Originally posted by: Lodestar
There can never be any comparison of level of transparency & emotional support of Adi-Imlie to Adi-Didi. There was just no emotional connect beyond the token you are my selected life partner.
Let's take example of Adi being worried for Nishant only after he fainted suddenly on V Day. Adi was shook by the incident. He was supportive & calm in front of the family but he was vulnerable on his own. It was not as if he didn't try to tell Didi his feelings about it. Yes he was not as vulnerable as he is with Imlie but he was not shutting Didi off. He actually was trying to seek some emotional support by letting her know how shook he was after Nishant suddenly fainted & mann main negative thoughts hi aa rahe the. But Didi as usual was on her own trip about getting negative thoughts about seeing the clothes ka receipt😆. That line of talk then suddenly forced Adi to close off about his fears for Nishant. Coincidentally it was Imlie who was also thinking about Nishant's condition during the same time. I mean all fam members must have been worried about Nishant's condition only but Didi was on some another suspicion tangent altogether😆.
There are many other incidents where Adi was genuinely seeking emotional support from Didi but she could never give it. Like when he revealed to her the truth of being forcefully married off to Imlie before his & Didi's marriage. Didi herself fainted & his hope for support from her also went down the drain.
Didi was always too involved with herself to look beyond herself & give any sense if support to Adi or anyone else. That is why Adi & her relationship could never transition into a more stronger bond after the marriage. They were stuck at the baseline due to Didi's inability to give understanding & support to Adi beyond the token everything will be OK.
Adi-Imlie on the other hand just grew strength to strength in their emotionally transparent bond & became each others safe place.
Lodestar, same pinch. I thought the exact same thing when I saw how Imlie sambhaloed him during his breakdown, and mentioned it in my earlier post as well. Even now when I rewatch the episode one thing always stands out. Didi was always to self absorbed to be able to see Adi beyond what she needed from him. Be it understand his point of view, or realise when he needs emotional support. She never was willing to go beyond the surface level maak that Adi wears to face the world.
Adi has always been a very private person. Being a journalist, and one that fights against the system has hardened him in a way where he is usually very cynical and sees what can go wrong in every situation. But his sense of righteousness has always propelled him to do the right thing no matter the consequences, even if it may cost him his life. Malini has always just interacted with only that facade that he has presented to the world and appealed to his sense of responsibility and assumed it to be his entire personality. She assumed his sense of zimmedari for her as love for her and that was why she never went beyond that. That was why even during the VDay incident when Nishant fainted, her entire focus was on bringing back the sui from Nishant to her to in the hurry to get her guilt of her chest and go back to the status quo she was comfortable with. Malini wanted to ensure that by confessing her doubts to him, she would avoid a further situation, where because she was hiding things from him, or she misunderstood him, Adi's sense of righteousness may change his feelings towards her. She could not even contemplate at that time that Adi was nowhere in the frame of mind to even comprehend what she was saying. That disconnect was glaringly obvious today, when Adi did not have to say a word and Imlie understood what he felt. Even though he was breaking down, she gave him his space till he pulled her close. I loved that she let Adi decide how Imlie was to console him. That was a big thing, because many times when we watch our partners in a situation where they need comfort, we decide how they get that comfort from us, rather than give them the space to decide how they want to be comforted. That little bit where by standing outside the room and then just holding him till he pulled her for a hug was what elevated the entire scene. Because that one bit showed that both of them will always be there whenever the other wants, but will not thopo their decision on the other.
Adi ne hamesha apne aap ko patthar, pahaad ya chattan bulaya hai, which somewhere I feel is wrong. Woh pahad nahi hai, he really is a coconut. Sakht hai, tough hai, but internally bahut vulnerable hai. Aur woh vulnerability sirf Imlie ko hi dikhai deta hai. Forbthe world he is very strong and tough, but actually he is a very sweet, simple and emotionally driven person. His own family has only seen glimpses of it due to Imlie, but Imlie has long before cracked that surfcae and connected with his core. So breaking apart in front of her is something that he knows he can do without fear of any judgement or having to keep that facade. Similarly she also has now opened up to him to showcase her insecurities that she never showed to anyone else, not even the T family. She knows that no matter what, Adi will understand where she comes from and will find a solution for her problems rather than make fun of her. Today showed that Adi also is willing to completely put his aan, baan aur shaan in Imlie's hands in the vishwaas that no matter what bewakoofi or plan she executes, she will ensure ke uske rehte, BS ki seriuos patrakar wali shaan pe aanch nahi aayegi.