Discussion of the Week - Snape - Page 3

Originally posted by: achal

I used to hate Snape before, but now I think he's innocent. The argument that he had with Dumbledore, I think it was about him killing Dumbledore. Dumbledore wanted Snape to kill him, because if he didn't Snape would have to die instead, since he had made the Unbreakable Vow. Dumbledore trusts him completely, and Dumbledore can't be wrong. Dumbledore was using Lupin to find out info about the Death Eaters/Voldemort through other werewolfs, just as he was asking Snape to find out more in debt info about Voldemort by making Snape prove to Voldemort that he's trustworthy..

Also, Snape was helping Harry all throughout the sixth book, by teaching him all the new spells, by being the Half Blood Prince.. He didn't do it directly, but he did help him, rite? And, Harry, who could never do nonverbal spells, could easily do nonverbal spell written in the book, all, I think, by the help of Snape.. Otherwise, why would Snape leave his such valuable book just lying around?

These r just my opinion tho, ans sorry if it's too long. 😛

I completely agree wit u achal, and no ur post isn't too long either!

i actually like Snape...he is one heck of a character....he really is different and interesting at times 😆 and ofcourse he is our head of the house 😉

i think that snape iz innocent

through out the books he's been helping harry in a indirect way for example;

the first book-he tried 2 stop harry from dying on the quidditch pitch

the second book-wen they were making the polyjuice potion
they needed ingredients and they nicked them from his store cupboard

the third book-he tried to save them wen lupin turned into a werewolf

the fourth book-the gilly weed

the fifth book-harry needed 2 learn occulumency but they didn't trust each other and we all no the consequences after that

the sixth book-snape was the half-blood prince

this iz the evidence that snape iz innocent but what he does to harry makes unsure

i guess that snape iz ambigous and very complicated
he probabely has his ownn reason 4 his actions. if he told sum 1 else bout he thinks that they wouldnt understand

you've also got 2 look at HIS CHILDHOOD. (I THINK THIS MIGHT BE THE KEY)

his muggle father beatening him or his witch mother
he had no one to talk to and must hav felt very lonely
i think wen his hogwarts letter arrived he must hav felt very happyfor very short period coz then the marauders started pickin on him this must hav lead to hatred and bitterness

personally i feel sorry for snape but i wouldnt say it to his face coz he doesnt need my pity. like the same wid lilly wen she stuck for him snape must hav sensed her pity for him which made angry

i think tht snape was innocent.. it was planned between dumbledore and him.. it is clearly mentioned in book 6.. if u all read it properly 😆 (sry got a little too over board) i think coz when hagrid says tht he saw dumbledore and snape talking snape said' plz sir ' and dumbledore was like ' u have to' (ok the words are not llike it is mention but wat i want to say is clear) it was tht and dumbledore meant tht snape u have to kill me or pretend to kill me but u are not and snape is like no i can't do it and dumbledore said no u can too..


ok it ois badly explained 😆

Originally posted by: achal

Harry the real hero since she is going to make him die in the end

who said harrys gonna die in the end, not jk rowling...so that means its just a rumour, and may not be true😛

Originally posted by: punk princess

i think that snape iz innocent

through out the books he's been helping harry in a indirect way for example;

the first book-he tried 2 stop harry from dying on the quidditch pitch

the second book-wen they were making the polyjuice potion
they needed ingredients and they nicked them from his store cupboard

the third book-he tried to save them wen lupin turned into a werewolf

the fourth book-the gilly weed

the fifth book-harry needed 2 learn occulumency but they didn't trust each other and we all no the consequences after that

the sixth book-snape was the half-blood prince

this iz the evidence that snape iz innocent but what he does to harry makes unsure

i guess that snape iz ambigous and very complicated
he probabely has his ownn reason 4 his actions. if he told sum 1 else bout he thinks that they wouldnt understand

you've also got 2 look at HIS CHILDHOOD. (I THINK THIS MIGHT BE THE KEY)

his muggle father beatening him or his witch mother
he had no one to talk to and must hav felt very lonely
i think wen his hogwarts letter arrived he must hav felt very happyfor very short period coz then the marauders started pickin on him this must hav lead to hatred and bitterness

personally i feel sorry for snape but i wouldnt say it to his face coz he doesnt need my pity. like the same wid lilly wen she stuck for him snape must hav sensed her pity for him which made angry

wonderful explanation...i feel sorry for snape too, but then again, i feel sorry for everyone, wen they have problems in life😳

Originally posted by: daniel_4ever

i think tht snape was innocent.. it was planned between dumbledore and him.. it is clearly mentioned in book 6.. if u all read it properly 😆 (sry got a little too over board) i think coz when hagrid says tht he saw dumbledore and snape talking snape said' plz sir ' and dumbledore was like ' u have to' (ok the words are not llike it is mention but wat i want to say is clear) it was tht and dumbledore meant tht snape u have to kill me or pretend to kill me but u are not and snape is like no i can't do it and dumbledore said no u can too..
ok it ois badly explained 😆

from the book~
Snape said nothing, but walked forward and pushed Malfoy roughly out of the way. The three Death eaters fell back without a word. Even the werewolf seemed cowed.
Snape gazed for a moment at Dumbledore, and there was revulsion and hatred etched in the harsh lines of his face.
"Severus...please..."
Snape raised his wand and pointed it directly at Dumbledore.
"Avada Kedavra!"~
u might notice tht the whole time Snape didnt say anything

p.s. can someone pls get rid of redei or whoever tht is because we really dont need someone like tht on our forum!

Originally posted by: NeetikaNath

p.s. can someone pls get rid of redei or whoever tht is because we really dont need someone like tht on our forum!

yes, please someone delete that post, and i say kick him out of i-f😡😳

Well m new here but would like to post ma comment on snape....

First of all i dont like snape, upto knw i thought that he is guilty of killing dumbledore but after reading the previous post i feel maybe he is innocent but whatever it happens in ma opinion he is still guilty.

Here is the explanation why he is guilty...

Well he knew that darco wouldnt be able to kill dumbledore so in the first place why make the unbreakable vow?????
Secoundly when killing dumbledore why did he have hatred in his face?..

Well just waiting for the seventh book to come out so we can knw more abt him..

lovelyprincesst wrote:
Well I'm new here...

Welcome!