Spoiler - 2nd elimination ..... - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

6.4k

Users

29

Likes

57

Frequent Posters

kamsocho thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: fungrl

I am sorry but Manisha was horrible when she sang her last song, she literally stopped and feigned innocence that the orchestra stopped playing !!!! come on She deserves to go before Meghna. I thought this was a singing competition not how pretty someone looks.

I concur that Meghna didn't sing with quite the intense feeling required, if Swaroop gets all the accolades for being the odd one out imagine Meghna who can see anything, let alone how people's expression change when they speak how can she work on something when the concept of facial expression does not exists for her..

I guess being overweight is a crime compared to singing off key and stopping in the middle if you are pretty.

God the audience is so shallow



meghna is brilliant and can become II5
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: pakeezah

i knew meghna would be leaving pretty soon but i was so hoping it would have been manisha or yashraj

i dont like yashrajs attitude nor do i think he is anything special in singing; shashi and sreeram and even rakesh run circles round him in his genre of singing

i dont like the way manisha sits close to nasuhad kawa whenever she can, stupid female, she better leave the guy alone

i get ulcers thinking kawa will be eliminated every time; doesnt help he seems to be putting on weight and losing his concentration and even dressing bad and not paying attention to his appearance, scruffy hair and all, someone pls tell him to buck up

look at shivam he was so scruffy before and how he is improving in appearance, dress up and singing, this boy is gong to to go far, if he gets eliminated soon, Im going to go and throw stones at indian idol office



Hehe... Manisha and Naushad...yes even I've heard along those lines...but I don't think Naushad is loosing concentration ,yes he seems to have deteriorated a bit but he's very talented 😊
I don't think he will get eliminated soon...he has a good fan following...but yes, needs to work hard
Angad_Kripa_200 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: fungrl

I am sorry but Manisha was horrible when she sang her last song, she literally stopped and feigned innocence that the orchestra stopped playing !!!! come on She deserves to go before Meghna. I thought this was a singing competition not how pretty someone looks.

I concur that Meghna didn't sing with quite the intense feeling required, if Swaroop gets all the accolades for being the odd one out imagine Meghna who can see anything, let alone how people's expression change when they speak how can she work on something when the concept of facial expression does not exists for her..

I guess being overweight is a crime compared to singing off key and stopping in the middle if you are pretty.

God the audience is so shallow



Completely agree.... Especially with the bold part.... I have always found Meghna's singing soulful and the only reason the expressions are minimised is because she can't see and hence move around...

It seems like this is more of a fashion show rather than a singing show... Vishwas was a great singer, but according to me the fact that he was married with a kid did not allow him to go further due to the shallowness of the major audience... Shini from last Indian Idol was voted off because she was married... Its seriously pathetic how people with talent are voted off while people with cool hairstyles, skinny jeans and full-on make-up without any talent are kept behind...
shubham150 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: pakeezah

i knew meghna would be leaving pretty soon but i was so hoping it would have been manisha or yashraj

i dont like yashrajs attitude nor do i think he is anything special in singing; shashi and sreeram and even rakesh run circles round him in his genre of singing

i dont like the way manisha sits close to nasuhad kawa whenever she can, stupid female, she better leave the guy alone

i get ulcers thinking kawa will be eliminated every time; doesnt help he seems to be putting on weight and losing his concentration and even dressing bad and not paying attention to his appearance, scruffy hair and all, someone pls tell him to buck up

look at shivam he was so scruffy before and how he is improving in appearance, dress up and singing, this boy is gong to to go far, if he gets eliminated soon, Im going to go and throw stones at indian idol office



YASHRAJ is not gonna go that soon ... doesnt matter u like him or not .... yeah he is actually the real package in II 5 ....... he is good singer .... he has got very very good stage presence ...he has got a style of his own ..... and yeah he is very straight forward ....... that makes him stand out .... he knows what he is doing .... and he do it well ...

and taking of naushad .. i dont think he is detoriating ...he is doing pretty well .. hez a good singer .. and doing pretty well ..

cheekygirl thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: fungrl

I am sorry but Manisha was horrible when she sang her last song, she literally stopped and feigned innocence that the orchestra stopped playing !!!! come on She deserves to go before Meghna. I thought this was a singing competition not how pretty someone looks.

I concur that Meghna didn't sing with quite the intense feeling required, if Swaroop gets all the accolades for being the odd one out imagine Meghna who can see anything, let alone how people's expression change when they speak how can she work on something when the concept of facial expression does not exists for her..

I guess being overweight is a crime compared to singing off key and stopping in the middle if you are pretty.

God the audience is so shallow

I agree. I was expecting a lot from people. I really wanted either Manisha or Yashraj to be eliminated and make Anu Malik to shutup from giving wrong comments.
Manik_mia thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: dinajv

i think that was a fair decision bcuz she was the worst out of all...i didnt lk her song zara touch me at all......



Yes we can not complain for this elimination. Meghna was weak in every episode.
Manisha was the same. If she does not improve any further next time it could be her turn.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".