HP Quiz -This isn't MAGIC, it's LOGIC ;) -Season 2 - Page 33

Al is the first answer Dobby??

Originally posted by: Mione

Well here's another from me. Put in a lot of effort (mostly to get it to rhyme) for this but enjoyed it all the more. Hope you guys have fun too! 😳

You may have seen my kind before

But got me as that you lacked in the past,

Introduced when you set out to explore

Yet departed in the midst of a crisis vast.

You cared about me and I about you

Got wounded and wounded others to defend you

You may be a hero, but Smart...are you?

I bet your fans are smarter than you.

The above applies to not one but 2

So dear fans, Al now gives you the clue

One was a President unlike me and you

And another a holy man, if you know who! 😉

Originally posted by: Mione

Well here's another from me. Put in a lot of effort (mostly to get it to rhyme) for this but enjoyed it all the more. Hope you guys have fun too! 😳

You may have seen my kind before

But got me as that you lacked in the past,

Introduced when you set out to explore

Yet departed in the midst of a crisis vast.

You cared about me and I about you

Got wounded and wounded others to defend you

You may be a hero, but Smart...are you?

I bet your fans are smarter than you.

The above applies to not one but 2

So dear fans, Al now gives you the clue

One was a President unlike me and you

And another a holy man, if you know who! 😉

Originally posted by: Mione

Dumbledore, Grindelwald, Sword of G and Sirius!!! 🤔

It's none of these, sorry... but may I know how each you derived these? 😳

Originally posted by: Mione

Well here's another from me. Put in a lot of effort (mostly to get it to rhyme) for this but enjoyed it all the more. Hope you guys have fun too! 😳

You may have seen my kind before

But got me as that you lacked in the past,

Introduced when you set out to explore

Yet departed in the midst of a crisis vast.

i took it as sword of G..

you=harry

me=sword of G.

harry had seen it n used it in COS but not used it to destroy horcrux. so he lacked it in the past to destroy a horcrux... i know lame reasoning! 😆 but next two fit as it was introduced to him thru dumbly's will in DH but they lost it right there in the middle of a crisis(gringrotts)

You cared about me and I about you

Got wounded and wounded others to defend you

You may be a hero, but Smart...are you?

I bet your fans are smarter than you.

and this i took Sirius.

you=harry

me=sirius

both cared abt each other and got wounded too for each other..

harry is a hero. the chosen one!😃

smart i took it as jovially just the way sirius would joke..in the sense that harry was indeed was not too smart..we know of his smartness in the second and third tasks of TWT! 😆 and of course we fans r smarter than him..at least i am! 🤣

The above applies to not one but 2

So dear fans, Al now gives you the clue

One was a President unlike me and you

And another a holy man, if you know who! 😉

took the sword to be the President.. a president is the chief commander of the defense forces and in a way the sword played a major role to destroy the horcruxes. and unlike u and me, its a non living thing..an object.

holy man.. 😆😆 sirius! the holiest of all Blacks!! 😆

can it be George?? you know "Holey" joke??😕

Ummm...ok to clear all your doubts, the last 2 clues refer to something in reality - as in, to our muggle world. And it literally means - one by that name (the same as the character) was/is a holy man and the other was a president respectively.

I'm really glad that you guys came up with such alternative answers to ones that I had initially thought of, but then they need to fit all of the lines. For eg: @ritchelle - Got me as that you lacked in the past - Means you did not have a relationship like the one you had with me before. And one more thing, the Hero refers to Harry 😳. So that's where the D&G thing doesn't fit ritchelle😉.

And well done CJ, Ron is one of the answers ...abhi mujhe uska logic batao. 😛

Also Ani and Laksh, I hope this has cleared the Holy man wala doubt. This clue is related to the other answer.

ok so the first para clubbed with president clue is Ron. yeah fits pretty well.

the second para and holy man clue...Im at my wits end coz there is actually no holy man in harry potter that i can recall. :-( and plus its a man. a living male being. can't remember!:-(