A step in the shoes of Rishi- dont blame b4 u know - Page 18

Created

Last reply

Replies

216

Views

14.7k

Users

44

Likes

491

Frequent Posters

-Paulomi- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi


If Indira's Memory comes back , even then Rishta's Marriage will remain valid.

According to Indian Marriage Law. If one Spouse disappears or remains untraceable for more than 4 years , and another spouse marries in meantime , the first marriage is automatically nullified ( even if missing person returns later).

So Inshi's marriage is now nullified automatically.

And As Regards Indu's custody , I have already given you answer once , if shweta goes court , there are more than 99.9% chance she will get Indu's custody.


that also depends how Indira disappeared,was it an accident or someones conspiracy or by Indira's own will.

for last option,i have nothing to say about this u all know the answer and if anyone of the 1st 2 options are correct then Indira can't be punished for the mistake which she has not done.

of course courts will consider that also,they can't give one-sided judgement.
ashish.sachi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: -Paulomi-

that also depends how Indira disappeared,was it an accident or someones conspiracy or by Indira's own will.

for last option,i have nothing to say about this u all know the answer and if anyone of the 1st 2 options are correct then Indira can't be punished for the mistake which she has not done.

of course courts will consider that also,they can't give one-sided judgement.


@Bold : No , it does not depend on that at all. In one case an Indian soldier got trapped in Pakistan for five years. His family thought he is dead and his wife married again. But when he returned , even then court upheld the second marriage only and nullified first.

@Blue : Even if there is no mistake of Indira , court will give custody of Indu to Shweta only. That is the standard practice in India , formulated by Supreme Court of India.
743546 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: -Paulomi-


that also depends how Indira disappeared,was it an accident or someones conspiracy or by Indira's own will.

for last option,i have nothing to say about this u all know the answer and if anyone of the 1st 2 options are correct then Indira can't be punished for the mistake which she has not done.

of course courts will consider that also,they can't give one-sided judgement.



@bold how would u knw dat..😆...no its not depend on that...
Edited by loveuratidi - 12 years ago
743546 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi


If Indira's Memory comes back , even then Rishta's Marriage will remain valid.

According to Indian Marriage Law. If one Spouse disappears or remains untraceable for more than 4 years , and another spouse marries in meantime , the first marriage is automatically nullified ( even if missing person returns later).

So Inshi's marriage is now nullified automatically.

And As Regards Indu's custody , I have already given you answer once , if shweta goes court , there are more than 99.9% chance she will get Indu's custody.



@bold its not 4years its 7 years...accordingto divorce act 1869...

@red if shwta goes court then definitely she will get indu's custody...
ipissonrishi thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Rishi even never loved Indira...Just because his heart saying Zara is Indira doesn't prove anything..If he is so sure then first get proof and then do whatever he wants to do..The way he is trying to get close to someone's wife tells you what he never loved Indira either..He was just attracted towards Indira physically and just because Zara looks like her he is attracted towards her too..It's just lust..Just look at his lusty expressions..Rishi doesn't have any moral values..Shameless creature running after someone's else wife..If he really loved India he could have wait for the proofs but no he just wants to go close to her and wants to touch her wants to hug her and that's all!!..
Rishi was lusty 8 years back and still is lusty and will always remain lusty...A big spot on the name of husband and father...
No wonder Indu is turning like Indira when Indira's father left her mother for some other women and had an affair with her...

emyl thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Indira once told Simi Diwan dat if life gives her another chance, she will never let go of Rishi...now life is giving her 2nd chance(i believe Zara is Indira) she will not loose Rishi dis time no matter wat happens... As for Swetha, she deserves a better and blissful life...no point waiting for Rishi to change coz his heart is not with him to give to Swetha.. Its with Indira/Zara... Same goes to Zara, her heart beats for Rishi only, dat is why she cant hav a normal marraige life with Malik...and i pity Indira, coz her daughter doesnt know of her existance... Her memories are erased from SN... It must be a great pain for Kutumb deep inside dat no one is allowed to talk bout her Indira... But why?
ashish.sachi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: emymichael

Indira once told Simi Diwan dat if life gives her another chance, she will never let go of Rishi...now life is giving her 2nd chance(i believe Zara is Indira) she will not loose Rishi dis time no matter wat happens... As for Swetha, she deserves a better and blissful life...no point waiting for Rishi to change coz his heart is not with him to give to Swetha.. Its with Indira/Zara... Same goes to Zara, her heart beats for Rishi only, dat is why she cant hav a normal marraige life with Malik...and i pity Indira, coz her daughter doesnt know of her existance... Her memories are erased from SN... It must be a great pain for Kutumb deep inside dat no one is allowed to talk bout her Indira... But why?


Who said , Shweta has prevented everybody from talking about Indira.

She has just requested them not to talk about her in presence of Indu. Since she is just a child. When Indu will get matured , Shweta will herself tell everything.

Other than that , She doesn't want Anybody to forget Indira.

It is she who arranges for Indira's shraad every year for last 8 years.
IFfirst thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Nice Post Simran ...

Regarding the blame game nd other remarks ...
All I can Say is let the fictional story remain fictional ...

There is absolutely no need for all the members with their respective preferences to justify their stands nd have unwanted conflicts just to clarify or prove that some character is better and the other is bad ...
This doesnot mean we don't share our thoughts but there is always a better way of presenting the thoughts ...😃

We must know that these r fictional characters nd they r made to behave nd act in a way the creator of the character wants to ...As we say CV's do spoil characters
So no reason for us to dissect characters in so much detail because the creators donot make/write characters in so much detail (mostly )...
if so much effort was put in making stories perfect without glitches nd bloopers then where would we get the Drama quotient from ...
as we all know mostly the drama is far from reality isn't it ...😃

Regarding the issue whether Rishi is right or wrong ..

It all depends upon the viewers perception ...😊

OK i know i have given a diplomatic answer ...😆
But thats what I feel like writing here ...😃
I hope i have not written something wrong ...😕


I want share this Quote here

"The fact of storytelling hints at a fundamental human unease,hints at human
imperfection.Where there is perfection there is no story to tell."
Ben Okri

So let the imperfection exist as they r nd we should enjoy whatever we can ...

Nd Simran very Sorry for my late reply ...

nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi


If Indira's Memory comes back , even then Rishta's Marriage will remain valid.

According to Indian Marriage Law. If one Spouse disappears or remains untraceable for more than 4 years , and another spouse marries in meantime , the first marriage is automatically nullified ( even if missing person returns later).

So Inshi's marriage is now nullified automatically.

And As Regards Indu's custody , I have already given you answer once , if shweta goes court , there are more than 99.9% chance she will get Indu's custody.




you r right in saying that rishta marriage is valid as per indian law . but its not 4 years its 7 years and inshi meet after 8 years . so the num does not affect here.

but it is very much difficult to shweta to get custody of Indu as per Indian law. surrogate mother has no rt over the child. and she has signed the contract also, stating she will not asked for the custody. only she can prove in court that neither Indira nor Rishi is capable of looking after child and Indu told to court that she wants to stay with shweta only .she dislikes her parents or she doesn't feel safe with them .as she love her father and khadus aunt andwhen she will come to know that she is her mother then it is difficult for shweta to make her blame her parents .so there is few percent change that shweta may get custody of her.

Edited by nutan7 - 12 years ago
DobbyDeol thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: IFfirst

Nice Post Simran ...


Regarding the blame game nd other remarks ...
All I can Say is let the fictional story remain fictional ...

There is absolutely no need for all the members with their respective preferences to justify their stands nd have unwanted conflicts just to clarify or prove that some character is better and the other is bad ...
This doesnot mean we don't share our thoughts but there is always a better way of presenting the thoughts ...😃

We must know that these r fictional characters nd they r made to behave nd act in a way the creator of the character wants to ...As we say CV's do spoil characters
So no reason for us to dissect characters in so much detail because the creators donot make/write characters in so much detail (mostly )...
if so much effort was put in making stories perfect without glitches nd bloopers then where would we get the Drama quotient from ...
as we all know mostly the drama is far from reality isn't it ...😃

Regarding the issue whether Rishi is right or wrong ..

It all depends upon the viewers perception ...😊

OK i know i have given a diplomatic answer ...😆
But thats what I feel like writing here ...😃
I hope i have not written something wrong ...😕


I want share this Quote here

"The fact of storytelling hints at a fundamental human unease,hints at human
imperfection.Where there is perfection there is no story to tell."
Ben Okri

So let the imperfection exist as they r nd we should enjoy whatever we can ...

Nd Simran very Sorry for my late reply ...

aah...!!...exact sentiments...!!!..😆😆..this is what even i'm not getting...its just fiction nd most things are un real..then why so much to bother nd proving the points...!!!...great post anu...!!👏

nd m glad to see u after days...!!😃😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".