Giaa and Shibani's scores Deserving?[DT Note Pg10] - Page 2

Originally posted by: roopalgupta

well i think both completely deserved a 30

gia's performance was very graceful and her expressions were beautiful...nishant's choreography was fantabulous...the performance was magical and somewhere keeping us hooked...

about isha's performance so it was such a flawless one...their beautiful efforts with the wall were great...their coordination was very nice...and the choreography was fabulous...it was a great fun to watch the performance...

and about the fact that u raised that we have saw better earlier too with these themes so 30 is not fair so i completely disagree...just coz someone created a high benchmark earlier in other seasons or shows then u can't say that the one who performed beautifully in present didn't deserved a 30...

Originally posted by: ran2012

Well I think both deserved 30. Giaa's performance was wonderful! Ok till now ppl used to compare between contestants of JDJ now they have started comparing between other shows!!😆.
I wonder then all the contestants performance has to be compared with other shows acts?😕

Originally posted by: Beelte003

I'm not denying the fact that the performance weren't good enough, I'm saying they shouldn't have been scored so high. Of course it matters if someone sets up a benchmark, you have to beat that inorder to outshine yourself and prove you're better than the best. I'm not saying all the contestants are nothing compared to Isha, infact, I haven't even drawn any major comparison at all. We know of a few possibilities that can portrayed through those dance forms so why go for the obvious?

Originally posted by: roopalgupta

firstly dear i didn't brought isha in between and request u too to not bring her here and i don't find any issue to bring her in here

@bold

i agree with the fact but only when the benchmark is created in the same season of the show...i mean if there was a higher benchmark for these acts in this season then i would have supported that gia and shibani didn't deserved a 30...its the first benchmark created by the girls in this season in the respective themes...and i think we should judge the contestants on the basis on their present performance and not on how close they are to the past created benchmark...

Originally posted by: Mandy20

woah, talk about jealousy 😉

Originally posted by: Beelte003

My apologies. I thought you mentioned her first. Or maybe you just got confused with the names you wrote Isha instead of Shibani in your post earlier.

Well, you do have a point there but do the contestants really need to set up benchmarks every season? I thought that platform has been through exceptional performances in the seasons earlier and the contestants this year were aware of it, only so they could perform better than the ones who've performed already.