Who wants himesh to not be in future idols

I simply cannot stand his over dramatic and biased personality. His jokes truly suck, his obsession with certain contestants is wrong and can affect the morale between contestants and he behaves like a village idiot at times.

There were so many great judges like Shekhar, Shreya, Salim, Farah etc, why are we stuck with him for past 3 seasons?

Vishal is the only judge that deserves to be there, Neha is hit and mostly miss

Himesh is actually the sane one out of the three 😆 And the only one with good musical knowledge.

If u look closely, he goes OTT when he doesn't like someone's performance that much but he needs to praise the person because Vishal and Neha liked it 😆

And when the other two keep the spotlight on themselves then he starts to vocal fry sing 😆

In all honesty if the channel wants Indian Idol to remain a bankable show they need to revamp the entire format. And that includes getting Neha's jija to show making the show about his family. Sony is anyways making money only thru TKSS, Indian Idol, India's Best Dancer, CID reruns...they don't have any good options anymore. Non fiction is their only saving grace so they better make smart decisions.

Of the three judges, Himesh is the most balanced in terms of feedback. Yes he does go all crazy sometimes, but atleast his bias is not as visible as the other two. The other two only like westernized songs and singers.

I think all three judges must go. A judge needs to show no bias and be neutral. It’s okay to work with some of the contestants, because you think telework voice suits your project but going ga ga on screen is an absolute no.

In my opinion the judges should be - a music director, a singer and a lyricist. Each of these has an input in the final outcome of a song and it would be interesting to see their take on such talent.

So far as a judge I’ve really like Shankar Mahadevan - he is to the point, no nonsense and has a good head on his shoulders.

I’d like the judges to be Shankar Mahadevan/Javed Akhtar/ Alisha Chinai

I only like Vishu. I miss the old judges like Anu, Salim

I like himesh,he is passionate about music and has knowledge, vishal is good too,neha needs to go all she does is cry

Neha should be kicked out,she has nothing to say about music,today also she praising anurita beauty like a brainless person,itni sundar lagti hai to koi film khud banayo aur us me anurita ko le lo

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

Of the three judges, Himesh is the most balanced in terms of feedback. Yes he does go all crazy sometimes, but atleast his bias is not as visible as the other two. The other two only like westernized songs and singers.

I think all three judges must go. A judge needs to show no bias and be neutral. It’s okay to work with some of the contestants, because you think telework voice suits your project but going ga ga on screen is an absolute no.

In my opinion the judges should be - a music director, a singer and a lyricist. Each of these has an input in the final outcome of a song and it would be interesting to see their take on such talent.

So far as a judge I’ve really like Shankar Mahadevan - he is to the point, no nonsense and has a good head on his shoulders.

I’d like the judges to be Shankar Mahadevan/Javed Akhtar/ Alisha Chinai

True.. Out of these 3 Himesh is the only good one. Mausam badal diya should have an auto mute button..

Shankar Mahadevan was best.. So was Udit Narayan.

But didnt like Javed Akhtar.. He and Anu Malik were very demoralizing in earlier seasons.. Cant forget one particular episode with Deepali Sahay. Though no complaints on their knowledge. Same with Alisha.

And with the quality of singers this season it must be super awkward for Neha to sit n judge them.. Guess thats the reason she sticks to just one line

Neha Kakkar, Badshah, and Tanishk Bagchi are what's wrong with bollywood music today. Nothing but remixes. No originality.

Originally posted by: niyati13

True.. Out of these 3 Himesh is the only good one. Mausam badal diya should have an auto mute button..

Shankar Mahadevan was best.. So was Udit Narayan.

But didnt like Javed Akhtar.. He and Anu Malik were very demoralizing in earlier seasons.. Cant forget one particular episode with Deepali Sahay. Though no complaints on their knowledge. Same with Alisha.

And with the quality of singers this season it must be super awkward for Neha to sit n judge them.. Guess thats the reason she sticks to just one line

I don’t remember Javed on II, but I remember him as a judge on Fame Gurukul. True he can be demotivating, but atleast he tells you your faults.

I’d rather be told my faults, than to believe I’m good and just be eliminated.

hmm not him, this time it is NEHA and VISHAL who are the more irritating ones! NEHA particularly! 🤢

Yes Himesh went OTT for Pawandeep yesterday, that was funny. But that was nothing on how Vishal n Neha react for SMP, when she is breaking all records of noise pollution.

Best get back Sonu Nigam as the judge. Even Shekhar is better judge than Vishal it seems. More composed.