Originally posted by: Anvi2009
I think the only way Imlie will accept her haq on Aditya is if Malini gives up her haq willingly. I do not see it happening any other way. They can make Malini as black a character as they want but it will not change Imlie's mind. Imlie not taking her haq back by herself or fighting for it has less to do with Malini and more to with her own personality. Right now she thinks only Malini has haq on Aditya and she has no right over what belongs to Malini, therefore she will not fight for it. And fighting with Malini is out of the picture, impossible. Aditya-Malini married legally with both their agreements. Unless Malini leaves her haq by divorcing or separating from Aditya permanently, Imlie will not do anything about her haq. And I have no issue with it.
My issue with Imlie in past 2 episodes is not because she does not see Aditya's POV or the whole picture or the future yet. All that is understandable. Imlie needs time and space. She needs to be not traumatized by Malini constantly. She needs patience from Aditya. She needs guidance from Rupu di. So yeah, her not understanding Aditya or not supporting him is totally fine. My issue is that in the past 2 episodes, she is blindly seeing things only from Malini's side. I did not like her stopping Aditya from speaking with his own mother or her blackmailing him to bring Malini back. All that can still be forgotten if in yesterday's episode she did not put her dreams aside just because Malini is not at home. This is a big blunder I think writers did about Imlie's characterization. Imlie not supporting Aditya is one thing, it is tolerable. But Imlie forgetting about her dadda and amma's dreams, about Aditya's sacrifice to take her to her exam, about her lifelong dream, about completely losing herself, acting like a zombie, because of Malini is not the Imlie I have come to know. She can be sad about everything going on but she cannot willingly sacrifice her education for Malini...that is hard no, not by saying that how can she fulfill her dream if Malini's dream is not being fulfilled. So my issue is there. Didi bhakti will stay forever, that is not going anywhere. But nothing should come above her education. Aditya did not come above it, Malini and her guilt/shame should not also. This, writers should never mess with.
And Aditya does not need Imlie's support to speak the truth. Yes, her standing by his side supporting him will give him strength. If it was any other man, he would wait. Would fake a relationship with Malini and wait for Imlie to support him. But it is not in Aditya's personality, his core characterization, to wait to speak the truth. He is extremely honest about his emotions. He was 100% right that what Aditya-Imlie are doing now will be gunah if he stays quiet. It is not that they are having an affair behind Malini's back, they are married after all and it is more about their feelings for each other rather than actions. But not telling Malini the truth ASAP is wrong also. His relationship with Malini is a separate matter from Imlie, and he needs to sort the mess about his relationship whether Imlie supports him or not. It is also not that Aditya-Imlie love will go away if they disagree with each other. But they also have to be true to themselves. Imlie is being true to herself by not fighting for her haq and Aditya is being true to himself by wanting to speak the truth. So the problem is not with Imlie not supporting or understanding Aditya, the problem is Imlie forgetting about her education, stopping Aditya from doing what he thinks is right so that he can have some peace in his life, and lastly, blindly only thinking about Malini.