Created

Last reply

Replies

199

Views

11.2k

Users

32

Likes

717

Frequent Posters

DMKJ_VB thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: -pixie-

@Ria- lets look at this way...there is this person you love with your entire being...you practically owe your entire existence to this one person..and for this one person's happiness you are willing to sacrifice your own...


Now one fine morning you find out that this one person, who means the world to you, never really respected you and doesnt really care much for your feelings or respect infront of his own value system- that allows him to decide what is wrong and what is right. Now as a woman you can do two things
1) Continue in the relationship- with the understanding that your partner does not really care much for your opinion or judgement. Now, here I am going to write something that I firmly believe- without respect there can never be any love!
2) End the relationship- understanding that if the person does not respect you for who you are, in the longer term you are doing yourself a favor- despite all the short term pain and angst you have to go through.

She chose 2. We may choose 1. Does that make her irresponsible or does that just tell us that Geet values her self a little more than we do ourselves?



first.i would never think that he never really respected me, if i was in geet's place, i would hv know n and understood why he said all that-of course not at that moment, but definitely, i wouldn't take such a long time!
to love and to love truly is an act,not of the strong but of the strongest-yes,without respect,there is no love,but if geet decided to end the relation as u urself accepted,well,then,she never really understood maan-to think that he didn't respect her.....that is not how real people react to situations, believe me , i hv seen real situations, husbands and wives hv the worst fights, they say worse things to one another-that does not mean they don't respect each other, anger makes u lose ur temper and words come out of ur mouth even though deep inside they don't mean anything-believe me ,i am talking from personal experience-but u don't start thinking that your loved one never respected u and its better to end the relationship.No! that never ever happens.
Edited by ria_sengupta - 14 years ago
-pixie- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
@Ria- Why do people break-up then? Isn't disagreement on a fundamental value such as respect- a cause of incompatibility?

You have the worst fights with your spouse-but then dont women go to their maykas? Some will stay and fight and give a cold shoulder- some will seek comfort from their loved ones- some will just need time to cool off and think things through.

I need to go now...but I had a good time talking to you all!
Rituparnaa thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago

Brilliant analysis ! Infact reflected exactly what I thought abt the current scenario !

DMKJ_VB thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: -pixie-

@Ria- Why do people break-up then? Isn't disagreement on a fundamental value such as respect- a cause of incompatibility?


You have the worst fights with your spouse-but then dont women go to their maykas? Some will stay and fight and give a cold shoulder- some will seek comfort from their loved ones- some will just need time to cool off and think things through.

I need to go now...but I had a good time talking to you all!


are baba, u r not understanding the basic difference between an extremely serious situation where relations break and a very serious situation where both parties get hurt but they mend their relationship................................
yes, a woman goes to her maayaka, yes,they will need time to cool down- but tell me what answer do u have to geet's silent acceptance of what teji and beeji told?
yes, a woman goes to her maayka- but she won't accept quitly if her hot headed bro insults her husband and tells her to stay there forever!
break ups and divorces happen over much serious issues-especially divorces!
pal_2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: maanddy



Exactly, sunita ! Thanks to GF and GHSP, i met some wonderful people and made very good and nice, sensible friends ! That is the reason, even i'm not watching it now, only for written updates and few my favorite actor's scene, i come here, but the main reason is that, i have got very nice and cool friends here, i can't stay away from them ! 😳

Me too, had quit TV (My reason is diff, but it does not matter), only on YT, but you know what, i really feel very bad for this show, and the character geet and dadi and the devil, coz once upon a time, i used to love this show, i used to fight with my family members to get remote and watch it at 9.30 and then, repeat at 11 ! 😳

And, now the days are come, when i can't even watch the original telecast ! This is very 'yak' feeling ! How do you feel, when the one thing, you died for, has become regular, random thing for you, that does not even matter a lot ?!?

Dadi, i used to love her, she was so nice, elegant, royal, rich and understanding dadi, our naughty dadi, who has become typical old age granny who can emotionally blackmail her grandson, and her only aim, is to mend her broken family, well nothing wrong in it, but she is just being, a normal granny who is failing, understanding her own grandson, and there was a time, when she was the only one, who used to understand her grandson, when no one in the world knows him and understands him ! I do not know, what happened to my naughty yet elegant and understanding dadi ! 😊

I still, hope that, everything, come back to normal and i enjoy my GHSP, the way it used to be ! I will see my Maan and Geet back ! 😳



Yes my situation was just like u..
once upon a time ...I have to fight with my kids and husband...they know now noone can make noise...whereever we go.. we come back before 9:30...whole day passed in thoughts of Maneet..

Now recently when I got offer for outing around 9 and I told my husband lest go.. then he was surprised and said " Your Geet is not coming?"...I told coming but now I am not to much interested.. then I thought what a change from few months.. I lost my charm..
I just watch for the glimpse of GC and to watch his acting ...

That time I spend 1-2 hour on forum,but now just 1/2 an hour and that just for my dear friends post..
I am myself surprised with such a change...
pal_2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ria_sengupta

i agree both Maan and geet have flaws which is after all natural........................and believe me, i absolutely have no problem with maan and geet having some flaws....yes, maan is short tempered,he gets angry really fast,he is full of attitude-and well, thats the reason we love him!yes,of course geet also has some problems, i certainly do not expect her to be without flaws but here the main problem is that geet's character consistency has not been maintained by the cvs...........maan was short tempered from the begining,right from his entry, and though his character has changed over time, i feel, his change has been normal, i agree that he was never a hen-pecked husband, instead he agreed to geet's tantrums, and whims because he knew her childish nature...................but geet started off as a timid and shy girl, who finally decides to stand up for what she thought right-i had huge respect for her,yes,she always had childishness in her,but thats what i said, during the office track, she never seemed irritationg or over the top, but all of a sudden,that childishness increased in leaps and bounds,and immaturity is tolerable only to an extent, when it surpasses those limits,people r bound to get irritated...................coming to the present track.......i can even try and understand why geet forgave dev( though i personally do not think it was right...but thats another thing).....yes,she was bound to get hurt by what maan said...............but leaving the home-No, that was wrong....she chose to run, and that is not the mark of strength at all, and now her attitude says, she has almost given up on her marriage, her Maan.only for those harsh words.even after hearing his apology, and all the while knowing in her heart that it was her action with dev(playing holi) which made maan lose his mind...and it was natural for him to do so, but still he never for once mistrusted Geet, he was angry becoz geet had chosen to forgive her sinner.....................geet's current attitude towards maan is unacceptable and thats the reason many of us do not relate to this geet,the original geet would have definitely not run,and she would hv been angry with maan, but she would hv confronted him,and then she would also have realised her fault in the whole issue.......but now geet does not seem to think she has any fault which is totally unacceptable!maan on the other hand is fighting for his love,he is ready to face all hardships to atone for those words uttered in a moment of anger and therefore my respect for this man increases two folds...........feel bad that the same can't be said for geet....................................geet's current attitude looks like ego instead of self respect, if it was self respect, she would hv at least talked to him,and most importantly,she would never stand quitely in front of her relatives when they were insulting maan.....according to me,that was the worst thing done by her so far and that is what totally made her lose all respect in my eyes-her attitude and silence convinced her relatives even more that she had been tortured and forced to leave her house by maan...................and this is not the way to uphold one's self respect, in fact not even ego,huge egoists would also not let their loved ones lose respect infront of others but thats exactly what geet did-and this is unpardonable!

yes ria I am agree with u..
My respect for Maan is increasing.. he was just thinking that He has gave a lot of pain to Geet.. but Geet even not for a single moment thought about Maan...that is not love.. after insult of Maan by her relative she was behaving in such a manner that she never want Maan in her life.. that is worst thing for me...
iMadz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: pal_2010



Same here, exact situation, i used to watch it with full volume, with no other person's interference and no outings after 9.00 pm and party, of course after 10.00 ! I used to think about MAANEET all the time and collect videos and write OS/SS on Maaneet, too ! 😳

But, see the day has come, when i'm not exciting about it all, I chose match before GHSP, i chose movie before GHSP, i chose my mom's favorite show on some channel before GHSP !

Even, i'm surprised at myself and changes ! Now, i do not think twice, if my friends call for party at night, in fact, i myself, select timings for 9.00 pm !

And, GF ! Oh, it reduced to a level much, i just come here to check written updates and to talk with my friends and GC/Maan/Maaneet's pictures ! That is it !

But, i can't resist GF, as i have got some wonderful friends here ! 😳







Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: dolphinUSA


QUESTION to ALL:
When does a woman leave her home and refuses to forgive her husband? Only in 2 occasions according to me:
- Either she is being tortured by her family and needs to run for her life...
- She loves someone else..(



A woman can walk away too if she values herself and feels that her identity is not valued enough by the man whom she loves to death. Plus in a story or in real life, everything is not linear with couple of options, but there are branches and a line said or not said can redefine relationships.

The word white-blood may seem like a joke and harmless but think about the context in which it was said, and then the impact will be clear. Gairat is a big word and when it was said, it destroyed the fabric of their relationship and hum. Those lines made Geet paraya from Mann and she again became without a family. I applaud the dialogue writer for his amazing world play.

Now coming to the story or the show. How many here pay attention to the characters and their development? A handful only and most are pleased by the scenes rather than a story. When MSK mishandles Geet -- taking a leaf out of M &B' story -- it becomes something hot, and no complains about the character being butchered. A character can be hot without mishandling or uttering words that can hurt real bad.

A long running show has to go through its usual twists and turns for its forward movement. And all said and done, I have plenty of complaints with the show but it has mostly to do with the story and flow.
Edited by an12345678 - 14 years ago
Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
Maandy:

"So, when they present a guy like MSK, it is very much obvious that, girls would love him a lot, and when this kind of thing will happen on the show, it is very much normal, that hero will get all sympathy votes !"

Though I do not agree much to the elevation of Maan's character due to the present track, but I agree to the above lines. And that is why most fail to dig deep when it comes to the analysis of Geet. 😊

Silver Poise
: 🤗🤗🤗 Great Posts and sadly, I need to tell you, I agree to all of them. 😆
-pixie- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
@Maanddy: Looks like your confusion ends where mine begins...since a majority of the viewers are women...I am surprised at the lack of empathy for Geet...A lot of us must be dealing with some of these issues in our relationships (I am making a very big assumption here that a large part of the viewership is committed to some kind of relationship and is not totally relying on Austen for relationship experiences 😃)..so the speed at which we jump to judge, try and hang Geet really amazes me...but then as you said all said and done..my heart beats as much for MSK as the next female on this forum 😆...so a lot of his flaws are quickly forgiven and forgotten😉

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".