What exactly is going wrong with Humsafars? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

4.5k

Users

18

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: prettypri

Vandy I updated my post with further rants😆

And did you see tbe on location video of Arzoo selling clothes...again it's Arzoo and her sisters and then sarfaraz and his wife there ...icing on the cake...that track also is dedicated to everyone other than Sahir and arzoo😕
Maybe we will have Sahir for 2 minutes there too!

yea i saw🥱
y is it even a track?
y is sahir asking her to sell clothes?
sahir has a deadline to meet and if jannat's main designer is aarzoo...she should be in office busy creating her designs...rather than wasting time...

saiyyara doesn't need a makeshift stall in the mall to sell its stuff

and who buys clothes from such stalls in a mall?
which shop will allow u to set up a stall outside theirs?
VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

di why isnt gul involved in the creative dept ?


how will i know?

i just ppl posting on the forum and elsewhere that she's not looking into humsafars
Ecrivain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#13


Oh Vandy I so agree with u ...and u know I can overlook anything , even The bloopers but the SCRIPT is an issue Here

The way the sequences pop up, with disjoint background ...I don't know what to Exocet

Cos eventually , the show n The characters n the CHMEISTRY n love scenes of the leads all Depends upon the SCRIPT ..n if tht is weak ..then I don't know wht to say now
prettypri thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: -vandy-

yea i saw🥱
y is it even a track?
y is sahir asking her to sell clothes?
sahir has a deadline to meet and if jannat's main designer is aarzoo...she should be in office busy creating her designs...rather than wasting time...

saiyyara doesn't need a makeshift stall in the mall to sell its stuff

and who buys clothes from such stalls in a mall?
which shop will allow u to set up a stall outside theirs?


Shivya seemed to be explaining that Arzoo wants to prove that people will buy good stuff irrespective of brand name...!
So I think that's what it is... She points out he didn't trust her and probably goes overboard and he challenges her about the fact that only design wouldn't be of use if it didn't have his backing!

But there is a time and place for such clothes... I don't think off the shelves people will buy expensive clothes... But they are going to show that She wins I bet!
VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: prettypri

You covered all the issues pretty well!

I think the main issue is lack of screen space for Sahir...and little interaction between Sahir and Arzoo...that's the death knell for a show promoted as a love story! And in this scenario airing promos where Sahir suddenly questions his feelings and even better...suddenly asks himself if he is in love...just don't cut it..they just confuse the viewers more!

Monday episodes need to be more like what we had last week...atleast the leads were seen...the editing was better...yesterday's episode would likely put off people from watching the show...!

Too too many side characters...side according to the definition of the show,...but they are taking up most of the episode time! And none of them make any sense...

Anam...she hates Arzoo and wants her out as Alvira brought her...but the credit she gives herself is too much...and the acting is bad! However she probably is the only villain I understand as a villain for now... besides Alvira who may or may not be totally bad!

Besides these I don't see why there are so many characters..

Kurti is the worst... bad acting.. Doesn't make sense.. Repetitive... All negative.. Unnecessary melodrama! They haven't established why alvira tolerates her so it's really difficult to watch her!

Zara... why bring in her angle so soon... If at all then it should have been wrt zaki... not an am...too much time wasted!

I don't like Nausheen... especially as she is also repetitive.. Character not explained... Why is she this way.. Why lie about the rent... Why meet sarfaraz... why why

Sarfaraz and his wife... Looks like they will also get more screen time and that's not something to look forward to!

Over all Arzoos character falls flat for me... I don't feel any sympathy or empathy for her.. Because her actions are contrary to her great claims! If there is an attempt to make her look good by butchering sahir there will be even less empathy!

Mainly they need to start focusing on the leads! Get a start to the story... Decide if you are going to show love... Work towards it...
This is really choppy right now!


kurti should be kicked out of the show with immediate effect😳
we just need one villain in the show...let anam be there...BUT...a villain does not need so much screen presence...anam seems to be plotting day n night!
show her as a professional villain...who just has vice against aarzoo...only in office...coz sahir needs to be be there to protect aarzoo...esp now wen he'll know that anam can stoop to the lowest degree against aarzoo...

sahir is a designer...show saaz together where both work together professionally...
he can't give crappy challenges to aarzoo..its just wasting screen time...
if sahir wants to punish aarzoo for creating a ruckus abt the stolen designs...he should give her a night's dealine to finish the jannat collection's designs...that'll be more logical!

keep aarzoo's family out of her professional life...i seriously can't tolerate her family's melodrama every single day!...they should be shown only if they have a contribution to a saaz scene...otherwise we do not need them on screen

aarzoo's character😳
its like u know...modern jhansi ki rani-cum kiran bedi- cum sonia gandhi- cum mamta banerjee- cum-every other female nautanki baaz we have in india right now!

too much screen time is being wasted on making her jack of all trades!
yesterday they wasted time on showing her searching for the dupatta again...wen that scene could've been cut short with zara immediately saying she sold the dupatta and then aarzoo telling her point to her family!

these team huddle's are becoming a pain in the neck!

every action in this show is reptative...be it aarzoo's family, aapa , alvira, nausheen or anybody else

the makers did a huge mistake ...they should've never shown aarzoo as a strong character if they wanted to show this nonsense...the low trps point towards thccepted well with the audience coz the first promos kept on shouting "nayi soch..nayi ummeed ke saath aa rahi hai aarzoo nausheen khan"

where is the nayi soch?
if she is chasing her dreams...the focus should be on her dreams...and...sahir being the catalyst of her dreams...its sahir who is going to identify the designer in her...groom her...
but sadly aarzoo is lost in the knots of her dupatta!

silky_harshad thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
1. first of all they need to understand that people are sick and tired OTT villains..so kurti aapa is a big NO NO...if they had to bring someone who genuinely love and care for sahir (I still think that alvira is dhedh shani 😆) then they should have brought some sophisticated, loving and warm character not this irritating lady...🤢

2. they really need to cut some screen space of side characters...please for God sake guys give a look at your audience demands...so far I haven't seen even one comment in favour of kurti,anam, zara or alvira, I personally prefer

3. i like arzoo's family but honestly their scenes are like drinking fresh caranmel with extra sugar in it...too much to bear...honestly i will prefer to watch a funny scene of sahir-zaki or sahir-alvira scene full of unsaid unreavealed bitter distance between mom and son than the ladies pouring love on each other
4. Arzoo is really a very good character..she is neither some flawless goddess nor a doormat, I really like her and they need to develop her character in story than making her a musibat magnet
5. zaki is adorable...Since prem days I am a sucker of brothers chemistry but no they want to make zaki a soldier against anam instead of showing his place in family and sahir's life..honestly the most intriguing part of his character is the bond he shares with sahir...see nobody can deny that sahir is exceptionally warm with him,which is interesting and there should be a solid reason behind this...
4. --Sahir ... the only good thing CVs did so far is hat they created an aura of mystery around him but now they need to build his character properly...and they can do this by giving him some screen space...and where the hell is shayar anyway and they need to justify his nickname shark
5. SaAz: humsafars is a love story isn't it...then where the hell is romance...SaAz need some scenes together...I guess cvs tried to show us subconscious interactions and silent observations about each other, i really like it...but you will have to show this to us dear creative...you can't expect audience to imagine sahir observing arzoo from his glass cabin and arzoo reading him in home and office...plus real interactions are important..
VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: ecrivain



Oh Vandy I so agree with u ...and u know I can overlook anything , even The bloopers but the SCRIPT is an issue Here

The way the sequences pop up, with disjoint background ...I don't know what to Exocet

Cos eventually , the show n The characters n the CHMEISTRY n love scenes of the leads all Depends upon the SCRIPT ..n if tht is weak ..then I don't know wht to say now


u know...i feel they r deliberately not writing scenes for hc😆
read some ppl talking that maybe hc is charging too much hence they do not want to shoot with him everyday...isiliye there's so less of him

i actually wonder if this can be a reason? i mean u cast an actor knowing fully well abt his charges...so u basically know what u r getting into!

if u have him on board...u should utilise him to the fullest extent!
here ...the script seems to totally ignore sahir/hc and move abt showing nonsensical stuff...


silky_harshad thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#18
and about behnd the scenes stuff, please change your editing team...itni kharab editing maine nhi dekhi to be honest... scenes mein flow nhi hai...dialogues are good but cut the melodrama 😆 and learn to explain things, aap sirf points dete ho explain ni krte that's why aapke aadhe marks cut jaatein hy... 🤣
prettypri thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19
Nayi soch is limited to taking her mothers name...rest is all usual bhaashan!
She never thinks of solutions...feels sorry for herself and then her family comes in...bhaashan...candy sweetness...and team huddle...they joke in tbe middle of extreme situations too...that's unreal! Takes away from the scene in fact!


silky_harshad thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: -vandy-


u know...i feel they r deliberately not writing scenes for hc😆
read some ppl talking that maybe hc is charging too much hence they do not want to shoot with him everyday...isiliye there's so less of him

i actually wonder if this can be a reason? i mean u cast an actor knowing fully well abt his charges...so u basically know what u r getting into!

if u have him on board...u should utilise him to the fullest extent!
here ...the script seems to totally ignore sahir/hc and move abt showing nonsensical stuff...


@bold if this is true, then hc is not shooting everyday...then why the hell this guy is not active on fb 😡😡 kal raat ko poore 25 hrs k baad online aaya 😡 ek mshg kro tou janaab ko dekhne mein teen din lgte hy...arse baad uss din cover change kra 😡😡 EXPLAIN 😡

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".