IP REDUX; OO-THA-HELL-O

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Supna9

@Supna9

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

Updated
Hi Sathya its very difficult 4 me to comments ur post 4rm mobile bcz when i sit n doing this sab k post merey brain me mixture ho jatey hyn aur me confuse ho jati hun aur agr kuch post ko quote karun tou wo code k saath hotey hyn aur phir wo bura lagta hy . Is there any solution 4 it.
Nw back to my bak bak on show.
Sathya really excellent analysis. N 2 da point. Yest epi's plot was weak they done story to move but with making so many lame excuses. Loved arhi confrontation. Yeah arnav n payal bonding. But yest i was irritated with payal. N ye anjali blind trust in her husband uuff.
Hi Doods,
tussi menu dil khush kr dita. Dil wich thandak pe gayi. U criticized on them lovely they need more.
About epi n other things i asked u questions what step nw they take 4 their story to move n about trp how they can increase ? Again u both did "TANTDOODASTIC" Job.
Hi pam, nw read ur post. Pam liked how u described about payal n kkg principles n stickness on their princ. N about arnav how n why he wanna win win just win. Really wonderful. But disagree that kkg said him dhokabaz in 1 hand i agreed n on other nt. Kkg did wrong when ever she says her husband sumthing wrong infront of others people outside of family its really feels bad. What ever they wanna say each other wrong or bad they say it infront of them nt others. Yeah he is dhokabaz nt only 4 kkg but also with him. He nt realise his emotions or hide it himself its really cheating. Bhai apne inner me tou tasleem kr lo k wo tumharey liye important hy.
hi anna,
read ur analysis its really nice . Can nt say more bcz i mention my problem above.

Edited by Supna9 - 13 years ago

Quote

kpk1002

@kpk1002

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

Great post 👏 Loved your analysis and the way you pick up on the tiniest of details and use the, to explain complicated stuff!!

Ok now, where to start!? The first part of the episode was just time pass and I didn't want to sit and watch that stuff so I forwarded it. Guess I didn't miss anything😊 The rest of the episode had me confused,fascinated, irritated, creeped out, and then finally disgusted.

What confused me was exactly why Khushi passed on the trophy. Was it

1- because of the sob story Payal told her about the other contestant...in which case, much as I love Khushi, I think she is nuts!! There was no guarantee that that MIL and DIL would be the ones who won. Bikram and Baital were pretty good too!😕

2-because of ethical reasons...Nani couldn't take part so hubby stepped in...this to me would make sense...though the dhokebaaz thing I still don't get😳

3-because she "didn't want to give any credit" therefore doing a tit-for-tat

Then I was fascinated...by Mami's acting, which I enjoyed and then by the Green room confrontation between Mr and Mrs Raizada. I really think Khushi has had it upto her eyeballs with his secrecy about his reasons for marrying her and his blow hot/blow cold attitude towards her. Now the battle between them is between two equals, I think, because she is no more the highly emotional, easily hurt Khushi. She has grown and matured and knows how to give as good as she gets.

Anjali just irritated me completely and the reasons for that are ones you mentioned in your post. Why does hubby need a nursemaid? Why does he need a human navigation system? Why can't she accept help from her family members when she is expecting? She says that they will worry, so what? Isn't that what family is for? To help when you need help, to take care of you when you don't feel well? What does she plan to do when labor hits? Not tell anyone and ask Khushi and hubby dear to deliver the baby?😡

The reason for me getting creeped out is obvious. Snakeman of course🤢 This guy is getting sicker by the minute and even though Khushi recognized this after the whole oil massage thing, she is still not actively doing anything about it. It's like she can sense danger, see it, smell it and even taste it, but she still doesn't want to safeguard against it!! The creep carries on in front of the pharmacist about how he loves her and wants to look after her etc., etc., and she just looks at him!! She does finally respond, but as I posted somewhere else, I think she waited too long. Shouldn't she have just cut him off as soon as he started? Who cares what the pharmacist thinks? He is a stranger and will remain a stranger after she leaves the pharmacy!! I wanted her to be more on guard and ready with sharper responses and put downs, so I have to admit I was disappointed 😔

The precap left me disgusted. The creep is now openly daring to touch her!!! In front of family, in front of strangers 🤢 I know this will get the story moving, but as a woman,I have to say that enough is enough. Not to the CVs. They are doing this to move forward. But to the character Khushi. What is it going to take for her to see the snarling animal in front of her and take action? Maybe she will tomorrow...at least that is what I hope, but forget Arnav and everything else. A married man who has betrayed you and your family and still stalks you is going well past limits, isnt it time to call in reinforcements? Maybe send some smoke signals or SOS messages. As Arnav rightly told her "tum har cheez apne aap nahi kar sakthi"!!!!

Sorry for the long rant, but this episode got me all riled up. I am all for MUs and moving forward, but please show the characters thinking, planning, unravelling, digging...in short, show them actually trying to figure out what is happening around them and how to set things straight.

Edited by kpk1002 - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Pooja

@poolovesarnav

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

Super duper awesome post :) :) :)

Quote

Arnav_Fan

@Arnav_Fan

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

Thank you again for a detailed analysis, Tanthya! 👏

I do have a comment about Arnification of Khushi - Not sure CVs are really showing it in the way they intended, or maybe I looking at it skewed. Because, ASR never berated Khushi publicly about something that he knew that Khushi did rightly or for right reasons. In today's episode, CVs portrayed Khushi publicly declaring that because her husband cheated that is why they cannot accept the prize. Khushi knows very well that ASR did no such thing. Wouldn't it be better to give a her a line like "Raizada are just happy to participate and we don't want the prize money and would like someone else to win"? Or some such line?

Quote

Sofna

@Sofna

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

🥳🤪 From 3/4th position to 10th???🥳🤪 ...

Yaaay... Even TRP viewers are BORED of this dragfest...🥱👎🏼...

I hvn't watched epi...dzn't look like will b missing much.....will just do with analysis on this thread...🤗...to keep my interest intact...

Thank U ALL who watch epi, n give such awsoem feedback...esp Tanths...who opens thread EVERYDAY...🤗⭐️⭐️⭐️

Quote

Filmyshilmy

@dennisdmenace

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

awesome post Tant 👏👏👏👏👏

my POV:

i would like to term todays episode as the return of IPK( on d lighter note). just a small request to d CVs, pls dont slow down or distract d track now.

i would not like to bash d other skits like Vikram-Betaal, salim anarkali, gabbar etc. d only reason behind is if all were not there we wud have said why did they show only 2 skits in a competition.

Absolutely loved d Payal ARnav scene. there is a gradual progression in this relationship. first Payal offers ginger tea to sooth Arnav's throat which he readily accepts. today he stands like a brother next to a crying payal offering his silent support. so the day Raizada family faces d trith even if Akash moves away from Payal it will be Arnav who will stand like a pillar and sort out everything.

green room scene: Khushi brilliant here. Asr tastes his own medicine. how do you feel when d person you r speaking to refuses an answer? how does it feel to hear that mujhe aapko jawab nehi dena hai... aapka ehsaan nahi chahiye from d person who has become your dhadkan. without whom he feels breatheless. Khushi has understood ASR more than herself ...kehneko heer par dil se Ranjha.....she has figured out that ASR needs to be thrown out his comfort zone, then only he is going to blurt out d truth. and she has started on her mission whether in full conscience or not but she has started pushing him to the edge. now it is to be seen how far ASR can resist in pouring his heart out. iss pyar mein kuch sahi galat nehi hai... may be before he is absolutely sure of Khushi's innocence he might confess.

@ doodleberry, loved ur bit of advice to Star Plus and 4 Lions. really dont know what were they thinking about d future tracks. and you r right. they have already lost a chunk of audience . bringinging them back duting this IPL madsness is going to be a tough job. as asual brilliant analysis.👏👏👏

@ Pam, grt job. never really strike me that Arnav is d last person to show a physical support to Khushi. i absolutely agree wth you on this.

Edited by mouramen - 13 years ago

Quote

showstruck

@showstruck

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

It was a superb happy reading Doodle as you gave it back to 4 lions and SP. They should feel ashamed for cheating us on our loyalty and time.

Reading both of yours analysis, can't help but looiking forward to the upcoming episodes.

Gutur..like your style too...

Edited by showstruck - 13 years ago

Quote

Jaya

@pink.lotus

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

the way the MUs stacked one upon the other.. was almost like the wedding day.

payal gets patao'ed by another kraakadayl teeyers, why cant she just faint away and escape the whole ordeal! payal, your silence cost us audience to suffer through another round of the exact same drama! 😡

poor manorama mami (never thought i would say this, but today I actually felt sad for her!)excellent, excellent uttraksha Ji.👏

payal telling khushi.. and honestly, for the gupta sisters, the money-is-tight situation is intimately familiar. forget the fact that it is a virtual stranger who "needs" money, but the gupta sisters cannot ignore such a plea for help. 😭

and khushi wins.. so trying to convince the judges that she does not deserve to win (what do you thin of contestants and judges discussing the prizes backstage?)😕 and borrows her husband's recent sentences... it was an act.. it was impromptu.. he was not the original participant on the roster... so it is technically cheating..BTW how come the compere suddenly knows her full name and is repeating it till it is ringing in my ears??? Mrs Raizada was plenty enough for a random stranger!👎🏼

and Arnav overhears,pulls her into the magical empty dressing room . and asks her, why??
I came to help you.. then why don't you want to win? when you deserve this? ASR cannot understand how anyone would want NOT to win😲.. he is not made in that style..

she feeds him his own medicine.. she has learned a lot from him about the proper way to get angry..why? does it make any difference to you? 😈
I don't think its important that i tell you the reason. the exact sentence he used on his wedding night.

and he's mad. "dont you dare talk to me like that"... why? what will you do? throw things? manhandle me? meh. old stuff.. I've grown used to your tantrums Mr. Raizada, i'm not scared of you.. and I'm not gonna tell you😡

.but then, he asks,I did this favor for YOU... and she picks that reason, okay.. that IS the reason. I don't want any favors from you... and poor him, accepts her answer.💔 and walks out(ok, storms out.. after all, he is ASR.)

and stupid, stupid khushi. and di. a pregnant woman is feeling dizzy. the drama for the show is over.. why can't they go home? why can't she run and call nani, mami, etc to attend to the abla naari? why the hell can't she tell sham to go find a pharmacy himself? khushi cannot go out in the night, but sham can.. or, akash, mama, uff. GRRR.😡

quote from an IF post (forgot which): they decided that the best idea was to leave the dizzy lady alone in a room and leave, without telling anyone!

and suddenly , arnav's phone which died before the show, came back to life.. and he called Di to hear her lies. 👎🏼

won't touch the sham scene ☢️with a ten foot pole..you have made excellent commentary already.

EDITED TO ADD

doodles, thanks for the way you phrased your review. made me see the sense and senselessness at work in the PH ,SP and the storyline.

is it really so much work to write out a believable screenplay? especially by people who get paid for it?

why do we have to resort to mindless cliches to drive a point.. anjali got dizzy, sent sham with khushi.. could have happened when they were near the raizada clan.. maybe minus arnav, to add credibility.

is it so much work to rotate the extras so that the same one is not put in a prime spot as different characters?

is it so much work to assure that the actors have blooper-free dialogues, at least?

Edited by guturgutur - 13 years ago