pakhim thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

I am not a big fan of Emon.....from the vry first day of piano round My Fav is Amit n Emon comes second....i am also proud that both of them makes a entry to top 5.....I was also vry happy when only Javedji praised Amit in Piano round...because i think he was the best judge ever .....and his compliments was last word to me.....

but after 9th gala round it is clear that he is vry much biassed to Amit ....and all knows there r two versatile singers in II..one is Emon n other Amit....if everything is alright then the final will be between Emon n Amit (pls forget the vote banks of Prashant n Ankita)...so to clear the path of Amit he has given such negetive comments to Emon....because Ankinta, Prashant are not camparable with Amit's quality.....so the final will become one man show .....

I want to Amit become Indian Idol...but not to win against Ankita/Prashant....

Kyonki ladne na ka mazaa tabhi hai jab samnewala jabardast ho....

if Emon copies Sonu perfectly it is a great achievements to a singer....pls Javedji don't comment on Emon so roughly.....if u can enjoy the dance (not singing) of Ankita ...u can easily tollerate a perfect singer like emon...

If u have time pls request Sonuji n listen once how he sings 'Teri deewani' or 'Khaike Paan' or ''Mitwa' ....i think he will definitely copy our beloved Emon.

VOTE FOR AMIT n EMON....THEY R THE BEST

Edited by pakhim - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.1k

Users

12

Frequent Posters

Amazinggg thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
I want to Amit become Indian Idol...but not to win against Ankita/Prashant....

Hahahahha so its your show that it happens everything that U want...its INDIAN IDOL and it happens as THE INDIAN PEOPLE want....they have voted PRASHANT and will be there until last round...Sounds bitter but truth 😆
cola_gul thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
um..yeh..i like..Amit n EMon too but Emon wuld b my first choice.!!!.. but i think itz kinda rude wen u say
"forget the vote banks of Ankita and Prashant"
im jus sayin..but i totally agree w// ur choice..i also like amit n Emon! 😃
pakhim thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Amazinggg

I want to Amit become Indian Idol...but not to win against Ankita/Prashant....

Hahahahha so its your show that it happens everything that U want...its INDIAN IDOL and it happens as THE INDIAN PEOPLE want....they have voted PRASHANT and will be there until last round...Sounds bitter but truth 😆

I think u r a aPrashant's fan......shame 2 u...shame

yummur thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
i do sometimes feel that some of the judges are too hard on emon. like if he goes out of sur in one place then they completely attack him for it. but if another singer goes out of sur way more than once then they say "you were out of sur but it's ok you'll do better next time." i wonder why they do that? is it because they have higher expectations for emon so they're also harder on him? but that's also not fair to the other contestants because that's basically like saying that they have lower expectations of the others so they don't judge them as strongly. if they want to be hard on a contestant then they should be equally hard on all the contestants, not just emon.
Edited by yummur - 18 years ago
r_tvfan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
I think the judges are completely against Emon. I don't understand why. i always liked Javed Ji's comments in Fame gurukul but something is seriously wrong with him. I mean everytime Emon sings, he says yeh toh accha singer hai.So if is good, praise him, compliment him, say he has the potential to become an Indian Idol. Why say oh he is a good singer and then find some fault. It makes no sense to me.

Today Anu Malik said he is the find of II. It took him 9 galas and so many piano rounds to say that. And today Udit says Emon should stay in, and the other day he had trouble decididing between Emon and Ankita.

Seriously looks like singing good is not required in the competition. If Sonu didn't have a problem, why the hell should anybody else have a problem. Sonu told Sandeep last year about the resemblance to Udit. He would have done the same. Sonu is not the one to lie. But Javed Ji says that Sonu had no choice. What rubbish. I am disgusted with these judges.

If Emon didn't sing well, say he sang bad, but saying that oh he's a good singer and then talking nonsense makes no sense. Javed Ji is the eldest and most sensible person, and comments like this don't suit him at all.
~Poonam~ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7


i don't listen to judges
i don't care 😆
mhk9 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
I think Javedji has lost his credibility as a judge. Because if you are a judge or teacher he should know your people nicely and he should know what is good singing and bad.
First, Emon does not copy Sonu Nigam, if we feel he sounds like that then what can we say about his look?? Does it mean his mom and dad copied Sonu's parents?

Pls pls someone should tell Javed that we all know that Amit and Emon are good singers due to their singing capabilities.

How come all these days, even when he got selected Javed ji did not see any copying of Sonu, BUT only when Emon declared globaly that he is Sonu's fan then he started commenting, how sad.

Anyways, Javed ji you are a judge and try to re-think your strategy instead of following Sony's drama where they have a fixed Indian idol in their views same as II2.
chanaa thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: mhk9

I think Javedji has lost his credibility as a judge. Because if you are a judge or teacher he should know your people nicely and he should know what is good singing and bad.
First, Emon does not copy Sonu Nigam, if we feel he sounds like that then what can we say about his look?? Does it mean his mom and dad copied Sonu's parents?

Pls pls someone should tell Javed that we all know that Amit and Emon are good singers due to their singing capabilities.

How come all these days, even when he got selected Javed ji did not see any copying of Sonu, BUT only when Emon declared globaly that he is Sonu's fan then he started commenting, how sad.

Anyways, Javed ji you are a judge and try to re-think your strategy instead of following Sony's drama where they have a fixed Indian idol in their views same as II2.

Javed ji was great judge until he carried your favorite high, 😛now he started to realize the truth. Now he is no more great for you because he is trying to speak his gut-feeling??? 😳

pakhim thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
He made same thing fr Ruprekha in Fame Gurukul (as for Amit).....given unnecessary harsh comments on Rex / Arpita.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".