Current Track - My Dislike

asterixandme thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
I'm not sure I really like this Sharma Family Separation Track.

It's not really a separation. Inshi are right there watching the goings-on. Every time a Sunanina or a Mandira are slighted, they turn their eyes towards an Indira who seems indifferent.

Personally, I dislike the way this is being portrayed because Indira is only pretending to be distant. She actually is not. The umbilical cord has not yet been severed.

To clarify, its not as though I am asking her to disown her family, but at least she should not do it in halves. At some point, its going to come through that she isn't convinced about this decision.

Its a major step and she has done well to distance herself. This was long overdue. But still, she is only thinking about her useless family instead of focusing on ways to utilize the distance in finding some peace of mind, settling into her married life, and shaping a meaningful husband-wife bond. I hope they show some movement in that direction. Its good that Rishi is a nice and patient guy (in a way that only telly hubbies can be) who thinks of her happiness as his own. He can do better in some ways but he is not the focus of this post.

When they were inside Sharma Nivas, Indira was preoccupied with her family's presence and problems. Now that they are out, they have found a way to be within earshot of her family's presence and problems! So what was achieved? And what's the point that she's trying to make? That she is capable of tough love? If so, then live out the tough love, lady! Be tough on yourself too.

I guess I dislike it more because her motivation is to make the members of her family realise the importance of Indira Sharma, but not their individual responsibilities towards the same family. This separation, then, is not to make them grow up. I hope I am proved wrong. But I deffo would not be surprised if they want her back only because she allows them to be their parasitic selves--an aspect that Dulari Bua is handling in an excellent manner.

But if Indira is constantly going to be on the periphery, and making her presence obvious, then there is no reason for her family to not take her for granted. Regardless of what she says or does to prove otherwise. For instance, merely saying that Mandira has Munna to protect her has no meaning if Indira is going to go and beat up the goon instead of Munna.

I hope I made some sense. Please feel free to agree/disagree. To clarify, this is not a bashing post. I tried to look at things from Indira's point of view and found that her intention is correct, but her handling of this situation is not. She really needs to find her life apart from her family, which she is not succeeding at. Simply because she is not giving it a decent shot.

Your views?

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

4.5k

Users

20

Likes

277

Frequent Posters

aadk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: asterixandme

I'm not sure I really like this Sharma Family Separation Track.

It's not really a separation. Inshi are right there watching the goings-on. Every time a Sunanina or a Mandira are slighted, they turn their eyes towards an Indira who seems indifferent.

Personally, I dislike the way this is being portrayed because Indira is only pretending to be distant. She actually is not. The umbilical cord has not yet been severed.

To clarify, its not as though I am asking her to disown her family, but at least she should not do it in halves. At some point, its going to come through that she isn't convinced about this decision.

Its a major step and she has done well to distance herself. This was long overdue. But still, she is only thinking about her useless family instead of focusing on ways to utilize the distance in finding some peace of mind, settling into her married life, and shaping a meaningful husband-wife bond. I hope they show some movement in that direction. Its good that Rishi is a nice and patient guy (in a way that only telly hubbies can be) who thinks of her happiness as his own. He can do better in some ways but he is not the focus of this post.

When they were inside Sharma Nivas, Indira was preoccupied with her family's presence and problems. Now that they are out, they have found a way to be within earshot of her family's presence and problems! So what was achieved? And what's the point that she's trying to make? That she is capable of tough love? If so, then live out the tough love, lady! Be tough on yourself too.

I guess I dislike it more because her motivation is to make the members of her family realise the importance of Indira Sharma, but not their individual responsibilities towards the same family. This separation, then, is not to make them grow up. I hope I am proved wrong. But I deffo would not be surprised if they want her back only because she allows them to be their parasitic selves--an aspect that Dulari Bua is handling in an excellent manner.

But if Indira is constantly going to be on the periphery, and making her presence obvious, then there is no reason for her family to not take her for granted. Regardless of what she says or does to prove otherwise. For instance, merely saying that Mandira has Munna to protect her has no meaning if Indira is going to go and beat up the goon instead of Munna.

I hope I made some sense. Please feel free to agree/disagree. To clarify, this is not a bashing post. I tried to look at things from Indira's point of view and found that her intention is correct, but her handling of this situation is not. She really needs to find her life apart from her family, which she is not succeeding at. Simply because she is not giving it a decent shot.

Your views?


i really lykd dis point of yours...Yes itz more important dt SF realise their responsibilities...But if we go by d track record of HD,dats a distant dream😆...And i feel itz ok if indira wnts her family members to realise her importnc bcs she has sacrificed so many things in her lyf for her family dt she cn expct atleast this much frm dm...😛
Edited by aadk - 13 years ago
Ranjinikishan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
101% agreed..indu besharmas ke saamne boltihe ki i dont care aur rishi ko interfere honese rokdetihe par peechese ussi goondako maarke, chappal pooja kartihe, shitti kahani hai.

i am really fed up of indira sharma's bade bade dialogues, chappal poojas & tappads yaar


Ila bedi dutta kuch toh naya dikayiye, story mein kuch bi naya twist hi nahi hai. 1st epi se aaj tak same dialogues, same kapde.

SHITTI KAHANI AUR SHITTI TRACKS.

btw people if u dont like my post i dont mind, even if u bash me, i dont care because this is what i am feeling now especially after watching yest's epi.

sirf sumit keliye aur inshi keliye yeh sab sehna padrahahai. the day sumit quits HD not even a second i take to forget HD

samrudhi.r thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Yes you have made a very valid point. I agree with everything u have written. All credit goes to our infamous HD CVs.
adinats07 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Best post i have read and well written...i agree to each and every point. Bold - is the best lines...
In addition HD still now only one plot is going on and on, that is how mean and money minded the sharma family are.. only difference is each and every plot is served with new ingrident - [here cameo] as a different dish.. but the main dish i mean the main plot is how are sharma family.. may be HD team are try to teach us how can a same plot can be showed in different track

Originally posted by: asterixandme

I'm not sure I really like this Sharma Family Separation Track.

It's not really a separation. Inshi are right there watching the goings-on. Every time a Sunanina or a Mandira are slighted, they turn their eyes towards an Indira who seems indifferent.

Personally, I dislike the way this is being portrayed because Indira is only pretending to be distant. She actually is not. The umbilical cord has not yet been severed.

To clarify, its not as though I am asking her to disown her family, but at least she should not do it in halves. At some point, its going to come through that she isn't convinced about this decision.

Its a major step and she has done well to distance herself. This was long overdue. But still, she is only thinking about her useless family instead of focusing on ways to utilize the distance in finding some peace of mind, settling into her married life, and shaping a meaningful husband-wife bond. I hope they show some movement in that direction. Its good that Rishi is a nice and patient guy (in a way that only telly hubbies can be) who thinks of her happiness as his own. He can do better in some ways but he is not the focus of this post.

When they were inside Sharma Nivas, Indira was preoccupied with her family's presence and problems. Now that they are out, they have found a way to be within earshot of her family's presence and problems! So what was achieved? And what's the point that she's trying to make? That she is capable of tough love? If so, then live out the tough love, lady! Be tough on yourself too.

I guess I dislike it more because her motivation is to make the members of her family realise the importance of Indira Sharma, but not their individual responsibilities towards the same family. This separation, then, is not to make them grow up. I hope I am proved wrong. But I deffo would not be surprised if they want her back only because she allows them to be their parasitic selves--an aspect that Dulari Bua is handling in an excellent manner.

But if Indira is constantly going to be on the periphery, and making her presence obvious, then there is no reason for her family to not take her for granted. Regardless of what she says or does to prove otherwise. For instance, merely saying that Mandira has Munna to protect her has no meaning if Indira is going to go and beat up the goon instead of Munna.

I hope I made some sense. Please feel free to agree/disagree. To clarify, this is not a bashing post. I tried to look at things from Indira's point of view and found that her intention is correct, but her handling of this situation is not. She really needs to find her life apart from her family, which she is not succeeding at. Simply because she is not giving it a decent shot.

Your views?

asterixandme thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: aadk


i really lykd dis point of yours...Yes itz more important dt SF realise their responsibilities...But if we go by d track record of HD,dats a distant dream😆...And i feel itz ok if indira wnts her family members to realise her importnc bcs she has sacrificed so many things in her lyf for her family dt she cn expct atleast this much frm dm...😛

Of course it's okay for her to expect it! The way they treat her is horrid. I am constantly surprised at what makes her tick. Especially now, when she is married and should have different goals and perspectives on things.

And then again, there is the point that respect and awe are earned and not expected. They would have been far more in awe of her if she had actually lived out her threats. And just because she makes them responsible does not mean that she will lose respect or importance. The earlier Indira knew this and craved for family life. But anyway, that's history. None of the characters here show a growth arc of any kind. So, to expect it from her is unfair.

Edited by asterixandme - 13 years ago
asterixandme thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Ranjinikishan

101% agreed..indu besharmas ke saamne boltihe ki i dont care aur rishi ko interfere honese rokdetihe par peechese ussi goondako maarke, chappal pooja kartihe, shitti kahani hai.

i am really fed up of indira sharma's bade bade dialogues, chappal poojas & tappads yaar


Ila bedi dutta kuch toh naya dikayiye, story mein kuch bi naya twist hi nahi hai. 1st epi se aaj tak same dialogues, same kapde.

SHITTI KAHANI AUR SHITTI TRACKS.

btw people if u dont like my post i dont mind, even if u bash me, i dont care because this is what i am feeling now especially after watching yest's epi.

sirf sumit keliye aur inshi keliye yeh sab sehna padrahahai. the day sumit quits HD not even a second i take to forget HD

Whoa! Complete frustration 😆 I have learned to laugh at these things now.

asterixandme thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: adinats07

Best post i have read and well written...i agree to each and every point. Bold - is the best lines...
In addition HD still now only one plot is going on and on, that is how mean and money minded the sharma family are.. only difference is each and every plot is served with new ingrident - [here cameo] as a different dish.. but the main dish i mean the main plot is how are sharma family.. may be HD team are try to teach us how can a same plot can be showed in different track


Thanks for the compliment 😊

@bold: I wish they progressed from this point. Does not seem as though they have any other ideas. So many things had so much potential, but no. Everything was underdeveloped and therefore, unconvincing.
DobbyDeol thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
agreeing wid each nd every word...vey well written...indira ne ghar ye kehkar chhoda ki wo kyun unki parvaah kare...then uske baad bhi usne yahi kaha...but uska faayda kya...!!...she's doing the same thing again...sharmas phir wahi ke wahi ban jaayeng because sooner or later they'll realise that whatever happens nd whtaever she tries to portray...she'll always be there for them...toh wo toh sudharne se rahe...even i did not very much like indira beating up that goon...nd saying ki wo har pal unke saath hai...kyun bhaii...isse kya haasil hoga...??...now again because of those besharmas she'll not focus on married life that much as she'll always be preoccupied wid the sf wellbeing...i'm not getting this track now...ab wahi puraani kahani shuru hone waali hai as soon as dulari leaves...they'll again turn into those parasites...let them suffer...then only they will realise their sense of responsibilty...
nd again...why does she need to make them realise her importance..??...unke andar khud zimmedaary ka ehsaas toh tabhi aayega jab pet bharne waala koi nahi hoga...warna toh wahi baat...
oops...sorrry ...i've gone too far..
twila thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
asterixandme...
Another Fantastic post ... Brrillianttt analysis. 👏
You have said everything soo Beautifully ... there is really nothing to add .
I guess we can scream from the rooftops till Kingdom come... please show some GROWTH in INSHI's characters , but alas to no avail ... where is the growth in Indu's character ?? 😡
... was she not supposed to learn to live her own life with Rishi serving as the catalyst that brings Happiness in her life ??
But how is that ever going to happen if she will turn herself into a 24 hour Watch Guard of the Sharma Family ?? ... of course the less said about Rishi's character the better it is ... do not even want to go there ...Sighhh...
We really need Ila Bedi to wake up and remember that INSHI are the leads of the show and not the Sharma Fmaily members ... Wake Up before it is too late .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".