QUALITY OS SINGING IS BAD - Page 2

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

have u heard teh SRGMP girls? They r FANTASTIC? I'd lik to see any of II-2 girls attempt songs lik Chittiye, Hare Rama Hare Krishna, Kehna hi kya with Rehman's bit, or any other song sung by Himani, Nihira etc........they'll be no match.

At the end of the day, its the SRGMP singers tht survive- look at Shreya, Sunidhi, Kunal....Have Abhijeet, rahul, Amit achieved the same as these guys?

Im 100% sure none of the girls frm II-2 can sing lik SRGMP singers.....compare Jyotsna's Oh La LA to Nihira's, compare Antara's rangeela to Nihira's.....II-2 singers r good, SRGMP's are FLAwlESS. And SRGMP singers sing really really tough songs as well.

100% agree with u

please dont compare dancers of II with singers of SRgmp

i think sony is highly influenced by FG to make II also in the same vein

i think sonu himself hinted that only good singers will stay for long

all the others will just fade away by the next season of II

whereas nihira will go on to rock bollywood

Originally posted by: amukta

When compared to sa re ga ma pa singers esp girls they r far superior.farah is emphasizing too much on perfomance---dancing so siging is suffering.I am listening to both partcipants and i think sa re ga ma pa they are far superior.no doubt.do u agree.The judges r more refined here ofcourse.

pl see to that hemachandra wins as he sings so well.he is perfect in his sur and tall and what a deep voice .pl vote for him

totally agree!!!!!!!! there's hardly any talent in indian idol besides karunya, amey, and maybe antra... sa re ga ma pa has amazing mindblowing talent that you cant decide which one deserves to win more!! just look at nihira - the next lata!! indian idol contestants are ok but def nothing compared to sa re ga ma pa contestants!

Yes I would agree that singers in sa re ga ma pa are better than indian idol from singing point of view.

Will somebody stop this crap ? Why on earth are we comparing the 2 shows. Both are completely different shows. SRGP is an out n out singing show. The max that the contestants do is wave a hand here n there or 1 or 2 steps. Whereas II is looking for the complete package. I'm not saying that we need to focus more on performing but come on..would you like someone going on to the stage and close here eyes and start singing. I bet that if you put all the so called singers of SRGP thru the same test as II contest they will fail miserably. I agree that girls of II2 are really pathetic..but there have been some good talent thrown out by janta..dilpreet,..ritu. But remember 1 thing II may have less good singers but they are really flawless. The amount of control that Amey and Karunya show in their singing is beyond praising and not to forget they can perform too. Also please keep in mind that Amey was once a SRGP finalist. Please listen to his songs..koi na jaane(he was 17 then)..and some of his marathi songs as well..such command over classical singing is hard to find...all srgp singers combined cannot match that. Yes SRGP has more number of good singers but II has less but amazingly gifted singers.

pl we talked ofthe girls.karunya and amey are undoubtedly the best.the girls in indian idol 1 were good frm day one.no dispute abt that.you will compare when two musical shows run at the same time.so pl understand.this time i am sure the indian idol girl will soon fade away.The girls in sa re ga ma pa were good right frm begining.whether u like it or not u have to digest this fact.

Originally posted by: vimlend123

...would you like someone going on to the stage and close here eyes and start singing.

Why not, infact I would close my eyes too and enjoy the song provided he/she sings like Vinit/Nihira.....

umm..i agree saregama contestants have stronger voices

but i duno....if i was to go to a concert i wud chose to go to an II's contestant's concert...i dont think ill enjoy saregama's that much

i wud rather listen to saregama contestants than watch them...their voice quality is good but i dont think they have that x-factor singers need on stage

i wud rather enjoy some1 on stage who shows energy and enthusiasm than sum1 who closes their eyes and sings to get perfect SUR

AMEY KI DEEWANI
MRS.MEGHA AMEY DATE 😳