Rahul Vaidya or Rahul Saexena - Page 7

gamezone if you are hell bent on calling Rahul Vaidya a mimic I cannot say anything to you. 😊

The bottom line over here is you simply cannot compare Rahul Vaidya to Saxena because they both have different voices and what one can sing the other cannot.You cannot compare Sukhwinder Singh with Sonu Nigam. They both are good but one cannot sing what the other can because simply it will not have the same effect.

And tanya thank you for agreeing with me. 😃 I know a guys voice does change till they are about 23-24. Rahul V's voice is more calm of the two that is what I feel.

Originally posted by: nisha655

2 things I would like to comment abt:

1. Sonu did say Rahul V should come in Top 3. What do u mean by calling Rahul V a "mimic"? If he sounds as soothing and flowing as Sonu in this age, it speaks for his immense talent. And its a very simple task to diff Rahul and Sonu's voice these days. Now see if u r determined to make them sound similar or bring someone down only to bring ur fav. up, then there is no further argume

nt to be made.

2. Rahul V also has a lot of depth in his voice. Its just that all the variations and notes he renders are so spontaneous that they sound extremely natural. Did u hear his audition song "Saawan beeta jaaye" or "Madhuban mein radhika" which he sang when he was merely 10 yrs old? I dont think there is any question abt not being deep or strong here.

At the end of the day, I like Rahul V, someone else likes Rahul S. Let it be that way, we can all continue to have our favs cant we?

I wud like to correct u that Firstly Sonu clearly mentioned that Rahul S shud be in Top3 and not Rahul V. If u dont beleive me then go and recheck the auditions of II 1, just dnt blindly argue over things ur unaware of.

And secondly , Rahul has won SRGMP even before many times right from his childhood. He is a composer himself and graduated in music.

We are not telling that Rahul V is bad singer here. but in comparison to Rahul S, he is way too behind. Because of fans merely voting on the basis of looks he cud reach Top3. no doubt i enjoyed his performances.But ultimately he is a loser any which ways in the race. What do u say to this?

at the end of the day if u wanna compare Rahul S and Rahul V purely from the judge's point of view( ppl with vast knowledge in music unlike u and me) Rahul Saxena will and wud have been the winner ,not even Abhijit wud have been.

Vaidya fans Please dont get offended by reading the above .

amisha its not necessary to put down other singer to prove your favourite is best.
Rahul V is the only singer who sonu promised to help and prepare him for the industry.Read rahu V s interview ,sonu has been the most helping hand in his career.When he was voted out sonu just stood up and hugged him as he was so emotional.havnt you observed sonu 's inclination towards rahu v.

Also accept the truth ,that rahul vaidya has been janta 's choice and not Rahul Suxena.It doens nt mean he is any less .He has been working with all good musicians.

its just that Sukhwinder cannot be compared with Sonu and its also fact that sonu is more successful today than sukhwinder for whatever reasons 😊 .

Originally posted by: Amisha123

I wud like to correct u that Firstly Sonu clearly mentioned that Rahul S shud be in Top3 and not Rahul V. If u dont beleive me then go and recheck the auditions of II 1, just dnt blindly argue over things ur unaware of.

And secondly , Rahul has won SRGMP even before many times right from his childhood. He is a composer himself and graduated in music.

We are not telling that Rahul V is bad singer here. but in comparison to Rahul S, he is way too behind. Because of fans merely voting on the basis of looks he cud reach Top3. no doubt i enjoyed his performances.But ultimately he is a loser any which ways in the race. What do u say to this?

at the end of the day if u wanna compare Rahul S and Rahul V purely from the judge's point of view( ppl with vast knowledge in music unlike u and me) Rahul Saxena will and wud have been the winner ,not even Abhijit wud have been.

Vaidya fans Please dont get offended by reading the above .

Amisha123 u r wrong sonu did mention it2 rahul vaidya dat he should be there in top 3 &not rahul saxena,2 rahul saxena he said dat he should be there in top 5.and amisha if u''l write wrong things we will surely correct u

plz guyz do not allow multiple voting otherwise the real result will never cum b4 us
and every knows who is the best so we don't want polls like this coz the result every1 knoiws

Originally posted by: navita_scorpio

Amisha123 u r wrong sonu did mention it2 rahul vaidya dat he should be there in top 3 &not rahul saxena,2 rahul saxena he said dat he should be there in top 5.and amisha if u''l write wrong things we will surely correct u

of course u can correct me if i am wrong but i can never go wrong in this because i have seen it innumerable times.

i dont have a proof right now, but if at all it is aired ever again u can check it ur self, One more thing i am not condemning Rahul.V, he is good there is no doubt abt it. But u guys also shud accept the fact thats all i wanted.

if not also i just wanted to correct what sonu told each of them

Rahul S ---Top3 and Rahul.V --Top 10 in the beginning .

Even if Rahul.V tells this himself some of them wil not accept it, i am 100% sure abt it

remember SONU also said dat INDIAN IDOL WILL BE ONE BUT IF HE HAS TO BE AWARE OF ANY SINGER IN THE FUTURE DAT WILL BE RAHUL VAIDYA....so it doesnt need to write dat RAHUL IS THE BEST...so VAIDYA fans whtever others write against RAHUL VAIDYA just SKIP .....cos HE IS GETTING BETTER DAY BY DAY.. 😊

thanks shefali..ya a guys voice does change till they are about 23-24.

.enjoy the pics in RAHUL VAIDYA topic..i have uploaded many pics there

Originally posted by: shimmeryf

amisha its not necessary to put down other singer to prove your favourite is best.
Rahul V is the only singer who sonu promised to help and prepare him for the industry.Read rahu V s interview ,sonu has been the most helping hand in his career.When he was voted out sonu just stood up and hugged him as he was so emotional.havnt you observed sonu 's inclination towards rahu v.

Also accept the truth ,that rahul vaidya has been janta 's choice and not Rahul Suxena.It doens nt mean he is any less .He has been working with all good musicians.

its just that Sukhwinder cannot be compared with Sonu and its also fact that sonu is more successful today than sukhwinder for whatever reasons 😊 .

yesssssssssssssssssssss......................we have said it all.......👏

SONU said dat rahul vaidya should in top 3 or top 10...u eliminated top part 3 part n changed wht sonu said.. 😆

Rahul saxena will be the best, if we are talking about knowledge of surs and depth of singing.

Rahul saxena rules even if anyone say anything .