Tia being treated Unfairly

Great!!! Another Tia topic..

For all those who things Tia should be eliminated... I will agree with you, but I want to see he in top 3 just because she is being treated unfairly.


I will not go back to other episodes. I will just discuss today.

Sreeram Vs. Shivam

Shivam was asked to rate Sreeram performance
Then
Sreeram was asked to rate Shivam performance

Lastly Sunidhi gave her points.


Tia Vs. Bhoomi Only

Tia was asked to rate Bhoomi's performance
Sunidhi then rated both Tia and Bhoomi
Lastly Bhoomi was asked to rate Tia's performance

Bhoomi "I will give her the same points as Sunidhi"

I find this wrong and feel politics is being played here.

What you think?

I think Tia has been a scapegoat for a long time and ALL the judges have been more than unfair to her. Their comments are way harsher on her.

And in today's episode on Bhoomi vs Tia. unless the judges have a different ears than us, I think it was very obvious that Bhoomi's singing was very bad (she screamed and screeched through the entire song) and Tia's was not too bad, Yet they put down Tia.

I am really getting frustrated with the judge's politics and I think the janta sees that too. That's why Tia gets enough votes from the janta and i am VERY pleased that Tia stays week after week.

In fact, I cracked up laughing at Sunidhi's reaction last week when Naushad was eliminated. I could she that she was thinking why not Tia?

I request janta to keep voting for Tia just to teach judges a lesson. I'd like to see Tia along with Rakesh and Sreeram in top 3 and Sreeram to win the idol

Yea, I wish the judges weren't THAT harsh on her, poor girl..

I 100 percent agree.

I can't believe what I am about to write...

U know I think judges are clearly showing that they are not liking the idea of Tia getting so many votes specially Sunidhi ....had it been with any other singers i would have understood.... but just against Bhumi ????....Give me a break !!!!!!...She has been singing besuri from day 1 yet nobody is pointing it out ...the sentiment is reflected on the forum too...I have come here after a long break and noted nothing has changed ...same old Tia bashing but hardly any mention of how besuri Bhumi is ..... with few exceptions of course !!!!!

I bet if judges were a bit less harsh in their comments Tia would have been out a long ago. Every season there is one contestant who is constantly judge's target and he/she goes on till almost the end. Last time it was Remo, this time it is Tia. More the judges bash her, more sympathy votes she would get and specially if someone like Bhoomi is there. Of course bith the girls are bitter enemies and one can see it.

Can't we just have a double elimination and get rid of both the women? They are both getting on my nerves.

Does any one think it in this way...... Judges are wantedly playing these games to untreat Tia so that ppl give her sympathy votes. Guys grow up. Judges tell what they wanted to tell, but we should choose the best person who deserves to be an Idol. Y you all get carried away with this kind of sympathy & start giving votes to Tia. According to me she is here today because of her sympathy votes. People vote her because she cried or because judges treated her bad.

Originally posted by: coolasice

Does any one think it in this way...... Judges are wantedly playing these games to untreat Tia so that ppl give her sympathy votes. Guys grow up. Judges tell what they wanted to tell, but we should choose the best person who deserves to be an Idol. Y you all get carried away with this kind of sympathy & start giving votes to Tia. According to me she is here today because of her sympathy votes. People vote her because she cried or because judges treated her bad.

Regarding Bhoomi & Tia sony is editing & showing us what they want us to see. When you watch extra listen to Tia's comments. She commented good about every one EXCEPT BHOOMI. About bhoomi she told that she is unable to understand her, but rest all told that she is Very Matured person. How come Tia is able to understand all her contestants except Bhoomi, because according to her Bhoomi is only one who is opposite her in Girls, because all the other girls are eliminated now. Once Bhoomi will go she will start talking about some one else.

So Pls I request all not to go on looks or beauty. Please Rate by the voice. This is a Singing Competiton not a Fashion Show. If you all want then Encourage TIA to Join some Modelling & support her to join Fashiong Indeustry. Anyways, she is doing her FASHION DESINGNING COURSE. So ENCOURAGE Her in that field.

NO OFFCNCE.

I agree but there are two aspects to it first I dont think Tia is getting much votes for her looks. She is getting it because of sympathy. Second most people cant be discreet. In a reality show, people starts to relate things with the contestants right from name to region etc, all things counts including people relating to themselves to ones victims of redicule or bias from their peers or elders or teachers etc for being a bit less talented than others which is the case here. I am not saying that should happen but that is how human psyche works. If you see even in this forum till maybe last week there were hardly any Tia fans now the numbers are increasing and it would continue to increase when judges start treating someone like dirt, specially if people start perceiving judges as biased which is the case here