Logic v/s Faith - Page 16

Created

Last reply

Replies

174

Views

11.9k

Users

22

Likes

854

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: PPak

Areyaar - when you get a chance would you be interested in writing a thread from Imlie's point of view the story to date? I start thinking about what has transpired from her pov - its hard for me to understand it fully. Till aDi wedding - I could understand her staying at Adi's ...after that I cannot see what her basis for wanting to stay with T's was. She is quite strong emotionally and far thinking...what made her settle for status quo with no plans for future...until Adi actually took matter in to his hands and kind of pre-empted her decision to leave. Why did she not leave earlier when Malini entered? I have some thoughts - but I thought it ill be good to see what everyone thoughts are. Meethi attributing all of Imlie's problems to NN is what got me thinking. Also Imli did say in one episode that NN actually shows her affection in a negative manner - never saw any sign of this - unless gettign Imli married to Adi was her idea of doing Imli a favor.


To understand Imlie's thinking, one has to set aside expectations of "logic". 😆......Imlie is a mix of paradoxes.....a village girl who has deep faith/belief in God, in the sanctity of rituals/relationships, but also has an independent mindset...these two things don't generally co-exist in a person from her background.


As she mentioned in yesterday's epi also, she runs on faith more than logic. I'm guessing your expectation is that she should have left after Adi married Malini? She did leave for PD then, didn't she? 😆....but destiny brought her back to Adi's life and his home with a gunshot....so maybe your question is about why she continued to stay at the Tripathis after recovering from her gunshot injury?


Overall I think there is a mix of reasons for why Imlie stayed back with the Tripathis.....firstly, as she told Adi in the hospital convo, she believes him to be her husband even as she understands he doesn't accept her as his wife.....this sounds like a statement without logic....lol so again, it's Imlie....this is about her faith more than what is rational/logical. She had nowhere else to go in that phase.....couldn't go back to PD cuz it was too dangerous. Education could be her ticket out but as we've seen she needed help/guidance there too....she's in the city now and she doesn't know her way around like she did in her village. No one in the story thought to push her education/college admission until they wanted to move the story.....lol so it didn't move.....and Imlie was content in her existence because again, her faith was enough for her even if she didn't have anyone else....that's how she saw it.


Once she was in the house, she became such a close part of it that it just became more difficult day by day to extract herself....she feels attached to Adi's family cuz she considers them her own now too....so she kept on staying....cuz again this is a girl who considers people her own without any expectations from them.


Imlie has been caught in her own conundrum all this while.....her beliefs ask that she do her part in being true to her marriage even if she gets nothing out of it....not even acknowledgement.....and conversely, her dreams have still been inside her somewhere - asking that she follow her wish to study, to become an officer like she had dreamt for so long....but she pushed aside the dreams for a bit to keep the sanctity of her beliefs alive.


Imlie is one of those rare cases who will do her part in respecting rituals even as she has the self-awareness that they aren't always fair to women....she pointed this out in yesterday's diya scene too.


Then there's the angle that she actually did become emotionally attached to Adi beyond just looking at him as her husband.....she became even more closely attuned to his every mood, the swing of his emotions, the few smiles she could pull out of him....even as her future seemed in limbo, the relationship built on the side.


Now finally the point of why she left.....because Adi attacked her faith/belief.....and that was in a sense the ONLY anchor she had left in her life....everything else got taken away from her.....her dreams, her husband, her choices.....faith was all that was carrying her through all this uncertainty....and Adi questioned that when he told her to find another husband....that is why that broke her and she finally left.....even though nothing else had changed and she'd still go back to facing danger in PD.....she already knew he considered her a burden....but this was the straw that broke her cuz it was the only thing she had to hold on to.....and so she left.


Her independent mindset didn't suddenly spring up when she decided to leave and told him she can manage on her own.....it was there all along....what changed was that she was hurt enough to react to this degree. Imlie is intelligent and knows her capabilities but she also struggles with motivation because she feels adrift due to her current situation....she wants to move forward but she also feels this great pull towards Adi now that has grown in all the time they've spent together......so that's where she is currently I think.....emotionally strong enough to survive on her own but her heart keeps pulling her back to Adi too......and to tie this in with Mithi's declaration that Imlie is a mashaal/torch.....the point of all of this is that Imlie prevails in the toughest of odds and only comes out burning with a brighter flame.....to the point now where the husband that she never wanted is now supporting her through the toughest of times.

Edited by AreYaar - 4 years ago
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago

Amazing explained, AY 👏That’s totally Imlie 😊

Basically, it all comes down to Faith for her. Imlie stayed because of her belief/faith, she left because of her faith/belief and if she goes back, it will be for the same reason. Thats her strength and her weakness. It helped her to survive in the toughest of situations and it can make her do the weirdest things. It helped her in moving mountains( wining Aditya’s heart) and it is also helping her in being a mountain currently. Also, between her belief and her dreams, Imlie will always choose her belief/faith like she did during her examination. It’s might sound illogical but that’s just her.

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: pamk06

Amazing explained, AY 👏That’s totally Imlie 😊

Basically, it all comes down to Faith for her. Imlie stayed because of her belief/faith, she left because of her faith/belief and if she goes back, it will be for the same reason. Thats her strength and her weakness. It helped her to survive in the toughest of situations and it can make her do the weirdest things. It helped her in moving mountains( wining Aditya’s heart) and it is also helping her in being a mountain currently. Also, between her belief and her dreams, Imlie will always choose her belief/faith like she did during her examination. It’s might sound illogical but that’s just her.


Thanks, Pam! And you've put it perfectly here in bold too👏


Imlie's faith is both her strength and weakness.....it can become her support system and also a roadblock for her, depending on the situation....but she is consistent in putting her faith/belief above all else.....yes, even her dreams. It may not seem practical, especially to those of us conditioned in a modern upbringing, but that is who she is.


This is fiction, and Imlie is our heroine here😆.....so the beauty of the story is that even as she sacrifices her dreams for her beliefs, she is rewarded in the long run with her dreams still managing to be actualized in a different manner. She was willing to give up her exam/her dream for Adi....so destiny made Adi the instrument that carried her to the examination hall against all odds.


It takes a long/winding/difficult road but sooner or later her faith rewards her and keeps moving her towards achieving her dreams :)

Whatever765 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 4 years ago

Such beautifully written posts here (loved Imlie's POV) I just hope the CV's actually visit this forum because if they don't they should- they will surely have a blockbuster on their hands if they are taking notes..! After IPKKND, this is the first time I am reading the analysis, opinions, thoughts, ramblings on a show...and so worth it.👏 Took me 10 years to appreciate the leads and in general the production quality. I believe there was a post somewhere regarding viewership. I am one of those who just started watching the show because of the Adi and Imlie jodi and not Malini and Adi, I basically just forward those parts. I do laugh at some of the obnoxious circumstances that has got the story to this point, but again we are in a fictitious world and just like Adi says, I wonder-" why does it feel so right"?! The reason being the surreal leads and their candid dialogues!

Edited by Whatever765 - 4 years ago
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Whatever765

I am completely off-post here but I have a curious question- what are these exams that Imlie is giving after studying the Pegasorus theorem and not the chintu pintu theorems?!

Not sure about the Delhi side and what those were but in the Mumbai ( MH) there are board exams at the end of the 12th year based on your stream. They are mandatory for anyone who wants to take admission for further studies in College. It’s a statewide examination. Then there are also entrance exams for medical, engineering, law etc if you want go in that field. Not sure what Imlie’s were and if they were board how they got over in a day as they test you for all subjects but well that just cinematic liberty 😊


Edited by pamk06 - 4 years ago
wizardofoz2 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 4 years ago

Superb episode and intense precap adi begging forforgiveness from imlie. Literally no words for GM and ST. Babusahib experiences the first pangs of extreme jealousy looking at imlie and prakash. The scene between adilie where he bursts out at her and asks her to marry prakash, GM hit it out of the park.ST beyond awesome in the last scene🥳. Writer ko bohot saari jhappiyaan🤗.

Edited by wizardofoz2 - 4 years ago
MuteButton thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Kambakth apologize karega 😆 For every single thing he told her during that bike conversation.


How does she not return with him now

Akand2011 thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

I think its better for imlie to go to Delhi with Adi. He messed up her stay too much in PD.

wizardofoz2 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: MuteButton

Kambakth apologize karega 😆 For every single thing he told her during that bike conversation.


How does she not return with him now


Have a feeling he will apologize and try to persuade her to come with him. But in the meantime dev aa jaayega aur wo shayad convince karke le jaayega both imlie and meethi. He will not tell his family after bringing them there.I still dont see how adi can bring her back.

Edited by wizardofoz2 - 4 years ago
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: MuteButton

Kambakth apologize karega 😆 For every single thing he told her during that bike conversation.


How does she not return with him now


Really... she is going to go back...haaye **me doing the dhol dance like Aditya**😆😆


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".