were d judges right?

padmanav has better singing talent then ankita and suhit, judges agreed on that, but still chose ankita. doesnt make sense. if any of u have watched american idol, sanjaya was in coz of his okay singing and performances only coz of audience votes. none of the judges thot he deserved to be there coz there were others with singing talent getting chucked out..

itz depressing to see judges making a judgement based on performances..isnt this show abt singing? other things do count but not at the expense of singing. if audience would have made this decision it'd been acceptable..

padmanav better luck to u, u shud try out better options where looks/clothes/attitude dont matter above singing..

i would never go and but a cd which has songs of Ankita...her singing is average and u will find lots of people with average singing talent.....then why would you like to pay and buy her CD ....although I would like to buy a CD from Padmanav....judges made the wrong choice....yes but I guess all judges had a soft corner for her as they danced with her..... 😆 ...I guess that worked out for ankita......

lol, u think judges chose her coz she made them dance on her tunes..lol

Oh God everyone cant be II, we have already lost Bhavin & Aisha over Ankita & Suhit, this is not at all new - anyway we know she cannot reach to till top5 or 3 neither could Padamanv - so just chill!!! 😉

Padvan and SUHIT were better than amit and ankita

Originally posted by: S a r a h

Oh God everyone cant be II, we have already lost Bhavin & Aisha over Ankita & Suhit, this is not at all new - anyway we know she cannot reach to till top5 or 3 neither could Padamanv - so just chill!!! 😉

we lost bhavin n aisha coz of audience votes, judges dint throw them out.. mebe padmanav would not have made it top 5, but he shudnt have lost to ankita for d silly reasons quoted by d judges..

Originally posted by: kay*

we lost bhavin n aisha coz of audience votes, judges dint throw them out.. mebe padmanav would not have made it top 5, but he shudnt have lost to ankita for d silly reasons quoted by d judges..

I know that - viewer's decision wasnt acceptable coz inspite of having good singing abilitie along with xfactor Bhavin n Aisha lost but clearly here Ankita has got excellent stage presence that she can make the whole studio dance to her singing with confidence comapratively better than Suhit or Padmanav - thats why she has been chosen and I am very much satisfied with the decision :)

jus leave Ankita alone 😡 😡 she can def rock da nation unlike some boring ppl..

jus leave Ankita alone 😡 😡 she can def rock THE nation unlike some boring ppl..LIKE SUHIT!!

BUT PADMANAV IS GR8 SINGER.. BUT SUHIT EWWW..

I CALL HIM.... PATHI HUI AWAAZ'!! 😆

Originally posted by: surveen_kapoor

jus leave Ankita alone 😡 😡 she can def rock THE nation unlike some boring ppl..LIKE SUHIT!!

BUT PADMANAV IS GR8 SINGER.. BUT SUHIT EWWW..

I CALL HIM.... PATHI HUI AWAAZ'!! 😆

here i dont talk abt suhit😕

i was jus replying those ppl who talked abt Ankita..

hope u got it..