remarriage and its 'rightness'...note added pg 12 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

96

Views

8.8k

Users

37

Likes

266

Frequent Posters

riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: indi52


hey riti,
thanks dear for coming and being so full of praise for the writing 😆always too kind. you know, i did not want to rant, because this show is v v important to me. so i let it stay in me for a while. but 8 days on, i am still uncomfortable, so thought i'd say my bit. maybe some good will come of it. as you say, if asr gave khushi the wedding she dreamt of because he wanted to and it was done with asr taste, that would be quite something else, wouldn't it. i can imagine me like this😍 and this 😍 and this too 😍 for a very very long time to come.

Yeah Di , when ASR brought that suitcase for SR😆 ...Stupid me thought that it might have bridal dress that khushi wanted for her wedding and then Embarrassed she will be gettin dressed as bride and he will take her in front of devi maiyya and their parents and do ASRish wedding... do pheras like Sallu-Aish did in hum dil de chuke sanam...😆.. *SIGH* but I had imagine lot of things that never happend
indi52 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Vishkanya

That was so wonderfully articulated. To give legal status to marriages, most Indian states these days require you to register your marriage, no matter how many big, fat rituals you have. So, I think it doesn't matter so much if you missed a ritual or two. But that is just me.

But I am also troubled by how suddenly this marriage no longer being valid was brought up as a plot device and the whole chastity and good-Indian-girl notions got bandied around. I understand the viewership compulsions, but frankly, that is just being dishonest to your story. And this wedding is so half-arsed as of now (the bride won't even get fancy clothes), how is it going to even get appreciation with the fantasy audience??
A private ceremony - tum, main aur taare would have been memorable. Perfect. But then again, why am I seeking that in a daily soap which (understandably) puts viewership compulsions ahead of aesthetic storytelling.


hi vishkanya,
thanks for reading and your thoughts. in bold what troubled me and what would have been perfect. now most states recognise only registered marriages as you point out. so yeah, the most strictly observed rituals also don't give the nuptials legal validity till that paper is signed. but as we all agree, that's not the point. oh i so wish they could do something about it. you see the reason i still hope is because for almost one year iss pyaar ko has managed to stick to its different soul. lots of strange things have happened but the essence of the show, its uniqueness, has not gone away. maybe, just maybe, they'll find some way to out of this too. ummeed pe duniya, etc. 😆
indi52 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
quote riti4u:
Yeah Di , when ASR brought that suitcase for SR😆 ...Stupid me thought that it might have bridal dress that khushi wanted for her wedding and then 😳 she will be gettin dressed as bride and he will take her in front of devi maiyya and their parents and do ASRish wedding... do pheras like Sallu-Aish did in hum dil de chuke sanam...😆.. *SIGH* but I had imagine lot of things that never happend


awww, riti, that's cute. would have pleased khushi no end. but kya karey this man is after the real thing ha ha. bichara, convinced that he is he is alreadty her pati. how much we think about our show, surely something good will come of it.
..mrinalini.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: indi52


hey sam,
thanks for that. and boy, you are mean. me love it. need that drama, now that we know they're madly in love with each other, bring on the smile wipers. 😆


The thing is...I can't take too much of mush..Now though ASR and Khushi are in their respective characters..The whole marriage environment is too cheesy...So am secretely hoping for some hoopla..and with Dadi around and Shyam not far behind..is that too much to ask??!!😆

I want Arhi consummation in the most unique place possible..Not in a room decorated with candles and roses..That's so not done for me!!I can't see ASR applying Haldi..wearing a long Sherwani with that turban on his head(Is that a turban..I dunno..Am a Bengali...So can't say much in that matter)..ASR...I have an image in my mind of this character..And though it's still okay for me..The whole marriage thingy is kind of cheesy!!

Though I trust the CV's..They won't disappoint me!!😉
molten_lava thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
Even I wasn't in favour of remarriage. I mean is a big fat Indian wedding even necessary? For me Arhi was a unique couple who didn't require a traditional wedding. That was the whole beauty about their love. You don't need to have a big fat wedding to have a successful marriage. There are so many marriages in real world which were celebrated so grandly and then in the end, they reach a stage where the partners don't even want to see each other's face.

Honestly, I'm quite sick of seeing those month long SP weddings that make me cringe.
But in one way I have to appreciate the CVs. They are keeping all the rasams as short as possible and its all moving quick.

But I think the main reason for the remarriage was for TRPs. And that is the only reason why I have now accepted this idea. If a remarriage can sustain the serial, I have no problems with it. I don't want my only favorite show in the tv to be axed due to low trps.

Nice post!⭐️
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: sampin


The thing is...I can't take too much of mush..Now though ASR and Khushi are in their respective characters..The whole marriage environment is too cheesy...So am secretely hoping for some hoopla..and with Dadi around and Shyam not far behind..is that too much to ask??!!😆

I want Arhi consummation in the most unique place possible..Not in a room decorated with candles and roses..That's so not done for me!!I can't see ASR applying Haldi..wearing a long Sherwani with that turban on his head(Is that a turban..I dunno..Am a Bengali...So can't say much in that matter)..ASR...I have an image in my mind of this character..And though it's still okay for me..The whole marriage thingy is kind of cheesy!!

Though I trust the CV's..They won't disappoint me!!😉

Hey Sam...
Do you think this marriage will happen...😆..So many things hovering around these two...poor lovers just hope they elope and get settled in remote island away from everyone...
..mrinalini.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Hey Sam...
Do you think this marriage will happen...😆..So many things hovering around these two...poor lovers just hope they elope and get settled in remote island away from everyone...

I think the remarriage will happen..But the immediate married life won't be blissful!!😳
henamani thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
i have gone through everyone's mail and here is my POV. i have watched all the Arshi scenes from the beginning and my opinion is based on my evaluation ARNAV SINGH RAIZADA - behind the gruff exterior exists a child of 14 who was forced to grow up in the wake of tragedy and was dead afraid of losing someone he loved, which is why he told hi Di that if he ever finds his soul mate, he will stay away from her, which is what he did when he met Khushi. Khushi affected him from the word go and he did everything she asked him to do however grudgingly. Arnav has always been afraid to express his love and therefore during the La episode, he tried everything to make Khushi say the magical words first. when he realised that he cannot continue with La, he again tried to stay away from Khushi but was unable to do so. Khushi boke through all his barriers and when he finally opened up to her, the MU started and he went back in his shell.
even then he was unable to push her out completely and he felt her pain at every moment but as he himself said that the terrace scene was engraved in his mind, he could never free himself
when he was kidnapped, the reason of his ILU was the fear that he will never be able to see his love again and he did not want to leave without letting her know.
eversince he has come back, the only person who has cared abt him is Khushi; even though he lashed out on her (even here i can see his POV), he never wanted her to leave. but again his innate fear took hold of him and instead of trying to stop her with his love, he tried other tactics (read contract, rent fiasco etc)
i think he would never have expressed his love to Khushi if DADI had not appeared in the scene. remember that Arnav is very possessive. even if he hurts Khushi he cannot allow anyone else to do so. the hurried up SR was just an attempt by Arnave to 'seal the deal' so that noone could separate him from his Khushi
it is only now in the face of adversity (read DADI) that he has realised how much Khushi means to him and that he cannot let her go. the unconditional love that Khushi has showered on him has broken through all the walls that he had created around his heart and teh 14 year old boy is out in open bc he knows that his Khushi will never hurt him
P.S: normally i dont get any replies on my posts. i would appreciate if i had some comments on this one
payasa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
good post...

thanks riti4u for the pm... it is indeed a good post...

u are voicing many of our views...

every story has a different type of story telling. ipk story narration is quite different from others...everything from his hate,marriage, his regret, her love realisation is woven in the story itself..they didnot require a separate track like the one they r presently showing..
we have already repeated these sentiments many a times in different posts...
finally one thing to say is what u said...it is non-ipk type...done to please a section of viewers..

p.s-
Edited by payasa - 13 years ago
aadhirai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#20
i m sorry i can't see from your eyes

whatever may the reason we feel but the truth is that really he agreed for remarriage because kushi(being a girl of orthodox family and having enormous feelings about the rituals) feels that their marriage is incomplete


so its duty of asr to make her feel comfort in their relation so i think remarriage is justified

still don't agree recall the scene where arnav sees kushi being slapped where he says "i don't know why people are making this as issue
anyways you need know lets do it"


and after that he tell to buaji "i don't know why you people are making it as issue i want to finish this here itself by completing the rituals"

and some elder are like dadi only
we can't expect everyone to be like nani
this is what happening in day to day life of most of people who wants to balance their family without leaving anyone

i don't want to say whatever happening is right but i just want to say i agree with remarriage
so that she can get the most important thing of her life to happen at peak of happiness


Edited by aadhirai - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Minionite · 9 years ago

[NOCOPY] Salaam Namaste Friends! This is Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Creations Gallery #52 !! Congrats on completing Creations gallery #51 and

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".