Spoiler - 2nd elimination .....

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

472195

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#31

Meghna was a gud singer....
But even am not very OK wid her elimination....She was for sure better than Tia...

Quote

pavelonmove

@pavelonmove

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#32

thanks for mentioning the source Shubham...
.
.

.
Powell

Indian Idol 5 Orkut Community Moderator...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

pallavi25

@pallavi25

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#33

I knew it! Meghna sings much better than Tia and Manisha but she was eliminated because of her handicap and her appearance. Even the judges were very mean to her as far as appreciation is concerned. Her sur taal was perfect everytime but judges were miserly with their praise. They wanted her out!
Manisha shd have been out as she completely messed up Zara Zara touch me.... her voice is guttural and awful in most songs.

Quote

472195

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: pallavi25
I knew it! Meghna sings much better than Tia and Manisha but she was eliminated because of her handicap and her appearance. Even the judges were very mean to her as far as appreciation is concerned. Her sur taal was perfect everytime but judges were miserly with their praise. They wanted her out!
Manisha shd have been out as she completely messed up Zara Zara touch me.... her voice is guttural and awful in most songs.

Yes...
But the last performance lacked some feel...Meghna is capable of doing sooo much better....
She was one of my favrts in d competition...

Quote

sushrutapandey

@sushrutapandey

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#35

I don't think Meghna is very good. She is very limited in her singing and goes off-sur a lot of times. She has a good voice but completely lacks expression except for certain types of songs. Plus, she has not been showing much improvement from week to week.

Quote

-swati-

@-swati-

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#36

I am feeling sad for Meghana.. purely based on performance Manisha was the worst..
So this elimination is not fair...
Somehow anu mallick always puts her down...she is not getting any good suggestions from judges...her voice is sweet...I personally liked her

Quote

fungrl

@fungrl

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#37

I am sorry but Manisha was horrible when she sang her last song, she literally stopped and feigned innocence that the orchestra stopped playing !!!! come on She deserves to go before Meghna. I thought this was a singing competition not how pretty someone looks.

I concur that Meghna didn't sing with quite the intense feeling required, if Swaroop gets all the accolades for being the odd one out imagine Meghna who can see anything, let alone how people's expression change when they speak how can she work on something when the concept of facial expression does not exists for her..

I guess being overweight is a crime compared to singing off key and stopping in the middle if you are pretty.

God the audience is so shallow