I want my MAAN not the MAHAAN...!! - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

84

Views

7.2k

Users

31

Likes

281

Frequent Posters

Bharathi_gurti thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#71
[QUOTE=dtri]I think you are contradicting yourself just a bit. No disrespect don't get me wrong. You said you love Maan for the mistakes he makes. Well there you have it. Maan's behavior was his imperfect way of dealing with the situation. and he with so much guilt today tried to justify his bad behavior by saying "I know my words hurt you so much but i didn't know what to do. Sach mein bol nahi sakta tha aur juth mujhse kaha nahi jaa raha tha" - So in his own Maan way, he apologized to geet too. Also don't forget, men, especially ones like maan (Whose arrogance you say you are in love with), have a hard time saying sorry. Most of the time he emotes with his eyes. Today he said sorry with his eyes so many times. Women say their feelings with more words - like Geet did. I feel that in today's episode, they both said sorry to each other in their own ways.[/QUOTE]i go with every words of yours dear.😳😉..
Edited by sindu1231 - 14 years ago
Bharathi_gurti thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: mysterygurl1427

@Muni di- i agree with everything u have said....i don't think i have to say anything after what di wrote...cause she wrote everything i feel....

I think what happened today in the episode was extremely beautiful! This is the kind of understanding Maaneet have with one another....despite having to spit such horrible words to one another...
their love triumphs all.....geet knows that maan had said such horrible things to her, but it does not matter to her.....because in the end....she knows that whatever he said was out of anger.....and he behaved that way only to keep her away from him.....for their child.
If a husband and wife hold grudges for everything they have said to one another....then there would be divorces left and right....and everyone would remain single. Geet has a heart of gold, yes Di i agree....it is only women that have the power to forgive....especially if that person had done something for a good reason then we do not care....we will forgive and forget! geet did the same here.....she realized her mistake as well...as she felt that some where in that arguement she had doubted his love....
and as for Maan's apology....even though his words were very less his expressions to me revealed...helplessness for the way he behaved that night.....and felt terrible to have said hurtin words to her....and i saw those expressions....and so did geet....the way she looked at him...she knows how much he has been hurt for sayin that
I love Maan....he is still the same....and so is our geet....
maaneet rock!!! thank Munni di for a brilliant reply

👏👏👏
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#73
@Arwen.... Geets..... Girls lub u...muahzzz.....
@Nargis....i cant imagine ppl defending such a horrid thing MSK said.. just coz 'he Din MEAN it' .. eeks.. havent we seen this before...in the office...in the outhouse....??!! What if he had simply told Geet...that i m not going to answer anything u say... and this is how i am..n walking off... wouldnt that have sufficed??
-Amrita2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#74
Wow! Nags, thank you for this post!

You know that I am already in trouble for saying such things, so I better not😆

If Maan didn't mean it, why not we say that Geet too didn't mean it...It was the situation that forced her to say that, hai na?😆

But, for those who say that Geet has to adjust herself, the same should have to be applied to Maan....I love Maan too, but when he does wrong, I accept it, cos I'm not blind too!
Edited by -Amrita2010 - 14 years ago
555070 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#75
Maan may be the kind of person who finds it difficult to say "sorry", but not to Geet. On their date, he had said sorry to her when he wasn't even sure whether she was crying because of him. So, why not today? Even GC's acting floundered. If at least his voice and expressions showed some regret and concern. it would have been bearable. But the screenplay, dialogs and actor, all let us down today.

I sort of accept that their relationship is not equal and am fine with that. In one of my den post, I had explained that their relationship is not equal, but is complementary and that is fine. (Won't go in to details here.) But even if he has the upper hand in the relationship, it does not mean he can not apologize!

Today's episode had the most uncreative Maneet scene ever!
GodHelpUs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#76
Just in time for a quickie😲
(don't let ur imagines run wild, i mean a short post😉)
My response to the thread was purely in context of MSK being made out to be a demi god. However, as is the wont, there are two sides to a coin and each of the facets needs be explored.
Therefore one needs to look at Geet's dimension too. That Geet considers Maan her guardian angel is known and rightfully so but the whole drama that unfolded last week resulted from Geet's lack of faith as well. In that context alone she too is partly to be blamed for the misunderstanding and the consequences.
In the episode where Maan finally mouths " I love you" amidst fake snow fall and the episode where Maan asks Geet to wear the taveez, she says, that every word uttered by MSK is the final word for her, acknowledging her trust implicitly.
At 18-19, she is young but her life experiences aren't what an average teenager would have been through. Just as she trusts blindly, marches on without thinking of the consequences and is ever ready to face come what may, she was hasty in jumping to conclusions as well. Maan did create a web of mistrust by his actions and unthoughtful words, inciting Geet to cast doubts on their relationship, but that alone doesn't absolve her of not rationalising Maan's behavior.
Maan has time and again proved the extent to which he could go for Geet's well being and happiness. What's the point of a relationship when you have to say -I love you, I trust you, I repsect you, I would go to the end of the world for you-every single day or each time there has been a disagreement.
Jaise jhoot ko chilla chillake sau baar bolne se woh sach nahi ho jata...vaise hi har baar apne pyaar ki duhai dena bhi zaroori nahi hai.
After all the PDA and not so PDA by MSK, Geet could have approached Maan with her concerns in a less aggressive way, instead of launching a verbal attack. Yes, she was incited by Maan but gauging from her understanding of Maan she could have shown some restraint.
During the sangeet episodes, Geet persists in questioning Maan and gently nudges him into a comfort zone and extricates the truth out of him about the baby vs mom dilemma.
The same approach would have been far better and the ugly turn that the argument did take eventually and the showdown could have been avoided.She let herself be influenced by external factors, like the TV show, and summed up 2 and 2 to be 5 and presumed a host of issues.
She wears stliettos to a date because Maan casually mentioned that he prefers girls in them. She takes Anni's advice and dresses up to seduce Maan the way its done on a tv show.
Woh kehte hai na, rishto mein kisi teesre ki jagah nahi hoti hai aur honi bhi nahi chahiye. Geet doesnt need a women, her self doubts and imagined grouses are enough to escalate things between them.
Only because the character is young, naive and gullible I forgive Geet for her hand in this mess. But CV can sure do better and not show such contradictions. On the other hand Maan compounded the misery by making stupid statements like..." Maine tumhe Khurana khandaan ki bahu banaya, ais o aaram diye...." which were spiteful to say the least.
One can't take back words just as one can't reverse time. MSK losing his temper is one thing and going overboard with his verbal backlash is quite the other.
Dont have time to read through another thread on the forum which speaks about saying and meaning sorry. And I do agree with the author of that post and have read the book she quotes therein.
Saying sorry helps but backing it up with excuses only ruins the effect and renders the apology tendered in vain.
Vaise sorry bolne se koi chota ya bada nahi ho jata. Geet ne apne behavior ke liye maafi maangi aur baat wahan par uski taraf se khatam hoti hai. Aagey se is baat ka khayal rakhe toh kaafi hai. Maan's apology however was too little too late and unjustified in proportion to his outburst. Mutual admiration ka toh suna tha aur dekha bhi hai lekin yeh toh mutual I am sorry forever club hai😆!
And yes, an angry Maan is very very delicious. Irresistible almost!😉
In conclusion, Geet could have not let her imagined worries get the better off her reasoning and prevented the needless drama. Maan could have handled the already sensitive issue a lot more tactfully than he did.
Edited by GodHelpUs - 14 years ago
Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: -Amrita2010

Wow! Nags, thank you for this post!


You know that I am already in trouble for saying such things, so I better not😆

If Maan didn't mean it, why not we say that Geet too didn't mean it...It was the situation that forced her to say that, hai na?😆

Of course it was situation for both of them, and it always the situation who made people to say things without thinking...That's why anger is not good, cause people can't control and utter such things which not mean to say or hurt anyone....

But, for those who say that Geet has to adjust herself, the same should have to be applied to Maan....I love Maan too, but when he does wrong, I accept it, cos I'm not blind too!

I think hardly people are blind here, mostly are MaanEet fan, and they judge them equally.....Accoding to me both weren't on fault, it's just the situation that both reacted....But Geet counted herself on fault by herself, cause she thought it was her who actually started the fight without understood him....Anyways it's totally rubbish to talk the past, it happened and it's gone, but i expect from both of them to understand eachother before reacting....





Muniza
ravenheart thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#78
@Nags :Yes today's episode left a sour taste in my mouth too. While I am a staunch Geet fan from day one, I find her behaviour in recent times a tad irritating. She was not at fault in the first place and she grovelled in front of him.
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#79
@ Muni and Shivi

If the CV's dont think they are showing Maan is Mahan and Geet a mere Mortal then why the vast disparity?

Okay you think from Both Maan and Geet's side right???So when Geet was saying her share of sorry which was way too much because the CV's made the character to do so....why did they falter in showing his part???

If what Geet did was wrong...then what Maan did was also wrong right???....I am not talking about holding grudges to each other here....why did the CV's not show Maan spell out what he felt, last time when he said those poison filled words, (which was by no means needed and totally uncalled for) he was sad and helpless, why did he not tell her what his state of mind why...???

Maan maybe a man of few words but he does not mince words with Geet and Def not when he has taken to a step to hurt her unknowingly/knowingly...and here he had done that deliberately, and yet it was as if Maan had nothing to say......

Acha chalo Geet felt bad she even asked such a question to him, so apologize kiya ......because the topic was brought, Maan also should have been shown telling how helpless he felt that day for not being able to tell her the truth, He had said those words to her but with every word he uttered torn him apart.....That for every tear that she shed he was dying a 1000 deaths but no.....aisa kuch bhi nahi hua......

The CV's have made Maan over protective....but did he not fall for Geet because of her courage, her never ending spirit to fight all odds and emerge winner???The CV's seems to have forgotten the sketch of their Main heroine

If Maan is showing this attitude coz this time it was regarding her Baby, then it should be showcased in such a manner where he talks to her about everything, and then support her, stand by her as her pillar of strength if she falls weak after knowing the truth.....Why is he underestimating her???

Maan's motive was to protect her coz when its regarding her child she gets all Hyper and thats what Maan wanted to avoid ...but thats no excuse throw word bombs on her....

Acha chalo lets assume its being over Critical/over analytical then why Today in spite of having a GOLDEN opportunity did they not use it to show Maan's side of the story as well???? They could have very well shown ki Maan ne aisa kyu kiya...how wrong he was it would only make him look more HUMAN....

But The CV's failed to show the remorse/Guilty side of Maan...The Director failed to execute it and the actor failed to deliver it.....
Edited by rickks - 14 years ago
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: -Amrita2010

Wow! Nags, thank you for this post!


You know that I am already in trouble for saying such things, so I better not😆

If Maan didn't mean it, why not we say that Geet too didn't mean it...It was the situation that forced her to say that, hai na?😆

But that not how the CV's ended up wrapping the situation na Amu???Whats they did is show MAAN Did not mean it...But Geet did mean every word,......Even if it was the situation that forced her to think so and do....they whole thing has been made to overlook the situation...the final verdict has been showcased such that GEET meant all that she said even if its Maan's actions and his indifference that kept doing this



But, for those who say that Geet has to adjust herself, the same should have to be applied to Maan....I love Maan too, but when he does wrong, I accept it, cos I'm not blind too!

Ilove Maan too.....I keep drooling over him...But i too am not blind to his actions....But the bottom line is we are the audience and this is in the hands of CV's and they have urned a blind eye to this😉



Love Viji

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 5 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 5 months ago

Double Post Sorry

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 6 months ago

Title: The Heartbreak Maan and Geet had been inseparable for years. Their love story was one of those rare ones that had withstood the test of...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".