Today's Analysis of all d Singers.....!!!

roadies_4 fan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Well i wud not say it was a disappointing gala.....but at d same time i felt noone was outstanding.....

Deepali was toooo very good but if she had a lil' more thrust in voice she wud have been outstanding....i mean like at some points not all.....she maintained the feel of the song very well though but like a lil' more shoutin needed deepali.😉

Amit was also very good but at some times wen the song really gets soft there he lost touch of d song....though he very well managed the sur.i mean maybe he got more into managing the sur there so maybe he lost the feel.....but that too at some places.😃

Chang ...umm wen the song needed the throw...there shud have been more power in his throw....i mean ya it lost the inspiring touch maybe not everywhere but he surely did lost the feel.🤔

Puja was good in her antara....but maybe the startin was not as good n touchin....morevor somewhere i felt the song needed to go a lil' soft but ummm that part was missing.still it was not so bad......it was pretty managable for us non-singers.

Ankita.....why did you get off the stage....i mean evn if for performance part....still i thnk it only deteriorated ur performance n all the more you misd a beat....n all hell broke at you.Arrey yaaar anil ji ko stage se hi phool maar deti naa.....well once on stage you were recovering into ur normal self but ur song was too short for recovery.

Emon....ummm at the startin i thnk it was not soooo good as it was said to be by the orkut ppl....i dun say he was flat but an essence was mssing in the first 4-5 lines....that were the low pitch lines....n once he goes "tujhe ab ye dikhana hai"....he was tooo good frm there...😊

well prashant was like ok good....but not d best performer....i didnt feel the same as anilji did....it didnt touch my heart.....the lyrics are so awesome that once you sing it good you easily connect....but sumwhere sumthin was missing,i dunno what....n anu sayin him as best performer confused me all the more.😕

Edited by roadies_4 fan - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.1k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

* Taurean_21 * thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
yeah agree wid u to some extent....amit ,ankita and deepali were really rocking....i didnt heard emon's song clearly.....so cant really comment on that..
Edited by * Taurean_21 * - 18 years ago
roadies_4 fan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I really thnk deepali was superb.....maybe one-two lines as uditji said she needed a special throw....but seriously i didnt even notice that....she was too good for me....actually outstandin for me.....superb job yaar.....n now PLZZZZZZZZZZZZ SAVE DEEPALI!!!
Edited by roadies_4 fan - 18 years ago
priyankumupal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
i agree on you on most parts but i'll add my two cents worth too
Emon had the feel of the song and the sur down to pat, i didn't notice the shaky start cos i was a little busy then but the ending was very good.
Amit was very good, the feel was there and the sur was perfect but i have to agree at a point or two i forgot that it was a patriotic song. he has it in him to do better. Both his and emon's songs were very tough so i'll give them both a 9 out of 10

Deepali was good, voice modulation was good, but there was something missing which i can't put my finger on. it wasn't the feel but something which was a tad bit off. otherwise her singing was very very good. i'll give her a 8.5

Prashant was good. he's singing was not as good at emon amit or deepali but he had the feeling it needed. i was moved by it but still can't deny he went of at a couple of places. i'll give him a 8

Puja was ok. not good not bad. she was ill and i feel that's why the feel of the song was missing. she sang the antra well and there she caught the feeling. the rest was so so. i'll give her a 6.5

Chang didn't work for me at all. he sang well but there was no feeling at all. i was thinking is this a romantic track? why is he singing it like he's asking everyone to come and do a romantic dance. not win a war. i'll rate him 5

Ankita was by far the worse. she ran around too much. she lost her voice and sur at about 10 places. if she stood still and did only a few moves she could have done better. but she really didn't do well. i'll rate her a 4
addyydda thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
i 2 believe that this was one of the worst galas ....noone gave an outstanding perf....very disappointing...
amit i believe was the best comparatively (but cud have been better...not up to his usual std) , followed by deepali...emon 4 the 1st time i felt went a bit off key (i know coz ive heard this song many times)n also lacked josh...ankita n puja were really off color (one of them is leavin tomorrow)... chang was ok (thats coz i dont xpect 2 much frm him anyway), prashant...ok, better than xpected


but over all disappointin episode..hope nxt round is better...

make u think if they r gettin enuff time to prac...they all looked off color....so sony shud put all shows on hold n let them do wot they r here to do---sing up to competition std
-Dayeeta- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

i enjoyed today's gala, but it wasnt an utstanding gala

umm in my opinion deepali was really good today but it wasnt her best obviously but she sang good, i enjoyed it 👏
next amit, i know all judges prised him, but i personally didnt like it, i also like him and support him but somehow today amit's magic was missing 😭
next chang, ummmm ya it was good performance but surely the qulaity he has createn last week wasnt upto the mark but ya feel was somehw missing 😭
next ankita, i also like her but today i am also lil disappointed, her magic wasnt there, 4 the first time i felt ankita was nervous where as she is soo much confedent
next puja, umm i liked it, she was good in antara, while starting she was lil out of the sur, but as we know she wasnt well, so she sang good 👏
next emon, trust me i am not saying this as an emon fan but a music lover, emon really sang well, while starting ya he was lil flat but in the high notes he was just superb and i loved it 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏
next prashant, frankly spking i didnt like his singing today atall, he wasnt in the sur i also felt tht, and i felt he was going fast, somehw it wasnt like his last performance
so my today's rankina (as i told b4, i havent judged anyone by my favs as i like all of thm)
no.1:Emon
No.2:Deepali
No.3:Chang,Puja
No.5:Amit
No.6:ankita and prashant
now lets hope 4 the best
and atlast its completely my point of view and its my opinion, if it has hurt anyone's feeling thn i am really sorry 😳

Edited by ~rahul ki rani~ - 18 years ago
Shufia thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
I haven't seen them all - just Deepali's, and I have to say that for the first time, I'm disappointed in Deepali, she should have sang it with MUCH more energy, she was totally slowing down the song . If she was meant to be good, then I wonder how bad the others were?
This episode seems like a really boring episode 😕 😭 - and where was Puja at the beginning?
Edited by Shufia - 18 years ago
cool_punjaban thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: * Taurean_21 *

yeah agree wid u to some extent....amit ,ankita and deepali were really rocking....i didnt heard emon's song clearly.....so cant really comment on that..

ankita rocking???????...i didn't see it anywhere today...she missed a beat and it wasn't upto the mark

Edited by cool_punjaban - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".