Barun is still not that good as ASR

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

JennyPenny

@JennyPenny

Elite

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#101

I think everyone needs to understand two simple lines from Tu Bata Mer Maula.

Ek Baat use mein bhi and ek baat use mein bhi hai. Basically Sanaya and Barun are two different actors, with two different characterizations, but both have something that the other one lacks, that's why when they come together, they create a powerpack chemistry and performance. It is usually when they both have a scene together, this forum is flooded with their posts.

Sanaya has GROWN so much from Fanaa, LRL, Radha, and MJHT and Barun has also grown and yes, there is room for improvement on both sides.

Quote

AnotherAdmirer

@AnotherAdmirer

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#102

IMO this topic has done a great damage to the camredrie between sanaya fans and Barun fans .

The Arhi magic will be lost if we forget to appreciate each other .

Wise words..but its not just this topic, dont wish to dig deeper, Will Let it all be gone, i guess and Hope with time things would be fine on both ends. With that pleasant thought in Mind, I wish you Good Nite and Sweet dreams :)

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Nayab

@Lavarnia

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#103

Originally posted by: Ipepe
When the show started,he was criticized to quite an extent and though I didn't agree with people who said he was expressionless even I thought that he needed to improve and of course he did but still I feel that there is something missing,he has to keep quiet most of the time and hence it is more important that he learns to convey what he is feeling without dialogues and through his eyes.
I am not saying he is bad because that would mean that I feel he spoils the scene which he does not.I am just saying that sometimes he is just average(harsh? lol I am sorry I was thinking of some other word and edited the sentence 2 times but couldn't think of anything else)

I am disagree with you😉.😉.I think that Barun is really good, and the best choise to play ASR.👏👏 His expression are good too😳😳.. I really dont think that something is missing😃...I think he is quiet, becuase us ka role hi aisa haai..😉..He is not like Khushi, (dont get me wrong here i am khushi/shanaya fan too)😉

I really hope that, they who thinks that something is missing, finds it in you very soon.⭐️

I love you Barun Sobti/ASR😳😃😛

Quote

momma1128

@momma1128

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#104

@TM -

I think people are finding that your topic was not well intentioned. The title of your thread could have been 'Barun is not too bad as ASR' but instead you chose 'Barun is still not too good as ASR'. Both mean the same, connotation is totally different and I think it rubbed people the wrong way. People in the BHPH forum were well aware of the conversations around 'BS' that went on before this forum opened up, so I hope you can understand if certain people have hit the end of their patience with his criticisms.

Much in the way that you are a fan of Sanaya, I am of Barun. I think you have to understand the reason why people are bringing up BHPH, is because you are making a case that he needs improvement in expressions - and if you watch BHPH you will see it is not because he does not know how to do them.

If you go back and read one of Barun's interviews, he has said that he has to do multiple takes as ASR because he has to keep a straight face for everything. ASR is very difficult for him to play. Given this information, I think whatever shot and look we are given from the director on our tv screen is precisely the expression Nissar wants to portray in ASR. Or else why not give us the take where Barun shows a little bit of humanity in ASR. So I think, you might want to send something to 4 Lions asking them to stop shooting ASR as a man of stone...although, I believe that is exactly what they are going for.

I think we are forgetting about the director here and his hand in what we see. For example, we know Sanaya's acting ability - so why is it that so many of us felt that she was acting like a child, instead of the bubbly young woman she is supposed to be when she came to the Raizada house the first time and in her first day at the office?? (check back and see - topics abound on this). It is not that she is an OTT actress, the director quite obviously wanted to hit us over the head with what kind of different worlds ASR and Khushi came from.

I think I have been fair is my response to you and hopefully you will think about ASR in a different way. I also hope that if someone has criticisms of Sanaya's acting, everyone here who has said it is fair to critique actors will take it sportingly, although I have my doubts as what I have seen in this thread is that saying Barun is lifeless and blank is okay criticism/opinion, but someone's similar opinion saying Barun overshadows Sanaya is deemed unfair. (look back - you will see it)

I love this jodi because of their chemistry. Chemistry is not one sided. It can only work when the couple's acting complement each other.

Peace

Edited by momma1128 - 14 years ago

Quote

ChocolateChick

@ChocolateChick

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#105

Anu, all I can say is this:

👏👏👏

And oh yes, this, for you know who 😉:

👏

Quote

Sunaina Mitra

@sunaina02

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#106

Anu - you always say things wisely and I like to lose my head in IF.😆

Quote

hkhb17

@hkhb17

Voyager

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#107

Anu, very well said!!!! 👏👏👏

I think whether we are Barun's fans or Sanaya's fans, it is immaterial. Right now they are acting well depending on the role they are essaying and their chemistry rocks on screen and off screen.

Let us enjoy the show!!!!

Quote

Nadia

@naddiya26

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 14 years ago

#108

he is doing great job loved his acting...

Quote

ktms

@ktms

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#109

first of all let me rofl for something that all sabzi's are aware off 🤣

completely agree to each word of yours anu!! Barun is delievering what his director wants from him and if some of them need barun to be more expressive then nissar is the man to contact.

Quote

MSA_SUD

@MSA_SUD

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

#110

I love how Barun plays ASR and the subtle way of expressing. That makes ASR unique. Credit also go to the director on his vision on ASR.

I think people (who find issues in Barun's acting) are comparing with other "young angry man" kind of characters played in Indian Television. People should understand ASR is different from them. Infact, I feel more a real life touch in ASR

ASR is not supposed to be an open book for others to read what is going in his mind. When ASR falls in love and he slowly changes, we may see more obvious expressions. Till then, I just want Barun to continue what he is doing now, which is excellent and what attracts me more to the show..