Mere Shivvay - Part 3 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

3.4k

Users

19

Likes

229

Frequent Posters

farinaks thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#11
Amazing post
I do agree wid u ...He isn't dong anything wrong ...like u said he jzt wanna protect her frm his mother nd diz harsh world
Edited by farinaks - 8 years ago
Sakkiyah thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#12
Totally agree with you...
Shivaay only wanted to know her background.It will never change the truth she is his wife.He whole heartly accepted her.
But she misunderstood his words and leave him.But Shivaay know her condition now.She was shattered after hearing that words.


--Risha-- thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#13
Asya good post. Why Shivaay is doing what he's doing... To me it's still unclear. Right now I think it's sort of like an itch caused by long standing views that he needs to scratch. What you said about him having to answer to the world, it makes sense. Still, am not fully convinced because we know he'll begin to hesitate more and more once he starts digging her past.

But yeah, I don't think he's doibg this for Anika but I also don't think he's doibg something out of character. I mean the whole point of this track is to show him his thinking is wrong. As Anika said, "kia insaan kee apnee koi pehcgaan nahee hotee?" "Kia hum bhagwaan jee se unka surname poochtey hain?" And so on.

So I feel like, as of now, Shivaay is doing excellently well. So many times I thought he'd not come back and he did. <3 He's clear that Anika belongs with him and vice versa. Anika, on the other hand, is acting weaker but even that I don't find out of character. She's grown up expecting the worst from life. I'm nit surprised she never truly believed it'll last.

So as of now - I don't think either Shivaay or Anika are acting out of character. apart from a few things here and there *cough* Obros scene *cough*, the track seems great to me.
asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: nim_var

Pearl... nice posts the last few days...

Truly he is going to sweep all the awards...Shivika are...for sure... Yep! they sure are 😉

Now..Shivaay wanting to find the truth about her parentage is to shut his mother up..so that she does not say those hateful things about his Anika. He needs those facts as a weapons to hurl at those who dare to point a finger at his wife. Period...so the quest for the truth on her behalf.. he had made peace with all that Sahil had revealed about his parents..
Exactly. How can he defend her and protect her if he does not know what he is up against. Besides, she is now THE OBEROI bahu of the heir apparent so if her past is dug up by the rivals or the media to make it juicy how would that make Annika feel when she sees it flashed on 'breaking news' one fine morning.
Till she was a lower middle class girl her struggle with her lack of background was fought with at that level. Now as his wife she will be one of the most sought after people for the media to get scoop on and write about. Shivvay has to ensure that he gets to the bottom of this before anyone else does. It was what she signed up for when she first announced that she was his wife. She has to understand the compromises and adjustments that come with it just as he has adjusted to her.


She could not grapple with the fact that Shivaay chose her over his NKK which was so imp to him. She was looking for the easy way out as that is what she was prepared for...
The minute Annika told everyone about her being an orphan she went on auto pilot as far as I saw.
She was emotionally distraught, kept looking at Shivvay for the signs of him feeling upset, generally broke down recounting things she has spoken about in the past with a calm and controlled voice and began adopting a defeatist attitude towards her whole situation. In short she had already decided to be judge, jury and hangman where he was concerned.

You are right about her looking for an easy way out and that is exactly what I said. She misinterpreted his conversation not because of what he said but because of what he so badly wanted to hear.
It was as though she could not digest the fact that he proved her wrong and that he came back to the room and still stood by his word that she was his wife.

As far as she knew and what she knew about Shivvay should have made him abandon her and end their relationship and marriage!!! How could he stand there so calmly and accept what she had said about her being an orphan!!??

So hence in her head there was a trick to this and he was only saying it to pacify her and pull the wool over her eyes. Shivvay choosing her over NKK was downright unbelievable and hence it must be a ploy on his part to hoodwink her.
I can see why she feels that way. It is because all her life people have mostly shunned her because of this fact and now here was 'The Shivvay Singh Oberoi' calmly walking back into their bedroom and reiterating firmly that she WAS still his wife


Loving this week so far...

Edited by asya34 - 8 years ago
IntrovertedDame thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#15
Lovely post, Pearl. You said it all!
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16
Yes finally someone else said it. Am so glad that we are on the same page in regards to why it is important for him to find that info out.it is not to accept her that he did already the way she is but basic bg knowledge to stop the insults to make sure tommorrow she will not have to hear the taunts and bakwaas of the world that if needed she has answers .
asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: --Nargis--

Res...Un res!! 😛


Asya...lovely post and excellent points. I am totally in agreement with everything you said. He wants simply to know...and there is nothing wrong with that at all. He has already chosen her, he has said it repeatedly that she is is wife, and nothing can change that...and he told his mother that as well. By going to Chanda's and bringing her back, his actions have proven it too...its not just words...its the reality...she is his wife...they will have arguments and both may get mad, but that needs to remain between the two of them in the house...she cannot leave him...he will not allow her to leave him...to leave what they have!!
Yes. She needs to understand that she needs to stay and not take flight at the slightest sign of him changing or questioning something about her. She is digging into Mahi's life and it's connection with Shivvay's but we don't see him fleeing the house in an angry huff!!!??
If he wants to find out about her she should not label it as him judging her on the basis of that. The man has already said she is his wife a dozen times over now and never abandons her to fight her battles alone. So she too needs to ask him - not question him grudgingly- why does he want to find out about her past. Fair is fair I feel.


As for not telling Annika that he is trying to find out her background...like I said before, he is not one to share with anyone...untill he absolutely has no choice. He may very well not find anything, and think of how disappointing that may be for Annika...and how hurt she would be once again.
I agree. To have her expectations and hopes dashed would make it worse. Like she had to live through that trauma all over again. Besides, I don't think he wants to risk her getting angry and walking out on him again ...lol
He knows how headstrong his wife can be.


After the way she broke down in his arms today, all that she shared with him about her struggles, and her fights with life, the world, people, God, and even within herself...he cannot and will not ever let her have to endure the same pain again.
True. It was absolutely beautiful to watch how quiet, attentive and supportive he was just by hugging her and being there mentally to listen to her.

If he can find information for her background, she will have some answers, and that will make her less vulnerable to people like his mom and the larger world, and most assuredly the media...and at the same time he will simply know her background as well. I don't think it will impact his love for her or his acceptance of her as his wife!! He simply cannot help that he loves her...even his MIND doesn't have that kind of control over his HEART!! 😃
Nope it does not. Not where she is concerned.😊

I am so hoping for a continuation of the scene today.
Me as well. I want to hear his explanation of his conversation with his Bro's that she apparently misunderstood.

there was a point when she told him that she knows his need for NKK are most zaroori for him, even more zaroori than her in his life...and I saw the pained expression he had on his face. He so wanted to tell her...you ar more zarrori for me than the air i breathe to live...I so want to hear these words!! And I think he will watch her sleep and definitely have some introspection tonight...perhaps recall all that he has done and said to her to cause her the pain that spoke to him about today! The more time he spends with his wife, the deeper he falls for her...to the point of no return!!
She may just get part of the declaration that she so wanted ...lol

Ssyed001 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18
As much as i loved the episode today - im kind of scared of what's next.

It seems that everything is moving too fast - like a train wreck. Also scared of Shivaay suddenly changing (hes done it in the past).

Also im in 2 minds about his motives to find out about Annika's past. I dont think hes doing it for annika, hes still doing it for his own satisfaction.
Edited by Ssyed001 - 8 years ago
asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: naadanmasakalli

Yes finally someone else said it. Am so glad that we are on the same page in regards to why it is important for him to find that info out.it is not to accept her that he did already the way she is but basic bg knowledge to stop the insults to make sure tommorrow she will not have to hear the taunts and bakwaas of the world that if needed she has answers .


As I said, just as there is a stark difference in being Kate Middleton and the Duchess of Cambridge, the same applies to being just Annika (before he knew about her being an orphan) and now Mrs. Annika Shivvay Singh Oberoi.
Both have to realize that there are demands, expectations and responsibilities that have to be met and adhered to. Being his wife was never put forward as being an easy role to follow and a smooth title to slip into. She has to understand the things that come with being his wife and the things that are important to him.
He has already accepted her so if finding out about her past puts his mind at ease then she should afford him the luxury unless she has something to hide.

vivacious_gurl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: --Nargis--


Gouri...what happens if he can't find any information about Annika's past...does that mean he will never take his relationship forward, never have any children with her? Would he hurt her in that way...I don't think so. He know Annika's affinity for kids...her belief that every child should have the love of both parents...and how would he keep the happiness of becoming a mother from her...from the woman he is totally in love with?? It doesn't make any sense to me. 😕


Nags that's exactly what I meant... The look on his face when pinky asked what wud he tell his kids bout their mother's family said it all... No He cudnt tell them she was an orphan... So he cudnt hv kids with her... Not yet... He hasn't reached there... He can die for her but can't bring a life in this world with her yet... Yes He will hurt her again if he comes to know she is an illegitimate child... He Knows this isn't her fault but that's how he is... Dev ka koi kasoor nahi that that he is illegitimate... Child doesnt decide they want to be born out of wedlock... But he held it against dev that he had ganda khoon.. That's how he is.. That's y he had said he can't think of Annika as ko of his kids n though she is his wife now.. That mom of kids holds true even now... Woh annika ka Past jaane Kya Karega? Will it affect his relationship with her... Yes it will... If she is from good bg he will get calmness... N it will justify his belief that she is well brought up coz of her blood which was good... If she is from bad relationship or from prostituition... What will he do... Will She cease to be his wife... No... She won't... But will she hv his whole respect... No... He will b in conflict with himself on what justification to give to ppl coz all his life he has been ranting NKK... It is his ego what he won't hv answers for ppl ... Whatever Many hv been saying on forum that Shivaay is mere Shivaay... No He isn't... He isn't happy to tell ppl proudly that my wife is an orphan brought up in orphanage n she is what she is coz of her own self n I'm proud of her...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".