The Apology -- Did it Hit the Mark? - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

262

Views

16.2k

Users

56

Likes

1.5k

Frequent Posters

Maverick29 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: -Aimz-

Glad to see a good debate going on in this Sobti Shrine.


Well, Maverick, let's just ask one thing: Did you expect it to hit the mark?
I, for one, did not.

Firstly, because I knew that this isn't some I-beg-thy-forgiveness track. It was a I-beg-thy-TRPs track. Oh yes, it was very much evident contrary to what you all thought you might spoon-feed the hungry audience.

Secondly- Come on! The intensity has long since been on a Baali trip. In fact, the intensity was all used up by that mutual "I hate you" dialogue by the poolside, or perhaps those super powers of the blue waters absorbed up the intensity. Whatever the case, I see no point in comparing the present scenes to the past ones, which would only be an insult to scenes such as the empowering rain one, the oh-so-touching Teej one or as you mention, the beautiful, heartfelt Gazebo one.

Thirdly (and oh you Phangirls, you can say "This is Sparta!" to me for this), along with the flimsy direction and sloppy screenplay, stands a failed characterization by Mr Sobti. I am forced to say, and forced because during those Diwali and Engagement tracks, I swear my drool glands used to work pretty hard, that Barun shows a I-just-got-bankrupted business tycoon, rather than a Doncha-mess-with me one. Do I need to mention the most awaited moment in the history of IPK, the "hair cut"? Boy, does he look greasy! No wonder Sanaya nowadays makes me wonder if I'm straight, the way that girl can pull of that goddamned wig and those hideous clips.


AWESOME!!! Spot on with everything. It is just may be that I dont have anything better to do so I am writing here! You are right, the old magic which by the way is only 6 months ago is not coming back till they decide to bring it back!

I think we have seen the business decision on "personnel" changes. So, no bringing back anything.

Cheers.
Maverick29 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: Harshitha

i like the term Sobti Shrine u all have coined lovely name for this forum, People are already discussing this thread which means mission successful people have read even if they dis - agreed



Sounds good Harshi! You are awesome in some of the responses -- I did not want to butt into those conversations!!!

Cheers.
monalisa1234 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: Maverick29


First I think the last remark is meant to be "tongue in cheek", if it is not -- unfortunately those guys will not be able to afford me. I am bit on the higher side for what they pay.

LOL! on "you are getting remarriage and redemption" -- we are not at the mercy of these morons. We are in fact being ultra nice in letting the have their jobs. At 2.5 and dropping if it goes below 2 ALARM BELLS will ring and there is no saving the show.

Yeah if it continues to NOT fit our expectations we will MOVE on to something else and the guys from the production house can move on doing whatever they do best since none of their other shows seem to be catching fire!!!

good debating as long as you dont get personal. If you force me to get personal, you will not like the results!!

Bang on Girl!!😊
I am struggling with my office project, at the same time keeping a constant eye on this thread...Hand is itching to type on, but unable to do the same as of now..
Maverick29 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: elope

why dont u write the script n act n hit the mark


LOL! For your sake I hope you are under 18. If you are, well I will just laugh it off as "she is still in love with the show and her precious Barun, so she will not like criticism".

If you are above 18, I feel sad for you on two counts:

1. You sound too stupid when you dont present an argument in an adult discussion. And that is sad.

2. If you man-up and start an argument, you will definitely be destroyed by any of the adults on this thread -- the thought of that also saddens me.

In all, you are just too sad!

Cheers though!
-SI- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: kookie2020

And at the end of the day it's the TRP that decides the future of any show on TV.
Consumer power dammit.
We are not the judgmental police here.



Can' u remember? TRP's r fake kookie..lol... If he write it, at least there will be some logic!!!..but wait a minute this is just a fiction... Loved your post dammit...
OmNaMaSteOm thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: godhuli12



Ok now I having another more sadistic wish ( I will b crashed like hell) ..
Someway Khushi also can give him a tight slap.. in some situation.. whatever..

no may b it would b too much.. ( i myself will fall) ..
but i want khushi's all sacrifices to come out as soon as possible..
I want to see a situation where every member of the family can tell arnav " How could you do that?"
just one full episode .. he should experience what it feels being khushi ..

specially payel-akash-mami they should know and akash should scold arnav for that..
and of-course shaym' truth .. ( when it will happen God knows)..
My next slogan will be restoration of khushi's dignity to full form..
until then I will bad mouth the CVs...😆

i will love this just replace the 1 epi of asking ASR in a 1 week.actually i wanted a month but then that would too much for the CV's to handle - i would love that

Edited by Harshitha - 13 years ago
Maverick29 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: zoharocks

i dont agree...man after all the moments they have shared this apology was not meant to be really hi-fi...the first apology case was the first one and because at that time they weren't that close didn't know each other this well he had to make it perfect...but this time he knew that a simple one would do because now khushi understands him better, feels for him better and now that the remarriage track is coming why are we still cribbing...lets just wait and watch because we all actually have always got more than expected...luv arhi luv sarun...👍🏼 the cvs


Now here is a point I would like to debate --

So you are saying you apologize more to a person you dont know but when they know each other there is no need for an apology!!!

So, you are proposing that "familiarity breeds contempt" holds in this case.

See the problem with your argument is -- so when he didnt know her, he just insulted her once.

But when he got to know her better he insulted her multiple times and he doesnt even have to apologize for it.

I hate to be your best friend -- he/she might be a very sad person because you believe in not apologizing and also in insulting people that are closest to you!!!
Maverick29 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: jainneha

srry i disagree first this is nt the real apology the real apology would be no short of epic and what did u say bs nt looking gud disagree he is overworked he works 12 hrs a day and now more and abt khushi forgiving him plz man it is nt gud to hold grudges it not only harms u more than the other person do more resentment it is like a poison eating up insides and every scene cannot be tailormade chill guys and believe me we are in for a rocky ride ahead so keep the faith keep rocking bs and sanaya all the best😃


I would be lying if I said I understood what you said. But I got a couple of points so I will address them and they may be misinterpretted because I didnt understand the whole thing you said.

Are you saying that since he is working 12 hours a day, he cannot muster up the strength required to apologize? I dont think that would be a good excuse for not talking to your wife.

As for Khushi forgiving him -- that is well within her character as shown -- she does not hold grudges.

But to repeat myself, the whole point of an apology is to convince the other side that you have understood "How" you caused pain and a promise that you will not repeat it!

Hope that makes sense -- we are just saying that this apology did not show that.
Superthree thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#99
Don't confuse issues the apology was grt beautifully enacted. Passion is always there simmering between these two, now gradually love and respect have crept in from a better understanding of each other..the gentleness comes from that and it was fantastic!,,,


applesauce. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

As he was apologising for his mistakes the editing team could have incorporated the flashbacks..and the moment could have lingered more in time..I think their in hurry to move towards shaadi day and thats for trp reason.I wont be surprise if they drag that day for two weeks.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".