sohini out - no one cared? - Page 2

Originally posted by: ..ashu

sohini does not deserve any comment because she is not grand daughter of asha, she is not favorite of lata, she is not friend of Salim merchant or anybody

Grand daughter : ritika
favorite of judges and Lata : Devender, Amit, Vipul
Friend : Amit
Friend : Poorvi

well said

judges are clearly bias

surprisingly even asha ji

Originally posted by: aa07

Sunidhis behaviour during the results announcement was the worst behaviour I have ever seen by a judge in any competition. Such a blatant display of partiality and dislike for one singer over another...had to be seen to be believed. Frankly sohini must be so happy to leave this sham of a show.

absolutely agree, was shocking to see sunidhi act like this

she favors amit and pourvi over everyone

Harmonium master irfar, sang one line extra but brilliantly, so, he was rejected for singing extra line.

Juhi pointed out that scale was low, so, she was rejected

Indu Bala wonderful voice said that she wanted to meet Lata, so, she was rejected

Kritika was rejected without any reason

These judges have selected their slaves but surely not singers.

Sohini did not shake hands with Salim and Sunidhi, so, she was rejected by Salim in mega audition.

These Judges are not human being. Singing industry depends on Sadhna Bhakti good heart.

But these judges have hates, ego, anger, absent minded, dishonesty
When they want to eliminate anybody, they, destroy the song by using techniques.

i feel like laughing over some comments here..no one is nobvody's son and no one is here a relative of everybody..agreed sohini shud have been given better comment but dat does not mean judges are biased..they only selected her in top 10..they could have rejected her in the theme round itself or the piano.they did not..at that time she was singing well but suddenly from the first gala expectation and stage fright got over her..the biggest gala got to her nerves and that is why her performance dropped rapidly..nothing to do with being biased..as u sow so shall u reap.jaise to taisa..had she continued or even bettered her performance from the piano she would never had got such comments.think over it :)

Originally posted by: tuntunituntuni

can anyone plz tell me how much trp this show is getting this tym?wat the hell type indian idol this is!! kitni boring hey yaar...kisiko ganey mey interest nehi hey..kisi ko comments dene mey..sunidi is like statue here..disgusting yaar

she always were on bottom.. i think she should have been out BEFORE Amitab and Kaushik..

Originally posted by: abduly4

I am sure, songs are being edited. Lips are not matching with the song sometimes.

Sohini is one of the best singer in music industry. She is already a playback singer.

She is highly talented and no body can compete her in classical out of these remaining.

She did not do any mistake. Her speed of bukiyan harkatein was same like man mohana song.

The judges are dishonest.

Sohini must come back.

New judges must be appointed.

do u even know how a show is telecasted. first the song and perofrmance is dubbed on stage and based on that comments are given. then the voice and picture (meaning audio and video) are demuxed and converted into a suitable format for transimission to satellites. then at the receiving end (meaning cable operator or tata sky etc.) these are again muxed and then we see it. sometimes due to demuxing and muxing there can be time mismatching but the songs are recorded on stage ( i know it through a reliable source who has gone to see the galas in studio since season I). So b4 commenting that the contestants are only lip reading plz know the facts properly or else the technical people will always laugh at you.

Originally posted by: abduly4

I am sure, songs are being edited. Lips are not matching with the song sometimes.

Sohini is one of the best singer in music industry. She is already a playback singer.

She is highly talented and no body can compete her in classical out of these remaining.

She did not do any mistake. Her speed of bukiyan harkatein was same like man mohana song.

The judges are dishonest.

Sohini must come back.

New judges must be appointed.

I agreed by all means.
They do editing good or bad whatever they want.

I think there was no one except asha ji and pandit jasraj ji who understands classical singing.. that is why i think she got eliminated.. very sad it being Indian Idol her singing was not appreciated..