Who wants himesh to not be in future idols - Page 2

The best panel was Vishal, Shekhar and Shreya in Indian Idol Junior . I honestly don’t know why and how Vishal has degraded so much as a judge. I also like Javed Ali too. I liked Neha the first season she judged but now she does too much nautanki.

Originally posted by: Tani91

The best panel was Vishal, Shekhar and Shreya in Indian Idol Junior . I honestly don’t know why and how Vishal has degraded so much as a judge. I also like Javed Ali too. I liked Neha the first season she judged but now she does too much nautanki.

Ya that trio was good. Always liked Shekhar.. Dont know y he prefers to stay off camera.

Javed Ali was great too.. Truly talented

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

I don’t remember Javed on II, but I remember him as a judge on Fame Gurukul. True he can be demotivating, but atleast he tells you your faults.

I’d rather be told my faults, than to believe I’m good and just be eliminated.

Not demotivating as in their singing Or talent.. It was about other stuffs.. Like first u distract with fake link ups, rivalry, competition and then blame them for being distracted.. II3 had lot of such stuff ..The girl was such a good singer.. Best among the girls.

The fact that Vishal has degraded is probably because the show and the talent has degraded. Wo bas adjust kar raha hai

🙋‍♀️ Me me , yes hr n Neha their over actions n not eligible as judges 👎🏼

Like on Saturday, he went nuts on pawandeep's performance. Yes pawan sang well but for hr to be this dramatic, like he went, he didn't know why he is such a big fan and will give him 10 songs and blah blah blah

Then they manipulate pawan to sing a third song on jeetu's request and then further sing the antra again on jeetu's request. Agree pawan was excellent with his mitti number but the extra footage was not fair to other contestants.

They did the same with Danish and his audition to ekta. Again, Danish sings well but please, he is not an actor, especially narrating Ajay devgan's dialouges.

I still felt Ashish did excellent with taki o taki number and was ignored for mausam

Even Saili who always sings Asha bhosle songs sang Lata's sheesha ho ya dil, so amazingly and did not get the mausam

I think judges are stuck on pawandeep, Danish and smp and it scares me. To think others will be eliminated one after other because they will end up in judge's bottom score

Originally posted by: pritirays

hmm not him, this time it is NEHA and VISHAL who are the more irritating ones! NEHA particularly! 🤢

Yes Himesh went OTT for Pawandeep yesterday, that was funny. But that was nothing on how Vishal n Neha react for SMP, when she is breaking all records of noise pollution.

Best get back Sonu Nigam as the judge. Even Shekhar is better judge than Vishal it seems. More composed.

As much as I would like to see it, Sonu Nigam isn't coming back as a judge. He is just as fed up with how much the platform has degraded. He actually demands more money if he doesn't want to come so the channel can't afford him. He actually reveals so much about Indian Idol here. Watch this interview of his from 3:00 to 7:46. 👇🏻👇🏻

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tWF6ubRJMI