Tia being treated Unfairly

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

lily1991

@lily1991

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#21

You shut up Dhruv. Tia will win.

Quote

rimjimbristi

@rimjimbristi

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#22

After reading all the comments I just want to say one thing...this is singing competition and deserving candidate should win. Teaching a good lesson to judges wont effect them.It will effect us and we will get a horrible idol for the nation who will annoy us by his/her singing.I m not against anyone.It's just a msg to all plz do vote for deserving candidate and u have every right to vote for ur favourite .

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

neelpankh

@neelpankh

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#23

I agree 100% that TIA is being treated harshly by the judges. Her performance on the 12th was not all that bad - swaroop was off key, bhoomi was off key and even rakesh was not at his best and they go hugging him and giving him another bike !! If you look at the earliest performances TIA's were really good (bounce baby bounce and sexy lady on the floor and the Pyarelal episode) but then they killed her confidence by asking each contestant who should be out and everyone said TIA. And then Sunidhi (TIA thinks the world of her) came down so harshly on her that the poor soul completely lost her confidence. Why did Anu Malik give her only 3.5 marks yesterday when he had a huge grin while she was singing?

I find the whole situation disgusting ...

Quote

Padmajaan

@Padmajaan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#24

Typical reactions most. Sympathy wave. Bull****!

Maybe you are right about Bhoomi I do not know. Yes she is not great I admit but Tia is far worse and does not have the calibre or the raison d'etre to be there any more.

Why compare Tia to Bhoomi before declaring that she should go on to top3 just because Bhoomi is equally bad or worse? Why want her to go on to top 3 just because you find that the judge's comments are harsh and biaised? What kind of logic is this?

Even you guys admit that she is far from being perfect or even good.

Then why compare? Why react to judge's reactions? Don't you have a mind of your own? Don;t you have ears? Don;t you have a mind that can make its own judgment?

If yes, then tia must go as she doesnt match up to the level required. She is not ready yet. maybe one day...?? but not right now.

This decision has nothing to do with whether bhoomi should go or whether swaroop should go and so on and so forth. And the decision should not be based on just the last performance by now!! The question is whether she matches up, whether she is consistent in her performance, whether she is confident (irrespective of the whyfores for her lack of confidence, if she is a true artist and singer and participant she should rise beyond all this) in her performance, whether she is pucca on sur and taal, whether she is versatile and so on and so forth.

In India we have made huge blunders because of sympathy waves in all arenas of life be it personal life and big decisions related to it, public life, political life and so on and we all know the consequences thereof.

So please behave mature, ask yourself just one question: is Tia good enough to stay on irrespective of any other parameter. If your answer is no your decision should be clear, isnt it?????

Padma

Quote

kichwamaji

@kichwamaji

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#25

Accepted the judges may have been a tad harsh on Tia.....has that helped her any? Looks like she really couldn't care less as audience will vote for her looks....she needs to come back with a vengence...nothing more...looks like she lacks the will...

Bhoomi is just awful...Tia is besuri sometimes, but she has a good voice texture....After the last few galas, Bhoomi has really fallen short of quality singing and versatility and her unique voice is not going to take her places...

Just my POV

Quote

1 2 3

Tia being treated Unfairly - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics