Overall Performance II3 versus II2

Page

Manny

@pri_is

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Guys, Its too early to say but I feel the general standard of II3 is much better than II2. Probably Karunya was the only exception but that could be true even after Indian Idol 10 also. He was such an exceptional talent. Barring him rest of the contestants were average and as a group II3 has much more talent.

Edited by pri_is - 18 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Vijey Umang

@Vijey Umang

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: pri_is
Guys, Its too early to say but I feel the general standard of II3 is much better than II2. Probably Karunya was the only exception but that could be true after the Indian Idol 10 also. He was such an exceptional talent. Barring him rest of the contestants were average and as a group II3 has much more talent.

I feel exactly reverse from this.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Hiba

@Me_Abhi

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Vijey Umang

I feel exactly reverse from this.

me too😕

Quote

Jugnu17

@Jugnu17

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

ii3 is more talented.
but u missed out Amey he was just as talented as Karunya.

Quote

seema

@mumbai80

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

Nobody is as talented as Karunya in II3 and Sa Re Ga...Amey Date was not even close!!!Karunya was just exceptional, every song he sang touched your heart.

Quote

Manny

@pri_is

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Well on Amey, I could say barring "Dil ne tum ko choon liya hai" rest were mediocre performance, I think Emon,Cheng,Abhi & Paul not to miss Prashant can beat him hands down.

Edited by pri_is - 18 years ago

Quote

77124

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

The first Gala of II2 was a star studded affair. I remember it was so exciting and most of the performances were good

And II3.....they had so much time to practise, and in accordane to that fact, they sucked.

Quote

payal

@*payal*

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Shawn89
The first Gala of II2 was a star studded affair. I remember it was so exciting and most of the performances were good

And II3.....they had so much time to practise, and in accordane to that fact, they sucked.

yea youre right...practically everyone was good in the first gala...i still remember pannas jhalak dikhlaja and ameys aadat...neha was good too...i guess relatively, this year was worse...but i still liked the episode, with the exception of three contestants, the rest were quite good...hope they get better next time, and i hope they pick the right songs..

Quote

payal

@*payal*

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: tpam

i wud disagree becoz .. last time judging was linient!! i feel it was almost same with one or two exceptions .. becoz last time sandeep was besura , karu was bad on the first day , even sagar was nt that gudd ravi was horrible ... pannas best and amey was guddd

sandy n ravi (both trained singers, unlike most this year) werent that bad in the first gala and karu was good, but he chose the wrong song (i think chak de), parleen did that this year too but he didnt even sing it right...i agree the judging was more lenient, i guess maybe thats why this year seems a lot worse than last...but come to think of it, the judgement this year made sense (tho anu was a bit too harsh) and last years too, cause sonu pointed out the sur mistakes and farah pointed out the performance mistakes (anu just cheered all the girls😆 offering them roles in his movies)