Giaa and Shibani's scores Deserving?[DT Note Pg10] - Page 4

Frankly, no! Gia toh bilkul bhi nahi! Shibani was very good, but again, not a 30! But if Gia got one, then Shibani deserved more than 30. Gia's tollywood performance was much better than this aerial act (not that the previous performance was exceptional either). And besides, I thought they were not supposed to touch the ground in their act? They were on the ground most of the act! But anyway, even if I do discount that, it still was an average performance. 25 or 26 would've been a better score. I felt Darsheel/Avneet did better.

I haven't watched Gia's performance so i won't comment about her. But yes, i felt Shibani's performance was just above average if not average ! Shibani and Punit lost out on co-ordination on many steps...it was clearly seen !

Originally posted by: Rapier

Frankly, no! Gia toh bilkul bhi nahi! Shibani was very good, but again, not a 30! But if Gia got one, then Shibani deserved more than 30. Gia's tollywood performance was much better than this aerial act (not that the previous performance was exceptional either). And besides, I thought they were not supposed to touch the ground in their act? They were on the ground most of the act! But anyway, even if I do discount that, it still was an average performance. 25 or 26 would've been a better score. I felt Darsheel/Avneet did better.

Coming to Shibani, I also thought that this wasn't her best. She has done better. But having said that, I still liked the performance. I would give it a 28. But a 30 was not deserving for either of the two/

TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU!!!! they didnt deserve 30

In my opinion they both deserved 30 their performance was very good especially shibani's i mean they had nice coordination despite of the wall between them, and their concept was very unique And Gia performance was very beautiful and they completed the most difficult challenge beautifully.

I liked the concept behind Shibani's performance. I thought they came up with a nice idea for the wall challenge but I didn't like the execution. Frankly it didn't have enough "dancing". I would say she deserved a 27, not really a 30.

I didn't see a single 30 point performance today. They were all average. Last week was so good! Is the enthusiasm drooping?

[quote] ll the three judges should learn dancing [/quote]

even I think gia and shibani deserves 27 not at all 30.