Did Gul and team make ASR or was it Barun?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

coolnisha_fun87

@coolnisha_fun87

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: sun2011

Sanaya is a good acting coach - - and costar and she always gave Barun credit too!!!

I wish Barun had realized how precious Sanaya is after his MAMR stint with the other big screen actress who seemed bitchy to me!!!!

Sanaya is not a poor lady who has done a favour on Barun.

She got equal popularity.

If Barun had a good co star then even Sanaya had a good co star.

I think you should see Sanaya's interview for this.

Why Sanaya was feeling uncomfortable with BD if she is that great independent actress.That was because her co actor made her comfortable.

If you see BArun in BHPH he independtly proved that he is a good actor.

Though the chemistry which SaRun created neither Monaya nor Shravan-Sanchi could create.

And why should BArun just stick to Sanaya..for Sanaya Khushi character lacked nowhere..she was happy doing Khushi but BArun was not happy doing same thing again and again.Wy should BArun compromise his choice because Sanaya wanted to stick with IPK.

Both were individual and both had the rights to continue with their preference.

And for an actor its normal to work with different co-star.

Barun is not someone who will keep using his achievement throughout his career.

Quote

Zee

@aamir18

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#52

Gul created Arnav

Barun breathed life into Arnav.

Khushi brought out the best of Arnav

The creatives sketched Arnav

The director captured Arnav

They are all important

Edited by aamir18 - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shreya Patel

@spate22

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#53

It's called give and take!! 😊

Shreya

Quote

soniaanna

@soniaanna

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: chowna
I will give Gul credit to create a character on paper
i will give Barun credit to make that character a reality '
i will give credit to director who showed it through his lense th character of asr

Righly said ,it is the full team but no other actor would have done what Barun could do, so a little more weightage to BARUN

Quote

rini_kat

@rini_kat

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#55

The whole IPK team contributed in making this show an epic one...Here no one person is responsible...But I will give credit to Gul more as she is the creator of this epic story and sketching out the characters...

Quote

Sasha

@sarunsashasingh

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#56

he was never famous before as an actor.. thru this show he is.. hence all the credit goes to the creators and the entire team to bring him to this level of popularity and towards the end ditching all team for his selfish needs.. hats off to Barun🤡

For ur kind information, Barun became a house hold name from baat hamari pakki hai.

And IPKKND gave his popularity new heights, so think before u preach.

Edited by sondaryalakshmi - 12 years ago

Quote

pinkeye

@pinkeye

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#57

Every one should be credited for Arnav except the actor who gave his
best portraying the character for 1.5 years. do u knw why? becoz its
d biggest irony fr an worthless piece oe actor named Barun Sobti who
by fluke and by fanpower swept all d imp best actor awards along with
sme of industry biggies. He chose to move on frm a shw which ran its
course bt till date gets mocked, bashed in the name of reality check to
his fans. sad bt bitter reality of this forum.

we should realise dt he meant nthing fr d shw and shd nt be credited at
all as he did a grave mistake and shd be punished.

Quote

Ananya

@Anarocksick

Rocker

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#58

I've never actually seen such fine acting by anyone on television...movies maybe but nobody made me look into their eyes to looks for hidden emotions. The things Barun Sobti conveyed with his with eyes, the hidden emotion he let out, the unsaid things... Oh he din't even have to have a dialogue. I swear I could watch him act even it were a three-hour mute movie.

However...that being said, I did not watch his earlier Tv shows (not such a big fan of hindi tv shows), I tried to though. But neither the story-line nor the acting made me watch them except probably 2-3 scenes. That proves that the role(ASR's that is) definitely made a difference. Now that's where a well written script and good direction comes in.

But whatever said and done, there have been a lot of popular tv shows, with good looking men with passable acting skills, but never...never have I followed those show like a maniac. Even when IPK's ship was sinking, with a shitty story-line and character assassinations, it was nothing but Barun's acting which made hold on to it (No offence, Sanaya was pretty good too). And that is a pretty big thing for someone to say who once used to make fun of hindi tv shows (even the popular ones with hot men in them).

So I blame Barun for making me watch IPK, I blame him for creating ASR and making me fall in love the character.

Quote

rini_kat

@rini_kat

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: simim

I have...I have seen Mohit with her, and sorry to say...there was nothing there...

Barun made ASR the way he was. An angry man has been played sevral times on TV...but getting people to see the vulnerable side of a borderline negative character is what Barun did.

He did not have too many dialogues...he was not the loverboy to find instant connect...he did not have the assiatnce of comedy to make him loved.

He did everything he could to make the character believable, loved, and chersished, as one of the most iconic characters on TV.

I agree with the TM, that while good writing helps, poor presentation of that writing, often makes the writing go down the drain.

So for the ASR we loved for over 1.5 years...most of the credit muct go to Barun and Barun alone.

The success for the show goes to a lot of things other than Barun...but for the portrayal of ASR ...Barun needs to get the credit

Mohit's character is not on angry young man types...Angry young men were loved very much be in TV or in movie...Here ASR character is sketched very well...Even the story is told on his POV...He was given immense importance...I had watched Indian TV shows for over 12 years.I haven't seen any show where hero is given prime importance.atleast in daily shows...There may be angry young men before but they were not given much importance as ASR ...
I am not taking away credit frm BS...He definitely gave much more to ASR...But fact is that creatives,Gul, directors equally contributed to this epic character...may be much more... We only saw the scenes after so much edittings and many retakes... So we only seen the best of the scenes...

Edited by rini_kat - 12 years ago