Rahul Vaidya or Rahul Saexena - Page 11

Originally posted by: gamezone

After all Sonu is a human being like us.. arre even god also likes the person who is his devotee.. so i wont call this a poor justification..

well said! 👏

Originally posted by: shefali_123

Rahul Vaidya is a different kind of a singer. What he can sing Saxena cannot. If you want just make Rahul Saxena sing some of the songs of Rahul Vaidya's album. I am pretty sure it wont sound good.

Yes Saxena is a very good singer with a different voice but the other Rahul is no less. He has a soothing melodious voice. With time he will get over his Sonu hangover. When Saxena tried to sing that hum dono jaisa hain kaun yaha he fell flat. He cannot sing masti bhara songs. Why?? He just got voted off the next day

How can you say Sukhwinder is more successful than Sonu. Sonu is was and will always remain more successful than Sukhwinder because Sukhwinder's voice just does not permit him to sing all kinds of songs. Can he sing the kal ho naa ho title song. He may get the sur but will it sound as good?? No. They cannotbe compared that does not mean he is not good. He is but there is still a difference.

I know Sonu is a gud singer.. this doesnot make his MIMIC, a singer of his caliber😕😕.. U tell me first...does any mimmicry artist copy u and me???..well, they dont...They always mimic the one who is famous....Similarly for this "MIMICRY SINGER"😆😆

and one more thing...hum dono jaisa, sung by RAHUL S was much better than the original song.. i have just heard the song.. I have both the songs with me... so plz u compare both songs bfore making this BLAHBLAH comments

Originally posted by: Amisha123

Hi everybody read the following thread and get to know what Sonu told to Rahul Saxena.
Hope it clarifies all your doubts and assumptions

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=139808&P N=1& TPN=1

Hey .....very well done....👏👏👏..this shud keep the SENSIBLE rahul V fans quiet.....but not all of them...gr8 link yaar...tx once again

Originally posted by: shefali_123

So what is Rahul Saxena won srgmp. Arpita Mukherjee also did. Will you all say that she has got great depth in voice. I have heard many people say in the fg forums that she cannot sing no matter what people say. Many people do not like her voice because it is screechy but she did win srgmp. Winning srgmp is no certificate of good singing. Kunal Ganjawala, Shreya Ghoshal, Sanjeevani all got picked from srgmp but why hasn't Rahul Saxena been picked after he won . Why he had to come to II to try his luck??

Rahul Vaidya is a different kind of a singer. What he can sing Saxena cannot. If you want just make Rahul Saxena sing some of the songs of Rahul Vaidya's album. I am pretty sure it wont sound good.

Yes Saxena is a very good singer with a different voice but the other Rahul is no less. He has a soothing melodious voice. With time he will get over his Sonu hangover. When Saxena tried to sing that hum dono jaisa hain kaun yaha he fell flat. He cannot sing masti bhara songs. Why?? He just got voted off the next day

How can you say Sukhwinder is more successful than Sonu. Sonu is was and will always remain more successful than Sukhwinder because Sukhwinder's voice just does not permit him to sing all kinds of songs. Can he sing the kal ho naa ho title song. He may get the sur but will it sound as good?? No. They cannotbe compared that does not mean he is not good. He is but there is still a difference.

The same difference btn Saxena and Vaidya. Saxena fans are hell bent on proving him the best singer in the world and they are putting every argument forward to prove that others cannot sing at all. Why if he is good it will be proved.

i am totally agreed..u r absolutely rite!!

well said👏!

gamezone I never said Rahul V is of Sonu's calibre. Can I ever say that. But I was comparing Sukhwinder to Sonu since you mentioned that Sukhwinder is highest paid so naturally he is more successful. I was replying to that. Plz read properly before replying.

hum dono jaisa he sung better than original singer I dont think so. I have heard both the versions many times now. What happened to kambakht ishq then this time. I remember Amit Sana performed the same song Rahul Saxena was no where close.His energy was low and he just couldn't get the feel of the song right. Why?? If he is that good he should be able to sing it then. That shows that he should stick to his genre of tanhaee and upar khuda.I have yet to see him go beyond that and succeed.

Again I say Rahul Saxena is a very good singer no doubt but he has his own niche and so does Rahul Vaidya. They simply cannot sing the same songs and do justice to them. So you still cannot call Rahul Saxena as the best singer of II and fg lot. He is very good but so are all others barring a few in thier own niches.

Originally posted by: gamezone

Hey .....very well done....👏👏👏..this shud keep the SENSIBLE rahul V fans quiet.....but not all of them...gr8 link yaar...tx once again

Yes absolutely. Ur welcome gamezone. May i know ur name?

Originally posted by: shefali_123

gamezone I never said Rahul V is of Sonu's calibre. Can I ever say that. But I was comparing Sukhwinder to Sonu since you mentioned that Sukhwinder is highest paid so naturally he is more successful. I was replying to that. Plz read properly before replying.

hum dono jaisa he sung better than original singer I dont think so. I have heard both the versions many times now. What happened to kambakht ishq then this time. I remember Amit Sana performed the same song Rahul Saxena was no where close.His energy was low and he just couldn't get the feel of the song right. Why?? If he is that good he should be able to sing it then. That shows that he should stick to his genre of tanhaee and upar khuda.I have yet to see him go beyond that and succeed.

Again I say Rahul Saxena is a very good singer no doubt but he has his own niche and so does Rahul Vaidya. They simply cannot sing the same songs and do justice to them. So you still cannot call Rahul Saxena as the best singer of II and fg lot. He is very good but so are all others barring a few in thier own niches.

what are u trying to prove yaar. U want to say that Rahul.V is the best compared to Rahul.S . Is this ur point?

What wil u say when Rahul.V is compared to Arijit singh. then also wil u say the same. U cannot even compare them.

ditto is the case with Rahul.S, One more thing Arijit himself told that Rahul Saxena is the best of the lot and he himself(arijit) is second best when compared to him.

What wil u say to justify all these remarks.

Dont make ur own statements and hell bent upon proving them

If ur making coparisons only on the basis of singing then Rahul.V lost against Amit Sana also who is once again a Superb singer with Original voice. But if ur comparing on the basis of performance then also he is way behind Sana and Qazi. remember this

Amisha u sould stop comparing with who said what .this never porves you point right.u need to see the big picture.
U have so far been only trying to prove what sonu said to RahulS and not to Rahul V.and on thisbasis u r bringing in links and writing even in qoutations .

Does it prove who is best?again dont bring arijit 's statement here bcoz we dont talk of him here .Rahul S and arijit are poles apart in their style.there are ppl out here who vote and experts who comments on their music.

shefali ,me and nisha are just trying to say that rahul V andRahul S areboth getting the share of their success .
in terms of success RahulV is leading thats it .the type of voice Rahul S had may be comparedto SS and rahul vaidya s to sonu.

Originally posted by: gamezone

After all Sonu is a human being like us.. arre even god also likes the person who is his devotee.. so i wont call this a poor justification..

i cant understand one thing abt Rahul V fans....Even when i say anything i have heard from the II show, they dont agree. And if someone tells them he has heard someting from here and there, then too they dont agree. But if somethingspoken In any program or any of ur friend is in Rahul V's Favour they quickly cling on to it....😆😆

So first decide which media u want to believe to......

gamezone when you just cant get the meaning of post then how could i ever get my message across you .
YOU have oly got one point what judges told to whom and on that basis you are ellaborating on everything.

to prove your point u first said sonu said this bcoz Rahul V is his copy.

if u qoute everything what judges told to rahul then plz try to remember the good things abt rahulV too.

if media is only sonu,farah and anu malik then why rahul is now more commercially successful and rahul S is not. 😊


ur understanding is so poor that when i said Sonu is
m ore succesful u hurriedly came up with a link of highest paid singer that shows how much u know of music.all ur supporter are only bringing on the qoutes of judges they dont have anything else to say .
😊

Rahul Sexana...Rahul Vaidhya juz hav looks and gurls r like goin nutz over him...goodness ppl?listen out to Rahul Sexana and compare him to rahul Vaidhya...RS is a versatile singer while RV can only sing romantic songs...oh and ofcourse Amit Sana is above all...