Nachiket; A worst father anybody can have, SHAME ON YOU![05/08/15] - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

6.3k

Users

22

Likes

126

Frequent Posters

EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#31
The truth is this show is just not on right path .At start both characters were believable , now things have changed completely . And nothing is believable in the show .
Filza. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: JB-US

No Neil's not responsible for all of the mistakes in his children's lives but he is responsible for a great deal of them.

Nishi did bend in the marriage or she never would've returned. She tried alternatives and Neil was merely one of them.

The misbehavior was there however it was explained justified and eventually would've have ended. Neil is could and is held accountable for intensifying and increasingly the misbehavior. As for mentioning the reasons, I have given numerous in the other posts.

You don't think it's a phase but however I do. Even before Nishi was getting married, Aarav took her to buy cotton candy and they reminisced the moments in which they argued with their mom and came for solace here. This meant they eventually made up and things were well and this was one of those problems as well.
.For crying out loud they're teenagers and there still changing.
Nishi first believed that love was everything but as soon as she settled, she began to believe that love was merely a lie, deceitful, and not fulfilling in comparison to household duties, pressurized motherhood. If this isn't a phase, then what is it.

She's changing continuously and as a child she thinks too quick, falls too quick, argues, and is unable to accept. Eventually she would've agreed with Ragini if Neil hadn't entered, her alternatives were running short and if Neil did not agree, she would eventually give in and later understand when she was independent.

As for Aarav, not a phase? Are you kidding me? He was a teenager who had a huge crush on a girl, who wanted a bike, and wanted to get rich really fast. Do you not see how childish these demands are and why I argue it's just a phase. Realistically speaking, every child wants these things which they first consider necessities but along with time understand that it's unfulfilling, they have to wait and work for it. He was still acting immature and eventually would've come to his senses, loved someone else or something else, and then moved on. Really Neil entered and provided his demands and that is where his mistook his childish behavior for reality.

I already gave several examples and explanations for the reasons they misbehaved and where Neil did not stop them, nor do I wish to repeat them.

Fine, he may not have been happy when she was upset but that did not stop him from salting her wounds or stopping their kids for the majority of the time from insulting her.



I'm talking about later when R did agree but on a condition and yet Nishi will not budge an inch from her stance.
And in my opinion a lot of things they did can not be justified for example calling & inviting your mother's ex husband without her knowledge, humiliating your mother in front of your in laws by bringing in her boss as a father figure for yourself. She ended up inviting her father to live with her without giving a thought to Ragini's feelings. Go figure.

Nishi's perception and opinion on love and marriage have changed but i'm talking of her equation with her mother. Nishi's bitterness with her mom has been forever lasting since the very beginning till date; constant phase in her life if you call it one.

And in my honest opinion Aarav's beavhiour was not a normal teenage behaviour. Taking huge sum of money from goons on interest is something that even 14 year old would not do.
He should have been done with his crush when the girl made it clear she was not interested in him. His demand of a bike must be childish but the extreme behaviour he was adopting with regards to his crush was plain unhealthy and destructive. I dont agree that Aarav would eventually have come to his senses if N was not there.
He would have gone behind R's back to have his way.
When these kids can call their father and meet him without R knowing they very well can do anything else they find right behind her back even if N is there or not there.
Edited by Filza. - 10 years ago
JB-US thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Filza.



I'm talking about later when R did agree but on a condition and yet Nishi will not budge an inch from her stance.
And in my opinion a lot of things they did can not be justified for example calling & inviting your mother's ex husband without her knowledge, humiliating your mother in front of your in laws by bringing in her boss as a father figure for yourself. She ended up inviting her father to live with her without giving a thought to Ragini's feelings. Go figure.

Nishi's perception and opinion on love and marriage have changed but i'm talking of her equation with her mother. Nishi's bitterness with her mom has been forever lasting since the very beginning till date; constant phase in her life if you call it one.

And in my honest opinion Aarav's beavhiour was not a normal teenage behaviour. Taking huge sum of money from goons on interest is something that even 14 year old would not do.
He should have been done with his crush when the girl made it clear she was not interested in him. His demand of a bike must be childish but the extreme behaviour he was adopting with regards to his crush was plain unhealthy and destructive. I dont agree that Aarav would eventually have come to his senses if N was not there.
He would have gone behind R's back to have his way.
When these kids can call their father and meet him without R knowing they very well can do anything else they find right behind her back even if N is there or not there.

I already explained Nishi's behavior regarding the in laws and provided a detailed perspective on that and hence will not repeat it.
That is the equation with her mother for it is not only Nishi's interest of love and overwhelming emotions but also her age that should be considered and her actions which must display an explanation for this type of interaction with her mom. Nishi's bitterness has NOT been a forever thing up to date. Few incidents do not speak for the majority of them and I cannot stress this enough, many of these incident also happened AFTER Neil came and the link always somehow lead to him.
Have you not seen how almost all of the time Nishi had some dispute with Ragini, she apologized, admitted her mistake. Yes Nishi refused to budge from her stance when Ragini announced her decision but what do you think I am trying to explain in the past posts, the exact same thing that it would have subsided. I gave enough reasons and explanations for this already. It was a stubborn act and like Nishi's every other decision would have changed, she is unsure about her decisions and changes them rather quickly. Do you not think it would have eventually gone to that phase.

Aarav's behavior? Not normal?
Okay, let's put it this way, he was temporarily upset him mom that he couldn't get his bike and lashed out at her at the birthday party and then came home to apologize to her. Ragini even said that Aarav tend to get frustrated and angry easily. Aarav had a crush and even after she announced she liked someone else, he was heartbroken but he still desired to improve. Now he wanted to start a business, this is where the Neil interfered and Ragini told him that he will be HEARTBROKEN if it failed. As true to Ragini's prediction and Neil's careless attitude it did. He was still only a teenager who needed to be guided but Ranbir's taunts and showing off shilpa in his face and the overall failure of his business caused him to react like this, any teenager who is confused and millions still today act in the same way unfortunately. His actions were more than justified, he had a strong bond with him mom and the flashbacks are a nice reminder that it always wasn't like this. Now to add on to the add on to his extreme behavior for a bike and such stuff was because he saw Neil's side of the family with it, and Neil's constant providence of these items allowed he desires to thrive in a rather hazardous and stubborn way yet he hadn't still reached those types of extremes that you are stressing solely for the bike which is why he still apologized to Ragini.
Even at gunpoint, Aarav told his mom that you were right, wish I had listened to you, and that you are very nice.
As for taking money from goons, it his friends who suggested it to him and that was where he did not where he was getting himself into. The whole point of him being an inexperienced teenager who instead of being told no was actually led into the candy shop by Neil and told to choose but then ate too much and didn't know what to do. Literally this is like the entire scenario that played out. If he had stuck to Ragini and did not start a business, or saw his super rich dad, it would eventually have worked out.
Do you not understand this? They all are teenagers who were exploring, discovering, which is why I argue that it was just a phase.

Yes they contacted their dad, if suhani and aagham could contact their mom they would too, in fact they secretly flew to india to meet their mom, yet this wasn't disrespect as much as it was just curiosity to meet their parents. As for Nishi, I already wrote in my previous posts why she went to him and that is because they already had an encounter and he had promised her that she will get married to Jignesh irregardless of whether it was right or wrong, her educations, etc.

Listen Neil may not have done it intentionally but he is responsible for majority of the problems in his kids lives and their continuous mistreatment of Ragini.
t-bonegirl thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#34
Just wanted to add something here. It was Jignesh's idea to make them Google thier father and try to know his perspective. He proposes Nishi should talk to her father, only her father can help them. Nishi opposes the idea first saying he hurt her mother so she won't. Then Jignesh says they should at least be knowing about him and what exactly he did. They should know the reason why they hate him.
So, she basically meets him to ask why he hurt her mother and leave her. But obviously he's her father so she ended up asking him for help.


I think it was completely natural of them to try to find out about their father. Every single parent child would want to learn about their other parent. The problem lies with the writers here. Even the children's characters have been butchered.
sanjana thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#35
Neil never was portrayed in good light. The same with Nishi and Aarav. They are not good children either. Agham and Suhaani are good and they have always been in good relationship and understanding with Ragini.. They both can be with their mother. I want the same to be shown. Ragini should never unite with Neil.
Filza. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: JB-US

I already explained Nishi's behavior regarding the in laws and provided a detailed perspective on that and hence will not repeat it.

That is the equation with her mother for it is not only Nishi's interest of love and overwhelming emotions but also her age that should be considered and her actions which must display an explanation for this type of interaction with her mom. Nishi's bitterness has NOT been a forever thing up to date. Few incidents do not speak for the majority of them and I cannot stress this enough, many of these incident also happened AFTER Neil came and the link always somehow lead to him.
Have you not seen how almost all of the time Nishi had some dispute with Ragini, she apologized, admitted her mistake. Yes Nishi refused to budge from her stance when Ragini announced her decision but what do you think I am trying to explain in the past posts, the exact same thing that it would have subsided. I gave enough reasons and explanations for this already. It was a stubborn act and like Nishi's every other decision would have changed, she is unsure about her decisions and changes them rather quickly. Do you not think it would have eventually gone to that phase.

Aarav's behavior? Not normal?
Okay, let's put it this way, he was temporarily upset him mom that he couldn't get his bike and lashed out at her at the birthday party and then came home to apologize to her. Ragini even said that Aarav tend to get frustrated and angry easily. Aarav had a crush and even after she announced she liked someone else, he was heartbroken but he still desired to improve. Now he wanted to start a business, this is where the Neil interfered and Ragini told him that he will be HEARTBROKEN if it failed. As true to Ragini's prediction and Neil's careless attitude it did. He was still only a teenager who needed to be guided but Ranbir's taunts and showing off shilpa in his face and the overall failure of his business caused him to react like this, any teenager who is confused and millions still today act in the same way unfortunately. His actions were more than justified, he had a strong bond with him mom and the flashbacks are a nice reminder that it always wasn't like this. Now to add on to the add on to his extreme behavior for a bike and such stuff was because he saw Neil's side of the family with it, and Neil's constant providence of these items allowed he desires to thrive in a rather hazardous and stubborn way yet he hadn't still reached those types of extremes that you are stressing solely for the bike which is why he still apologized to Ragini.
Even at gunpoint, Aarav told his mom that you were right, wish I had listened to you, and that you are very nice.
As for taking money from goons, it his friends who suggested it to him and that was where he did not where he was getting himself into. The whole point of him being an inexperienced teenager who instead of being told no was actually led into the candy shop by Neil and told to choose but then ate too much and didn't know what to do. Literally this is like the entire scenario that played out. If he had stuck to Ragini and did not start a business, or saw his super rich dad, it would eventually have worked out.
Do you not understand this? They all are teenagers who were exploring, discovering, which is why I argue that it was just a phase.

Yes they contacted their dad, if suhani and aagham could contact their mom they would too, in fact they secretly flew to india to meet their mom, yet this wasn't disrespect as much as it was just curiosity to meet their parents. As for Nishi, I already wrote in my previous posts why she went to him and that is because they already had an encounter and he had promised her that she will get married to Jignesh irregardless of whether it was right or wrong, her educations, etc.

Listen Neil may not have done it intentionally but he is responsible for majority of the problems in his kids lives and their continuous mistreatment of Ragini.



look i dont want to repeat the same thing again and again. I have stated my opinion on Nishi's behaviour with my own reasons.
you consider a few things unimportant to connect it with her overall behaviour towards her mother and her nature but i dont see it that way.

& i dont remember Nishi apologising almost ALL of the time she had dispute with her mother. And i know what you are trying to explain. I dont buy the explanation and i only stated what i think which is that she would not have given in eventually and i really dont want to repeat the reasons.

Same goes for Aarav, I dont think if his father had not agreed to help him out he would have quit the idea of business altogether. He would have still went about it.

Now i never termed his crush or his demand of a product not normal.
The whole way he went about doing business in my opinion was highest level of stupidity which normal teenagers will not do. That and the very reason that he wanted to earn money through business for his crush who had rejected him was way too idiotic a behaviour for his age. He wanted a bike because Shilpa liked one. He wanted to become rich because Shilpa liked rich men. His obsession was going to dangerous extremes.

How is digging your own grave exploring. He knew he would not be able to retuen yet he goes about dealing with a dangerous goon. And please dont tell me he had no idea about the seriousness of the entire situation. He could have just asked for help from his father since he was the one who was supporting him in his venture.

And erm its not that i dont understand (as you have mentioned) i have a different perspevtive.

Also i am only talking about Aarav's mistakes here which certainly should not be taken as me saying N is entirely clean here.

Coming to Suhaani and Agham, they contacted their mother for her sake, to see her not because they wanted a favour from her. Nishi contacted N because her mother will not let her marry Jignesh and she wanted him to help her. There is a BIG difference between the two situations in my opinion.
And a correction here, Nishi and N's first ever encounter was at the airport. N never promised her before that meeting that he'll get her married. He didnt even know she was Nishi. It was after she met him that he agreed. It was not like that he promised her something and that served as an incentive for her to go meet him.
Edited by Filza. - 10 years ago
JB-US thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#37
^^^^^^Frankly speaking this is getting tiring.
I believe it's just a phase for Nishi and Aarav and it could have subsided with time without Neil's interference however you believe otherwise.

It's not that I find things unimportant to consider in their overall behavior but the value I give to each is different similar to you how you do not give consideration to my explanations and other examples in Nishi overall behavior.

In the beginning of the show it was mostly Nishi that would end up apologizing to Ragini and this leads to my points why Neil is accountable for the severed caused such bitterness. You
can disagree but this will remain my opinion.

As for Aarav, his behavior was going to extremes because Neil supported him. Really I highly believe that if he hadn't seen Neil's lifestyle and wealth, things could have been different and I have been arguing this for a while now and I truly do not wish to repeat my reasons all over again.

As for the digging your own grave remark and exploring, you know I did not mean it in that context. Exploring as in trying to find yourself, feelings towards another person, identity, and in that sense. However now that you bought the goons up again, I might as well say that Aarav seriously did not know the mess he was getting into. Again his friend recommended it to him and they said why not. He was inexperienced my whole point being and Neil supported him regardless of the fact, he went ahead and got it and it was his first time taking something from the market. He didn't even know how to properly do business and deal with people which is why nivedita refused to pay the money in the end. He could've signed a contract, done something but no which is why I argue that he was a teenager and was exploring.

As for the suhani and aagham and Nishi calling up Neil,
This is from someone else but it applies well enough here
Posted: 06 August 2015 at 7:33am | IP Logged Report Quote
"Just wanted to add something here. It was Jignesh's idea to make them Google thier father and try to know his perspective. He proposes Nishi should talk to her father, only her father can help them. Nishi opposes the idea first saying he hurt her mother so she won't. Then Jignesh says they should at least be knowing about him and what exactly he did. They should know the reason why they hate him.
So, she basically meets him to ask why he hurt her mother and leave her. But obviously he's her father so she ended up asking him for help."
This is from t-bone girl by the way.
There this is the whole Nishi calls Neil well explained.

Nishi and Aarav cared for her mother and this went all out the window when Neil walked in. He helped to develop a rather lowly image of their mom which I have given many reasons for.

Really it is a matter of perspective and will remain,
I do not wish to repeat what I have said and neither of us have as so much as hindered from our opinions and therefore this was a good debate and on a concluding note, I have put my part out and I have read yours and the concept is yet again debatable.

Hiphop_R thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#38
Filza...i too agree to whatever u have posted...shifting the complete blame on just nachiket is not done. I will not repeat whatever u have been sayin but yes nishi and aarav's characters were very well defined way before N's entry and trust me even if Neil would have said no for nishi's marriage..she had full potential to run and get married and she would have done it. As far as aarav is concerned..he is also no less..if u remember seeing the earlier episodes where shilpa's mom questions him about his status and money..he was so dissappointed that even if Neil was not involved here...he would also go against ragini...maybe not immediately but he would have surely done it..and if not Ranbir..it would have been another guy..cos aarav was so madly in love with shilpa dat he was ready to cross all limits...just imagine when u have ur dad to support u financially..why would somebody go to babubhai..so desperate..so is this also neil's fault??? I'm not even getting into ragini and neil...just talk about nishi and aarav and filza is rite...blame d writers who have sketched their characters dis way
JB-US thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Hiphop_R

Filza...i too agree to whatever u have posted...shifting the complete blame on just nachiket is not done. I will not repeat whatever u have been sayin but yes nishi and aarav's characters were very well defined way before N's entry and trust me even if Neil would have said no for nishi's marriage..she had full potential to run and get married and she would have done it. As far as aarav is concerned..he is also no less..if u remember seeing the earlier episodes where shilpa's mom questions him about his status and money..he was so dissappointed that even if Neil was not involved here...he would also go against ragini...maybe not immediately but he would have surely done it..and if not Ranbir..it would have been another guy..cos aarav was so madly in love with shilpa dat he was ready to cross all limits...just imagine when u have ur dad to support u financially..why would somebody go to babubhai..so desperate..so is this also neil's fault??? I'm not even getting into ragini and neil...just talk about nishi and aarav and filza is rite...blame d writers who have sketched their characters dis way

look no one is shifting the entire blame on natcheket here, the argument is that whether Neil's influence in his kids lives cause Nishi and Aarav to develop this bitterness towards Ragini.
neiralove thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#40
It's not Nachiket's fault that Nishi and Aarav idolize him; that's their problem. He never flaunted his wealth in front of the kids in a "look what I can give you that your mother can't" type of way. When he gifted Aarav the bike, he was fulfilling his son's birthday wish. However, Aarav took this a step further himself in arguing with Ragini that Nachiket is a better parent because he happens to have more money and can more easily satisfy his children's desires for material possessions. Nishi argued that Nachiket is a better parent because he agreed to what she wanted.

Now, Nachiket's fault lies in not correcting this attitude. Once he saw that Ragini's children were drifting away from her because of him giving them what they wanted, he should have sat Aarav down and made him understand that having a new bike and living a life of luxury also has its' downsides--Agam and Suhani could have told him about how they would struggle to get their father's love and affection. Same with Nishi: Nachiket should have explained to her that her mother was simply scared of Nishi's marriage falling apart like her own. That's why Ragini didn't want her to get married so early; however, he thinks that if she is ready to face any and all consequences resulting from the marriage, she is free to get married. Nachiket and Ragini had a difference in opinion on the matter, but that doesn't make one better than the other because their opinion agrees with Nishi/Aarav--the kids simply have to understand this.

Ragini always gave her children immense amounts of love and care, and did whatever she could with her limited resources to give them material possessions as well. Nachiket, on the other hand, gave his children material possessions instead of spending time with them. Ragini bakes a cake for Aarav on his birthday and stays up until midnight to celebrate with him, whereas Nachiket wasn't able to make it for Suhani's high school graduation party. There is simply a difference in what they prioritized in giving their children and what their children wanted. Ragini's children always longed for money, and Nachiket's children longed for love. Neither set of kids were completely happy with their parent pre-leap.

After the leap, it became clear that Nachiket was able to give his children love and time as well as monetary possessions. But Ragini, still stuck with the same job and lifestyle and being away from her children was unable to change for them (as per the script of the show)

Honestly, Nishi's blaming her mother for her problems is completely unjust. I seriously think this is just a plot gimmick to make Ragini feel attacked from all sides. As JB-US pointed out, Aarav did say that he wish he had listened to his mother and he wanted to prove himself to her once again and regain her trust. But his behavior post-leap has changed back to the "my mother is the sole cause of all of my problems" stance, which again, I think is simply a flaw of the writers rather than a legitimate shift in the character.

Finally, I do think Nachiket was wrong (and, frankly, out of character) when he took Aarav without telling Ragini in last night's episode. They both should have been there when Aarav came out, and given him the option as to who he wanted to go home with. Obviously NB would make him choose Nachiket, but at least Ragini would be aware of his feelings.

These are all just my opinions, and I don't mean to hurt anyone's feelings with them. Just thought I'd share my thoughts on the matter too 😊
Edited by neiralove - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".