Meenal got less votes...She deserved it..

Hi guys...Many of U disagree with me, but serisouly..........I had doubt that either Meenal or Yashshree would be out.......N YASHSHREE IS OUT.......n Then it was Meenal's Turn......

Farah was right Meenal did't perform tht well....I agree with Farah......N even i wasn't happy with her performance.......but well good luck to her for the next time.......

I M SO HAPPY THAT ANTARA N MONALI GOT HIGHEST VOTES.......

HAPPY THAT NEHA CAME ON 3RD PLACE...........N MEENAL ON 4TH.....

Well Meenal sang perfectly. Most people pay attention to Sonu's comments then Anu's comments, and Last Farah's comments. Sonu and Anu know about singing and that is why people listen to them when it comes to a singing competetion. You don't want an idol who sucks at singing, but gives good expression. Meenal tries to good give expression, but she pays more attention to singing because she is smart.

Originally posted by: KunalK

Well Meenal sang perfectly. Most people pay attention to Sonu's comments then Anu's comments, and Last Farah's comments. Sonu and Anu know about singing and that is why people listen to them when it comes to a singing competetion. You don't want an idol who sucks at singing, but gives good expression. Meenal tries to good give expression, but she pays more attention to singing because she is smart.

It's Indian Idol...U have to sing well n also perform well..U have to good at everything.......

And abt the singin...I think Antara n Monali has a better voice than Meenal.....but it's ur chocie.

I am completey dis agree Meenal has to go long way, we really appreciate Farah Khan judgement.. unho nay jo bhi predict kiya woh sahi hua... lekin plzZz yeh pahlay singing competition hai .. theek hai Farah nay theek kaha k meenal ki performance mein koi kami rah gayi thee she is a choreographer she better know that...par un ko saath yeh bhi theek se clerify karna chahiye tha that she sang beauitifully,she has a melodious voice.....as 2 judges belongs to music praise highly praise her We hope k next gala mein Meenal apni singing capability k saath saath apni performance se bhi farah ko mutasir karay....
Best of luck Meenal
Alishba Karachi,Pakistan

Originally posted by: KunalK

Well Meenal sang perfectly. Most people pay attention to Sonu's comments then Anu's comments, and Last Farah's comments. Sonu and Anu know about singing and that is why people listen to them when it comes to a singing competetion. You don't want an idol who sucks at singing, but gives good expression. Meenal tries to good give expression, but she pays more attention to singing because she is smart.

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU THIS IS SINGING TALENT SHOW. IF PERFORMANCE IS THAT IMPORTANT THAN THESE PEOPLE CAN EVEN DO CABERAT DANCE.

Originally posted by: karish89

Hi guys...Many of U disagree with me, but serisouly..........I had doubt that either Meenal or Yashshree would be out.......N YASHSHREE IS OUT.......n Then it was Meenal's Turn......

Farah was right Meenal did't perform tht well....I agree with Farah......N even i wasn't happy with her performance.......but well good luck to her for the next time.......

I M SO HAPPY THAT ANTARA N MONALI GOT HIGHEST VOTES.......

HAPPY THAT NEHA CAME ON 3RD PLACE...........N MEENAL ON 4TH.....

I totally agree with u karish89.meenal deserve it,she didn't perform well.and I also very happy for Antara and Monali,coz they got the highest vote.thats nice congrats Antara and Monali.

i think that meenal has strong vocals and can sing really well and we better have musical ear rather than popping our eyes out.same farha in piano round and now sonu both told antra to less her performance(dance steps) as it effects her singing though she can sing well otherwise.

MEENAL SHOULD GO A LONG WAY...but for the girls it should be jolly or neha out next!

da thing bout Meenal is dat shes a gud singer but along wid dat shes a gud performer..she doesnt overdo her performance-like yday in da gala round..she was singing well AND had a gud stage presence. she dusnt need 2 run around da stage wid 2 much movement..she has dat natural stage charm n she interacts wid da audience well. i think she'll go a long way..and da i think da only reason y she was in da bottom 3 was cuz of farah's comments..i think she'll go a long way n 4 me-she's defi. da agla indian idol !! 😉

Originally posted by: KunalK

Well Meenal sang perfectly. Most people pay attention to Sonu's comments then Anu's comments, and Last Farah's comments. Sonu and Anu know about singing and that is why people listen to them when it comes to a singing competetion. You don't want an idol who sucks at singing, but gives good expression. Meenal tries to good give expression, but she pays more attention to singing because she is smart.

DISAGREE WITH YOU INDIAN IDOL ITS A IDOL ITS NOT ONLY VOICE QUALITY ALSO LIKE SMARTNESS LIKE AS MODEL A GOOD PERFORMER THATS WHY I AGREE WITH KAREESH MEENAL SHOULD GO OUT SHE CAN'T GIVE GOOD EXPRESSION WHAT KINDA SONG SHE SINGS...ANYWAYS THATS FROM ME AND THANKS KARISH FOR YOUR COMMENT