Amey sounded off key!!! - Page 9

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

Dont compare amey's version to the original. The high notes sung by Daler have been sung in 'harmony'---therefore the effect is different. When you sing in 'harmony' it means that there are two tracks overlapping each other, each in different scale. Since, Amey cant sing in two different scales at one time what he sings will sound different to the original. Rehman is famous for overlapping tracks---thts his trademark---thts why they say singing Rehman songs is no joke.

And Amey also had to deepen his voice for the song---maybe it's the change in voice that your ears couldnt adapt to.

He certainly wasnt off-key----no offence, but do you even know what off-key is? It's when you sing OUT OF TUNE and your singing ntoes become flatter....Amey's too well trained to ever go flat.

As for Amey 'shouting' in the high notes then do you even know how high rang de basanti goes---even females find it hard to sing--one of the biggest rules when singing 'high notes' is to keep your volume up so that the lyrics are clear.

My dear, off key means plain and simple off key.. you are right.. out of tune.. and the best trained singer can go off key..and I don't think it was due to overlapping tracks or anything like that.. sorry, no offence ..

Originally posted by: pragatimanoj

Nobody wants Amey to sound exactly like Daler. One should always be true to thier voice like Karunya. He is not imitating Nusrat saheb, he is singing the song to the best of his ability in his own style. Nobody asked amey to sing like Daler, he chose to sing like him and he failed miserably at it. He was not singing the song correctly. I mentioned earlier that he had goofed up at the "sanse" part. He is a really good singer and should not make such silly mistakes. He has a long road ahead of himself. Everythime he is on the stage he should give his best performance as millions are watching him including the music directors who would want him to playback for them. If he makes these mistakes they might not want him.
Cheers
Pragati

i disagree totally, i just dont think amey tried to imitate daler... i think he just did everything required of him to sing that song. since it has very high notes, he sounded like daler a little but he wasnt trying to. i think he deserves all the marks for singing such a hard ar rehman song

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

fastlover21, that' sall u gotta say to the well convinced argument of breathingirony fellow? please why dont YOU grow up and come up with a better comeback? 😆

U never cud state anything convincing and now u r hanging on to somebody else's statement😆

I pity on u too😃

Originally posted by: Mishtimoni

My dear, off key means plain and simple off key.. you are right.. out of tune.. and the best trained singer can go off key..and I don't think it was due to overlapping tracks or anything like that.. sorry, no offence ..

Nope sweets, Off-key means 'out of tune' AND 'singing 'flat' when u r out of tune it doesnt necessarily mean tht u r singing flat.....AND amey's voice is certainly not flat!

Originally posted by: fastlover21

U never cud state anything convincing and now u r hanging on to somebody else's statement😆

I pity on u too😃

it's not my fault you decided to ignore my arguments! and there's nothing wrong with supporting anyone. well i pity you more now because you only use personal attacks instead of coming up with justified arguments

Originally posted by: pragatimanoj

Nobody wants Amey to sound exactly like Daler. One should always be true to thier voice like Karunya. He is not imitating Nusrat saheb, he is singing the song to the best of his ability in his own style. Nobody asked amey to sing like Daler, he chose to sing like him and he failed miserably at it. He was not singing the song correctly. I mentioned earlier that he had goofed up at the "sanse" part. He is a really good singer and should not make such silly mistakes. He has a long road ahead of himself. Everythime he is on the stage he should give his best performance as millions are watching him including the music directors who would want him to playback for them. If he makes these mistakes they might not want him.
Cheers
Pragati

Who said he was imitating Daler? Of course, he can't sing this song that way he sang Tu Hi Re or Suno Na. Every song comes with its own style and flavor and you can deviate and improvise but how much? Why are you comparing Amey's song to Karyuna's anyway? Yeah, he sang a Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan song but so did Meenal and she to improvise as well. Compare Amey's to the original if anything. His song was of much high pitch than the others.

Originally posted by: pragatimanoj

Nobody wants Amey to sound exactly like Daler. One should always be true to thier voice like Karunya. He is not imitating Nusrat saheb, he is singing the song to the best of his ability in his own style. Nobody asked amey to sing like Daler, he chose to sing like him and he failed miserably at it. He was not singing the song correctly. I mentioned earlier that he had goofed up at the "sanse" part. He is a really good singer and should not make such silly mistakes. He has a long road ahead of himself. Everythime he is on the stage he should give his best performance as millions are watching him including the music directors who would want him to playback for them. If he makes these mistakes they might not want him.
Cheers
Pragati

Amey was neither sounding like Daler nor was he imitating Daler. Amey was sounding like Amey only and he was grrrrrr8.

Originally posted by: fastlover21

U never cud state anything convincing and now u r hanging on to somebody else's statement😆

I pity on u too😃

You tell em not to get personal and now u r getting personal yourself....Kadwiphool, didnt ask for your 'pity'!!!

Look, if u think Amey sang 'off-key' then thts your opinion

um there's only one person in the show who sings flat and that's sandeep

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

It is overlapping tracks---IM 100% SURE.....thts why when this song was sung in SRGMP, they had Hema singing in one scale and vinit singing in another.

I don't think so. Daler Mehndi completed the recording of the song in 15 mins (see this)
and its hard to believe that he did all that in 15 mins. That song suited Daler style of singing and he sang that well. Now Amey is a very good singer, argubly the best but he ruined the song by tyring to imitate Daler and not singing in his original voice. Karunya was in a similar position, he was singing NFAK Saheb song but he didn't try to copy Nusrat Saheb's husky voice and that why his song sounded better.