Javed Sa’ab has been ordered..

After two piano rounds of positive and sweet comments, Javed Sa'ab was curt with some of the contestants. He disagreed with Alisha and Udit on more than one occassion. He was very vocal throughout the show. Has he been specifically instructed to do so by the producers?? The judges being too sweet wasnt going down well with the audiences so they have decided to add some masala on that acoount maybe!😉

But all said and done Javed Akhtar does come across as the most honest, eloquent, intelligent and witty judge...👏

Hope some of it rubs on to Alisha coz she is giving out very dumb statements in name of judgement!!🤢

Ashu, is there a telepathy going on between us? I was about to post something on similar lines and saw this😊.

For me Javed ji is the only judge. Udit Narayan is OK but Alisha is a big NO🤢. She is worst that Farah Khan. At least Farah was funny. What is Alisha claim to fame again?

Having said that I would say Javed ji tends to get picky with certain contestants. I have seen similar trend in FG when he chased Shamit even when he was good only because he once played a game with another contestant. Now with Richa I see the same. Last time too he was critical of her. You can say that he has higher expectations of her being a very good singer but critical remarks everytime makes a huge difference in people's mind and voting pattern.

In my opinion tonight Richa was very good and as expected Javed ji had some remarks set aside for her again wheras he gave a standing ovation to Smita. No doubt Smita was good but she was not exceptional to get an ovation from judges. Charu and Deepali were much better than her. I dislike sympathy votes. So even though I like Smita I still think that Javed ji was partial towards her and felt for Richa.

javed is always correct with his judgement... his remarks too r witty and interesting 😊 i saw that he was discussing something with udit yesterday while alisha was giving her judgement 😕

alishas claim to fame is made in india album maya 😆 😆 😆 and i agree with both of you, i like the way javed saab speaks so eloquently, and he is very smart person, i respect him so much and the way he said to smita that he is elder than her but he will still give him standing ovation, its the way he said it depicts his debonair nature. what a well read guy 👏 👏 👏

alisha is an unnecessary judge there, where is anu malik 😕

Sorry to say, but Richa was not good in the piano rounds. She was amazing in the auditions, which increased the expectations. But even otherwise (without expectations too) she was not in sur at all.

Javed is the only judge. Throw out Alisha. Even Udit seems to be very sweet, even when the contestant is totally out of sur.😲
Is Alisha classically trained ? She is so wrong most (read all) of the times.
There are other ways of encouraging participants. Give them the right feedback, not +ve ones.

That is one thing I like about SRGMP, is that other gharana gurus are so curt and frank. But SRGMP does not have good contestants this time. After seeing II3 girls first round, I thought WOW what a talented bunch. But guess I was wrong. Too much masti and dancing and less singing.

Javed A. has knowledge about sining - wonder how 😕 but he mostly speaks what I think during the performance... otherwise usually judges contradict my opinion 😆 which yea naturally it doesnt make any impact on me but speaking about other JUDGES Udit can be a good judge but he doesnt know hoe to speak out his mind... wonder what language he knows 😕 but most of the times he cant say what he actually thinks Alisha is a showpiece wearing Russian costumes(not in summer tho) 😆 she can not judge actually - she probably is very honest & thinks everyone is better than her in singing🤣

Originally posted by: S a r a h

she probably is very honest & thinks everyone is better than her in singing🤣

🤣 Then I would agree with Alisha.

Originally posted by: raunaq

alishas claim to fame is made in india album maya 😆 😆 😆 and i agree with both of you, i like the way javed saab speaks so eloquently, and he is very smart person, i respect him so much and the way he said to smita that he is elder than her but he will still give him standing ovation, its the way he said it depicts his debonair nature. what a well read guy 👏 👏 👏

alisha is an unnecessary judge there, where is anu malik 😕

She was lifted by Milind Soman in the video...That is her claim to fame!!😆

And Maya,

Do you no the one person who would be desperately praying for Anuu to come back...no Raunaqwa not you!😉...but Richa!! He really likes her and is the only person who can fight the negative remarks form Javed Sa'ab to protect his favorite...I too felt Richa was way way better then many singers y'day.

Smita sang really well but I feel that she is one of the hundreds of voices floating around...Richa has a unique voice!

Originally posted by: Maya_M

🤣 Then I would agree with Alisha.

That was an honest remark Sarah!!!😆😆😆

Originally posted by: Maya_M

🤣Then I would agree with Alisha.

😆 good one 😆