Meenal got less votes...She deserved it..

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Shraddha

@lashy

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 19 years ago

#21

ok fine everyone who supports farah says that performance is important as it is the INDIAN IDOL... when you release a music video, you record the music separately and the performance in a studio separately.... as a package meenal is good so thats all that matters...

adnan sami - does he dance while singing? he just bounces..
asha bhonsle???
even sonu nigam, alisha chinoy - while performing on stage, they give more importance to their songs...
Have you seen a live show of sunidhi chauhan? she runs out of breath trying to perform..
and these are the biggest names in POP music...

Quote

taran

@Iq_RkForeva

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#22

i agree, yasheshree should have been out at piano round but somehow she was in, i think dilpreet was much better

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

gowtham

@indianman

Rocker

Posted: 19 years ago

#23

Lashforever,

i totally agree with u. When i was working in india, i organised lot of stage shows in the hotel i worked for. when these singers perform on stage, they play a pre-recorded song & lip sync to it.. becos they all know that one cannot have perfect tune & good performance at the same time.
Specially this stage is more about the talent of singing. If one falls short in singing, then wats the use of a great performance?
Bt all said & done, I was quite impressed with meenal's performance, she atleast put affort to be in rythm to dance with the other dancers, unlike RAVI & SANDEEP, whose performance was pathethic & FARha praised them to the hilt... 😡

Quote

kachhori

@kachhori

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: karish89

It's Indian Idol...U have to sing well n also perform well..U have to good at everything.......

And abt the singin...I think Antara n Monali has a better voice than Meenal.....but it's ur chocie.

OH YES.

😉 MEENAL cant perform but sings good.

😕 NEHA cant sing but performs well

😕 FARAHA is right for MEENAL.

😕.BUT SONU & ANU not right about NEHA

Quote

nyctenz

@nyctenz

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#25

Come on.....Menal is great and she doesn't deserve to be the last on the girl's list. As Sonu rightly says...if Menal concentrates more on performance...her voice quality will detoirate. Well....I would say...we need an Idol who has a pleasant voice more than who can perform... Menal does have stage presence and her smile brings out the beauty in her!!!! VOTE FOR MENAL!!!!!

Quote

1 2 3

Meenal got less votes...She deserved it.. - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics