IP REDUX; Nutcracker !! - Page 115

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

75.3k

Users

75

Likes

6.6k

Frequent Posters

sharmibalan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: IndigoBlues

Well, we've already seen him bring out the lioness inside her...😉

🤣🤣🤣🤣
Arhimaniac thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tanthya



He will turn her into that ..a consort equal to him ...


@bold
This is what is actually meant by the promo dialog...keh main tumhian Mrs.ASR bana ker hoon rahoon ga😳
SunoNa123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: iritz



As much as I understand Khushi's nature and the fact that it was in her character to have gone to Anjali to soothe her... I too felt it was very insensitive of her to have told her, just a day after the woman's life is shattered and she doesn't even know why or how... you tell her to forget him and move on... You need to give a person some time to get over the shock and mourn the grief.

Again, Arnav was in character too when he lashed out on Khushi... and the fact that he soon realized his mistake and regretted makes him a little better... For Khushi doesn't realize when she's at fault.

It was when Arnav told her in the middle of the road, on the way back to RM from GH, that she realized for the first time that not speaking out at the time, was a mistake on her part... Not that if she had spoken then, anyone would have believed her ! But then, at least her conscience would be clean.

They are humans (ok... not really... but then they are supposed to be humans) and humans make mistakes... both justified somehow, both unjustified somehow... That's what them make humans !!!


ur so right. And moreover khushi wud be the last person anjali wud wanto see now, and hear to move on about Shyam frm this very girl on whom her husband lusts on??

I hope somebody steels Kushi's fix it all glue and she learns she is nt right always.

tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: nancynair

I would also say Tants that I did not like ASR refusing professional help from doctor at the clinic initially,

Anji needs medical attention first and foremost and not the let her be attitude of RM vaasis now

It is heartbreaking for family when initially a family member goes into severe depression which is a medical condition

They themselves need guidance and counselling at this stage for the patient can do anything including harming her self more so in Anji's case when there is a family history




I think Nancy..Arnav understood that Anjali needed him and not a Gynec ...Had she been a Psychologist ..I would have agreed with You..But Arnav knows how to handle his hysterical sister and not a Gynecologist ...

Anjali needs counseling but not when she is rebelling passively... Her rebellion breaks down when she asks Arnav to get Shyam back..That is when ..family shud have rallied around her ...
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: redwine1


Hey Riti ..

Remember the scene when she first finds out the truth about Shyam .. she meets ASR .. he points out the problem .. she wants to tell him but she stops simply because she knows of his dedication to Di ...

Then the next time around ..she wants to tell him .. she hears his Di is going to have a baby .. she was again justified in hiding it from him .. coz the truth at that point of time would have destroyed Arnav .. & isn't that exactly what happened ( but ofc she dint know about it )

NOW FOR THE MAIN INSIGHT ... all the times she HID about Shyam .. was ONE REASON ONLY ... her LOVE for the one MAN ASR ... the moment he tells her i know .. she says it out ...
I woman in LOVE .. makes a decision based on her emotions .. not necessarily what on hindsight may look right or wrong ...

BUT for the WOMAN in LOVE .. protecting her LOVE from GRIEF & BLOW .. would've been paramount ... 😃

Now yet again .. this is how i read Khushi .. this was what she always spoke out .. i did it for U

Sweetheart loved the way you explained...and believe me I get what her intentions were but in life
there are situations where you have to deal with practical decisions rather than emotional ones...
she saw true colors of shyam that night...she saw lust..she saw deceit..what made her think that she can take decision on anjali's life by keeping her and her brother in dark about it... I always maintain that it was not her secret to keep... but I do understand that it was only HER love for this man that led her to make this decisions... so I get her..😳
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago


For the rest .. aren't circumstances the biggest villains of the piece ???


I get your point Ruby but then why blame the man!? So in a way she did lead Shyam on right!? Ny not taking any action against him!

She the one who stands up for herself against the mighty ASR - fights with him - contradicts him - cannot stand up for herself. And when Arnav throws the same thing at her - he is judged!? Why!? Was he wrong in saying that!? He was not! He cannot have a dream that Khushi did not lead Shyam but was forced.

I dont like the guy being blamed for all the mistakes. We are discussing a possibility here. Maybe Khushi could not go and confess anything - because she is Khushi - but there was never any regret - any thought of even letting anyone know. It does not matter whether she did not confess to anyone - the thought counts. I am sorry but "mitti daalo" was the nail in the coffin for me. More so the man lusted her in front of his wife - but there was never a thought!?

COming to Gupta ladies
- biggest disappointment on planet earth! Payal - Garima and Buaji - knowing Shyam is in the same house - they never questioned Khushi!? I mean what is wrong with that family!? Whatever it is I am sure no family - would want their daughter to be in the same house with a man like Shyam. True they could not do anything about it - but they could show some concern.

My point is I dont see a character growth at all - neither did I see it before - nor do I see it now. I am hoping it happens soon though - because I cannot see Arnav or Anjali being blamed for Khushi's so called righteousness.


Darling .. read the last bit of my post ..

.. aren't circumstances the biggest villains of the piece ???

I am with you completely ... there is ONLY ONE WRONG IN THE SERIAL .. SHYAM MANOHAR JHA ... the rest all are victim of the circumstance they have been in at the point of time ...
U r Fan of ASR ... baby .. ASR is patterned on me ..😉 ( at least thats what i feel) .. so i dont blame him either ..

MY point for a long time here is ... why r v looking for more villains of the piece
One day it is ASR ..
One day it is Anjali ..
One day it is Khushi ...

They all are humans reacting to a situation in front of them .. in the best way they understand ..

Does ASR .. have to be wrong for KHUSHI to be right .. NO they can both be RIGHT OR WRONG ... 😃

Edited by redwine1 - 13 years ago
Nina90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Nareshkota



I don't think they feel she is right...Otherwise they won't show many-a-time Arnav winning over her..

It's not about who is right it's about consequences of your actions and learning from them..



@Bold: I agree, but how much has Khushi learnt? True, she feels bad, she sheds a few tears and then back like a boomerang. I do love her banging back into her cheery mode; I get her because its been my policy all my life but one thing that pricks me is that if she is so righteous she should also learn from her every mistake and it shouldn't take her so long.

Nareshkota thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Arhimaniac


@bold
This is what is actually meant by the promo dialog...keh main tumhian Mrs.ASR bana ker hoon rahoon ga😳



Hope he will be highly successful..
Nia.D thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: --Anna--



I get your point Ruby but then why blame the man!? So in a way she did lead Shyam on right!? Ny not taking any action against him!

She the one who stands up for herself against the mighty ASR - fights with him - contradicts him - cannot stand up for herself. And when Arnav throws the same thing at her - he is judged!? Why!? Was he wrong in saying that!? He was not! He cannot have a dream that Khushi did not lead Shyam but was forced.

I dont like the guy being blamed for all the mistakes. We are discussing a possibility here. Maybe Khushi could not go and confess anything - because she is Khushi - but there was never any regret - any thought of even letting anyone know. It does not matter whether she did not confess to anyone - the thought counts. I am sorry but "mitti daalo" was the nail in the coffin for me. More so the man lusted her in front of his wife - but there was never a thought!?

COming to Gupta ladies
- biggest disappointment on planet earth! Payal - Garima and Buaji - knowing Shyam is in the same house - they never questioned Khushi!? I mean what is wrong with that family!? Whatever it is I am sure no family - would want their daughter to be in the same house with a man like Shyam. True they could not do anything about it - but they could show some concern.

My point is I dont see a character growth at all - neither did I see it before - nor do I see it now. I am hoping it happens soon though - because I cannot see Arnav or Anjali being blamed for Khushi's so called righteousness.




On a light note, Khushi is a late bloomer... It's always Arnav first who realizes, grows and changes, while Khushi takes triple that amount of time to understand, develop, and grow... even with their 'love' - it was Arnav who first recognized it... Khushi came about it only just a few months back when he was kidnapped!!

So, she'll realize her mistakes only much later on... my poor lil Khushi - a late bloomer! 😆
--Anna-- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Nia.D


Agreed.. like I said in my post.. ASR mostly reacts when a trigger is present... till then he normally snaps curtly 😆

Also, I could sense the disappointment with Khushi that he had, that she - the girl who is his strength right now, was the one to go and spoil things for his wrecked sister... it was more of him feeling let down by Khushi's action...



Heyya Nia! 😳

Havent read your take ya! Havent read anything till now today! And replied to your PM - FINALLY! 😳

Yes it was the disappointment! When Nani asked Khushi to stay away from RM Arnav did not like it - but he understood that both he and Khushi need to stay away from Anjali. He was disappointed because at this time he is in between the sea where he has to maintain both his relationships - his wife and his sister. The condition that he saw Anji in devastated the brother in him and when he came to know that the wife on who's support he is holding strong could be the reason for that condition - he reacted. Was he wrong!? No. Dont we take out our frustrations at the one we love the most!? 😳



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".