Originally posted by: Nina90
Hi,
The story has some loopholes. See in the flashback where they have shown only once where Arnav's dad and mom talking before his mom commits suicide his dad says, "Rathna, you have mistaken." but she runs away and commits suicide. I think at that time it was Garima who had met Arnav's dad and maybe asking him for some help for the treatment of Kushi's dad who was involved in the accident a year earlier when Kushi's mom passed away. Dadi must have met Garima again under misconception of her being the other woman. And Garima fearing Dadi being all alone and needing to raise Kushi by herself succumbs to her threats and is stigmatised. I feel Arnav's dad was telling the truth about the woman his wife witnessed him meeting. So that is why Arnav might again accept the surname Malik as he finds out that the woman his mother thought to be other woman and committed suicide was not the real one and he might feel that his father was not given a chance by his mother to explain. But he had an affair with Shyam's sister where she(Shyam's sis) had voiced her insecurity to him (Arnav's dad) as shown by Arnav and Kushi in the last night's episode.
Does this fit?
Does she commit suicide? There are doubts on that, rulama... if it was suicide, why would Arnav's Dad commit suicide? If a year had passed before Garima came to meet the Maliks, Khushi would definitely remember her father, na?
No Kushi would have been told that he is dead along with her mother. But in reality he might be alive with memory loss or camatose or paraphlegic which would traumatise a child who would have adored her parents if the parent alive is not able to recognise her. So Garima might have told Kushi that he had passed away in the accident itself.
Arnav's mother committed suicide with the gun as a gunshot is heard. Arnav's dad must be coz he lost his property, his wife (though he might not have loved her), his OW who went against him in cahoot with his brother, his social standing in his society (as Dadi is so fond of aukat, he too must have been the same.) in other words barbadi who forgot he had two gems with him dependent on him.
Edited by rulama - 12 years ago