean, the ones who are popular, don't have talent .. They are here to learn, obviously they are not professional dancers, and not always will their performance turn out to be poor .. at least give them a chance to prove themselves ..

Quote

Silence

@SecretKhabri420

Achiever

+ 9

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: lats55

he become popular because of his dance

Do u mean Hrithik became popular of his dance only?, I don't think so, otherwise he would not recive so many awards for his acting, there is no way of avoiding that he is a good dancer, but he would not survive in bollywood and be popular of only being good dancer and not good actor, but he is much popular beside dancing is acting in first place.......

Quote

Siddhi

@-tanya-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

Noone should take offence against what you said, since it is a fact. I agree with you 100%.

Quote

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: farislove

Do u mean Hrithik became popular of his dance only?, I don't think so, otherwise he would not recive so many awards for his acting, there is no way of avoiding that he is a good dancer, but he would not survive in bollywood and be popular of only being good dancer and not good actor, but he is much popular beside dancing is acting in first place.......

probably i like to see his movies not for his acting but for his dancing.. esp dhoom 2..

Quote

lillipop105

@lillipop105

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: Mickee
Hi all

What is happening in the show at the moment is a fight between popularity and talent! What do you say?It has happened in the past with the other sony shows also..like JDJ 1 and JDJ 2..Without doubt I would say that Sandya Mridul and Shweta Salve deserved to win..(Mona and Prachi fans,no offence..No personal comments here..😉..)I always want the best dancer to win, regardless of him/her being an actress,model or sports player..

I totally agree!!!!! Prachi definetly deserved to b in da finals but Sandhya shold have won even tho i'm a prachi fan..

Quote

Noshin

@x.n0sh.x

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#19

I totally agree with you!

Most of the reality shows go with popularity rather than talent and that bugs me a lot!

And this contrast of Popularity vs Talent can be greatly viewed in JDJ.

They are particular contestants who are "passing by" ( getting hell a lotta votes) just because they are popular, good looking etc etc. But they are not getting those thousand votes for their talent and that is not fair.

Reality shows are not set up to see " who is the most popular" but who is the most versatile. But people dont see that.

That is how the world is rolling, and i dont know when will this injustice stop.

Edited by n0sh - 16 years ago