How Indian Idol should have been! - Page 2

i will not comment on II 1 as i watched it from top 3. but 4 II2 i wud say

1. amey
2. karunya
3. meenal
4. monali
5. sandeep
6. antara
7. panna
8. yashashree
9. ravi
10.anuj
11.sagar
12.neha

1.karu
2. amey
3. meenal
4. panna
5. antara
6. monali
7. anuj
8. sandeep
9. sagar
10. yashashree
11. neha
12. ravi

1. rahul vaidya
2. abhijeet
3. amit sana
4. prajakta
5. aditi
6. rahul saxena
7. harish
8. mukesh
9. vishal
10.ravinder

arijit for me however is tghe best find in reality tv

Originally posted by: bsb-star

arijit for me however is tghe best find in reality tv

you know you are right!I love karu and hemu too,with all my heart.but arijit is peerless.such is his power that his singing conquers all hearts.or how do you explain the love he got from shamit,FG faculty,the veteran javed saab,shankar mahadevan...for him 'har gunaah maaf'..just to hear him sing....

Mine PERFECT II2 rankings:
1-AMEY DATE
2-Nc Karunya
3-Panna Gill
4-Antara Mitra
5-Sandeep Acharya
6-Meenal Jain
7-Monali Thakur
8-Sagar Swarekar
9-Neha Kakkar
10-Yashashree
11-Anuj Sharma
12-Ravi Tripathi

II1 REankings:
1-Rahul Vaidya
2-Abhijeet Sawant
3-Prajakta
4-Rahul Saxena
5-Aditi Paul
6-Amit Sana
7-Amit Tandon
8-Harish
9-Mukesh
10-Ravinder Ravi
11-Vishal

Indian Idol 2

nc karunya
amey date
monali thakur
panna gill
saGar sawarkar
meenal jain
neha kakkar
anatara mitra
sandeep acharya
anuj sharma --- never listened to yashashree

1}Karunya
2)Amey Date
3)Sandeep Acharya
4)Panna Gill
5)Meenal Jain
6) Antara Mitra
7) Sagar
8)Monali Thakhur
9)Yashishree
10)Neha Kakkar
11) Anuj
12)Ravi Triparthi

Originally posted by: srk_lover

u put neha kakkar b4 karunya and amey?? hmmmmm strange...well ur opinion i guess 🤔

Right mannnnnnn......thazzzzzzzz really wierd ranking.......anywayzz thier opnion:

Umm gonna rank only II2 cozz i never watched II1:

1. Amey

2. Karunyna

3. Meenal

4. Monali

5. Panna

6. Antra

7. Neha

8. Sandeep

9. Anuj

10. Saagar

11. Yashshree

12. Ravi

Just imigine battle of top four between Amey, Karu, Meenal, Monali..................amazing singers, performers, and also with XYZ factor..........anywazzzzzzzzz history has been written so no point dreaminmg.........have fun

PEACE

1. NC Karunya
2. Amey Date
3. Antara Mitra
4. Meenal Jain
5. Panna Gill
   
6. Monali Thakur
7. Neha Kakkar
8. Sandeep Acharya
   
9. Yashashree Bhave
   
10. Sagar Sawarkar
11. Ravi Tripathi
    
12. Anuj Sharma

Based on piano rounds it would go like this I guess:

Top 4 (in any order)

• NC Karunya
• Sandeep Acharya
• Antara Mitra
• Monali Thakur

Top 8 (in any order, but top 4 would remain the same)

• NC Karunya
• Sandeep Acharya
• Antara Mitra
• Monali Thakur
• Panna Gill
• Neha Kakkar
• Meenal Jain
• Sagar Sawarkar

Top 12 (in any order, except the top 8 would be same)

• NC Karunya
• Sandeep Acharya
• Antara Mitra
• Monali Thakur
• Panna Gill
• Neha Kakkar
• Meenal Jain
• Sagar Sawarkar
• Ravi Tripathi
• Yashashree Bhave
• Amey Date
• Anuj Sharma

I also took the opportunity to see if, according to the votes they received in piano rounds, contestants left early, late or within their range.

1. Sandeep Acharya - within his range
   
2. NC Karunya - within his range
   
3. Anuj Sharma - left late
   
4. Amey Date - left late
   
5. Antara Mitra - left early
   
6. Meenal Jain - within her range
   
7. Ravi Tripathi - left late
   
8. Panna Gill - within his range
   
9. Monali Thakur - left early
   
10. Neha Kakkar - left early
    
11. Yashashree Bhave - within her range
    
12. Sagar Sawarkar - left early
    

sandeep (overall)
karunya
amey
monali
antra
sagar
neha
ughhh
yeah and the others
of course
anuj and ravi or at the bottom 😆