Some things amiss.......

Rah_HuJu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Ok Mods if something like this has been posted before, plz close the topic....

There are a few things in Deathly Hallows which are a wee bit difficult to digest:

1. The Gryffindor sword was taken by Griphook when they rob the Lestranges vault....how does Neville remove it from the Sorting Hat to kill Nagini in the end?😕

2. Harry's son, James says he sees Teddy & Victiore snogging & Ginny says 'Our Victoire'.....Is Victoire Bill & Fleur's daughter??they don't mention it anywhere😕

3. We're told that the families of those who fled from Hogwarts return to fight....weren't the Death-Eaters patrolling Hogsmeade??😕& how did the families get to Hogwarts in such a short span of time???😕

4. What happened to Kreacher?😕

5. When Harry dies & sees Dumbledore, that thing which keeps crying in the bundle, it was supposed to be Voldemort when he dies?😕

Have more puzzles in mind, but if these can be answered first, would appreciate it😳😳

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

653

Users

4

Frequent Posters

diya_1987 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Rah_HuJu

Ok Mods if something like this has been posted before, plz close the topic....

There are a few things in Deathly Hallows which are a wee bit difficult to digest:

1. The Gryffindor sword was taken by Griphook when they rob the Lestranges vault....how does Neville remove it from the Sorting Hat to kill Nagini in the end?😕the sword of gryffindor was always available to a true gryffindor....like harry cud get it out of the sorting hat in the chamber of secrets.....likewise neville being a true gryffindor cud do the same......so it dsnt matter whr the sword is......a true gryffindor can always get it

2. Harry's son, James says he sees Teddy & Victiore snogging & Ginny says 'Our Victoire'.....Is Victoire Bill & Fleur's daughter??they don't mention it anywhere😕ya its not mentioned dat victoire is bill n fluer's daughter.....but it can easily be understood from her french name......

3. We're told that the families of those who fled from Hogwarts return to fight....weren't the Death-Eaters patrolling Hogsmeade??😕& how did the families get to Hogwarts in such a short span of time???😕 maybe they apparated directly to hog's head.....

4. What happened to Kreacher?😕he was mentioned to be fighting against the death eaters in howgwarts.....dunno wat happened to him finally

5. When Harry dies & sees Dumbledore, that thing which keeps crying in the bundle, it was supposed to be Voldemort when he dies?😕 i wont be able to explain this properly.....m sure sum1 else will explain😊

Have more puzzles in mind, but if these can be answered first, would appreciate it😳😳

chhilt thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Rah_HuJu

Ok Mods if something like this has been posted before, plz close the topic....

There are a few things in Deathly Hallows which are a wee bit difficult to digest:

1. The Gryffindor sword was taken by Griphook when they rob the Lestranges vault....how does Neville remove it from the Sorting Hat to kill Nagini in the end?😕 It doesn't matter where the sword of gryffindor was... a true gryffindor can always get it out of the hat in moments of great need.

2. Harry's son, James says he sees Teddy & Victiore snogging & Ginny says 'Our Victoire'.....Is Victoire Bill & Fleur's daughter??they don't mention it anywhere😕 It isn't mentioned in the books but J.K Rowling said in an interview that Vixtoire is Bill and Fleur's daughter.

3. We're told that the families of those who fled from Hogwarts return to fight....weren't the Death-Eaters patrolling Hogsmeade??😕& how did the families get to Hogwarts in such a short span of time???😕 The Death Eaters ceased to patrol Hogsmeade when they returned to Voldemort... and the families could have Apparated directly to the Hog's Head and then through the passageway to the Room of Requirement

4. What happened to Kreacher?😕 I'm not sure about this one, but he either stayed at Hogwarts or it's likely that he returned to Grimmauld Place.

5. When Harry dies & sees Dumbledore, that thing which keeps crying in the bundle, it was supposed to be Voldemort when he dies?😕 It's the eighth piece of Voldemort's soul... and some people also asked that since voldemort feared death he would come back as a ghost.... but he wasn't given the choice to do so... he was forced to stay in that miserable state forever, as a punishment for his sins.

Have more puzzles in mind, but if these can be answered first, would appreciate it😳😳 Go ahead and post more... i think we'll be able to help you out. and i hope that the answers were satisfactory....

Rah_HuJu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
oh thanks so much for answering the queries guys...now my mind is at peace!! 😛 😉 ok the other puzzles I had are solved...thanks to a good friend of mine who managed to sort them out for me!! 😳
cezzurockz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
hmmm it seems m late they hv answered it ask more so tht even i cn gv my opinion 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".