How Indian Idol should have been!

Okay, this is completely YOUR opinion. You rank the contestants the way YOU would have liked the show to go with the Top 11/Top 12

Indian Idol 1

1. Aditi Paul/Amit Sana
2. Amit Sana/Aditi Paul
3. Prajakta Shukre
4. Rahul Saxena
5. Vishal Kothari
6. Amit Tandon
7. Abhijeet Sawant
8. Rahul Vaidya
9. Mukesh Kumar Pancholi
10. Harish Moyal
11. Ravinder Ravi

Aditi Paul/Amit Sana either one could have won & I'd be happy.

Indian Idol 2

1. Monali Thakur/Meenal Jain
2. Meenal Jain/Monali Thakur
3. Antara Mitra
4. Neha Kakkar
5. NC Karunya
6. Amey Date
7. Sagar Arun Sarwarkar
8. Anuj Sharma
9. Panna Gill
10. Sandeep Acharya
11. Yashashree Bhave
12. Ravi Tripathi

Again, the Top 4 could have gone anyway. I'd have been happy.

No bashing please.

waiting for duet song of Amit and aditi......😃

u put neha kakkar b4 karunya and amey?? hmmmmm strange...well ur opinion i guess 🤔

Originally posted by: srk_lover

u put neha kakkar b4 karunya and amey?? hmmmmm strange...well ur opinion i guess 🤔

i agree with u..

meenal..amey..karunya..antara should be on top 4's

heres my list

1. Amey😉
2. Karu or Meenal or Antara
3. Meenal or Karu or Antara
4. Panna or Monali
5. Neha
6. Sagar
7. Sandy
8. Yashashree
9. RAVI AND ANUJ!🤢😡

1)Panna Gill
2)Amey Date
3)Sandeep Acharya
4)N C Karunya
5)Monali Thakhur
6)Meenal Jain
7)Neha Kakkar
8)Antara Mitra
9)Sagar
10)Anuj
11)Yashishree
12)Ravi Triparthi

woww ...anuj before panna?! 😕 i disagree ...well its yur opinion ... 😕

I like the way it is!!!! lol I have nothinn 2 regret!!! My hubby is Indian Idol!!

II 1

amit/rahul.v(top2)
abhi/aditi/rahul.s(Top5).

amit sana shd have been idol.his performances were trendsetters...never experienced before in an indian singing competition.truly original.his kisna",bijuriya",marhabba",and many more..the magic hasn't been be recreated.

II2
karunya/amey(top2)
antara,meenal,monali(top5)

karunya shd be idol....again because of sheer energy on stage.magic of "hum thi woh thi",kaisa yeh pyar hai"jaa re hath nathkhat,"badan pe sitare".......it is all about the impact the singer makes on the judges and audience at that point,which cant be recreated again....

from other shows...some show stoppers

arijit(aashique banaya)
rex(dholi taro)
arpita(dayya re mein kahan aa phansi)
hemu(nahin saamne)
nihira(ilove you)
ujjaini(black)

so u want only girls in top 4 (II2)??? 😆 😆 😆

my rankings for II2 are :
1.Amey
2.Karunya
3.Antara/Meenal
4.Antara/Meenal
5.Monali