Is Sonu really fair?

Sonu very plainly told Anuj that after he sang Solah baras ki- aapne aaj bilkul accha nahin gaya...Do you really think he sang that bad...comapre it to Ravi Tripathi's last gala performance which if you remember Sonu had praised....

Is Sonu a really fair judge or does he have his biases as well....

Nopes! he do favoritism alot..but some times and for some contestants his comments are really worthy..

wel i think if any1s comment has value among the 3 judges its sonu. i hav noticed evn durin the audition rounds he tried 2 b as fair as he can. i thk singin cums 1st in indian idol n thn performance n luks. whts an idol who cant sing well? i hope the janta n evn contestants takes his comments seriously. sumtmes he may sound a bit baised but hes human 2. his comments r definately more valuable thn anu or farah.

n yah ravi was gud wen he sang teri did ko akhiya. i thk tat was ravi's best.

ya sonu is fair.. nd wat ever he said was truth.. ravi was good in his last performance nd he sang very difficult song..

very very fair. he is da best

Originally posted by: giggles_2005

Sonu very plainly told Anuj that after he sang Solah baras ki- aapne aaj bilkul accha nahin gaya...Do you really think he sang that bad...comapre it to Ravi Tripathi's last gala performance which if you remember Sonu had praised....

Is Sonu a really fair judge or does he have his biases as well....

I was wondering the same.........why Sonu said that to Anuj and that too not giving any reason he just said it in his face 😕 ...... I don't know from singing point of view...... I mean i am not that good with all sur, taal things but I really liked Anuj that day.... he did put lot of feelings in that song. I don't know what made Sonu so upset 😕

But compared to other 2 judges..... i think Sonu is the most fair of them all. I still value his judgment a lot....

I won't say always but yes most of the times he is fair.

Originally posted by: giggles_2005

Sonu very plainly told Anuj that after he sang Solah baras ki- aapne aaj bilkul accha nahin gaya...Do you really think he sang that bad...comapre it to Ravi Tripathi's last gala performance which if you remember Sonu had praised....

Is Sonu a really fair judge or does he have his biases as well....

i think as Anuj is one of the fevourite contestants of Sonu ji, so he expect much more from Anuj,thts why he said so.....Sonu is a real judge

Amoong the three judges, I feel Sonu has more depth knowledge when it comes to Singing!
And if you are thinking of Anu Malik, check out various internaitonal album before releaseo fhis music and you will get the idea where from he get 'inspiration' rather than creating his own meloday...
and Faraha - No comment !!
Sonu is not only fair but critical to help them improve....and see the improvements in many of the contestents so far...