QUALITY OS SINGING IS BAD

When compared to sa re ga ma pa singers esp girls they r far superior.farah is emphasizing too much on perfomance---dancing so siging is suffering.I am listening to both partcipants and i think sa re ga ma pa they are far superior.no doubt.do u agree.The judges r more refined here ofcourse.

pl see to that hemachandra wins as he sings so well.he is perfect in his sur and tall and what a deep voice .pl vote for him

Originally posted by: amukta

When compared to sa re ga ma pa singers esp girls they r far superior.farah is emphasizing too much on perfomance---dancing so siging is suffering.I am listening to both partcipants and i think sa re ga ma pa they are far superior.no doubt.do u agree.The judges r more refined here ofcourse.

pl see to that hemachandra wins as he sings so well.he is perfect in his sur and tall and what a deep voice .pl vote for him

I beg to differ. None of the SRGMP girls(Or guys) are better in any way.

Originally posted by: FrenchieRox

I beg to differ. None of the SRGMP girls(Or guys) are better in any way.

no way dude!! srgmp contestants were far better when it comes to the girls at least!! i wasn't at all impressed with the girls of indian idol..but look at the talents of nihira, himani, ujjaini and so on...they were far better in every aspect!!

Actually performance not means that u have to dance & all...It means u shoudl feel or enjoy the song....

Even Ravi didnt dance or something liek that...he chose that type of song also that time farha liked that....

Abt sagar & meenal they took a dance number & they should enjoy that though both sing well...

If all r praising them then whts the need of judges...
they have to tell the weak points of each...otehrwise hw can they will improve ...

Originally posted by: tia_angel!!!

no way dude!! srgmp contestants were far better when it comes to the girls at least!! i wasn't at all impressed with the girls of indian idol..but look at the talents of nihira, himani, ujjaini and so on...they were far better in every aspect!!

Thats your opinion. The contestants of SRGMP have been hyped to no end.

Vineet is the best singer out of all singing competition shows. Indian Idol contestants are no match for Sa Re Ga Ma Pa contestants, though they are anyday better than the stupid Assam ki Voice, Assam ki Janta ki Choice, Assam ke militants ki Choice- Mr Debojit

YES AMUKTA, I AGREE WITH U. GUYS R FAR BETTER THAN THE GIRLS IN ID.SAREGAMAPA SINGERS R MUCH BETTER THAN THESE SINGERS . THESE ID GIRLS DONT HAVE THE STRENGHT & CONTROL IN THEIR VOICES. AGAIN THESE JUDGES R GIVING TOO MUCH BHAV TO NEHA. SHE IS NOT SO GREAT. I THINK THAT FARAH HAS SOME ATTITUDE PROBLEM.

OK 1 thing I downloaded the song of some of the srgmp contestant and I beg to differ that II2 r not better, infect I feel the same that vineet does not sing in sur at all I know he does not have any training in classical singing but that does not mean that Himark ratmadiya should put him up in the sky just for sympathy sake.

Please download their songs and listen properly and you will know the difference.

And btw this is II2 forum and not SRGMP please post all this crap on the SRGMP forum. 😡 😡

have u heard teh SRGMP girls? They r FANTASTIC? I'd lik to see any of II-2 girls attempt songs lik Chittiye, Hare Rama Hare Krishna, Kehna hi kya with Rehman's bit, or any other song sung by Himani, Nihira etc........they'll be no match.

At the end of the day, its the SRGMP singers tht survive- look at Shreya, Sunidhi, Kunal....Have Abhijeet, rahul, Amit achieved the same as these guys?

Im 100% sure none of the girls frm II-2 can sing lik SRGMP singers.....compare Jyotsna's Oh La LA to Nihira's, compare Antara's rangeela to Nihira's.....II-2 singers r good, SRGMP's are FLAwlESS. And SRGMP singers sing really really tough songs as well.

I think they are focussing too much on performance, hence singing has suffered. I think they must focus on singing first, Janta is going to vote on your singing ability and nothing else. And why don't they sing some of old songs. And on Tuesday, for god's sake can they sing some songs, they devote entire episode annoucing results and zero sining. I liked what Sonu said today, that who wins II2 will get it bec'se of his/her singing.

OT: SRGMP singers are far superior, no doubt. Can you forget Vinit's Tera Jadu Chal Gaya, Nihira's Roz Shaam Aati Thi and other contestants are/were fabulous too.