3IDIOTZ-Maukhe pe Chaukha-Maaneet kisses NT Misses - Page 59

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

I was wondering one thing..let me pen down here...

now that all MU is cleared...i dont want to delve into it anymore...but i wonder if geet's apology was complete in the true sense...

i think dialogues of maan in video conference room had much more depth and was more meaningful....he was saying that he is not the right man for geet because his own bro is responsible for geet's horrible past....he blames himself for carrying the same name as dev and as such he has begun to hate his own family....

he said that he will always be a mirror of past events to geet and that he will never be able to forget the past suffering of geet...

therefore he thinks that geet may not forgive him for being dev's bro...

but wen geet read out the letter of apology...it contained apology only for wat she did on that horror friday...she was only mentioning that watever hapnd was due to circumstances....she mentioned that for that event maan was in no way responsible and as such both of them r right for each other....she also said that she and her baby need maan because if he is not there for them then their life will be in darkness....

wen geet started off with saying sorry and that she was wrong that day....maan replied that he already knows that...it clearly implied that maan was expecting some other assurance from geet....

maan's dialogues implied the future uncertainties in their relationship...he thinks that since he is bro of dev therefore both of them can never forget the past....but maan did not get any assurance from geet on this point....

on wednesday's epi geet had already apologised for friday and maan had forgiven her for that....but on thursday too she did the same thing...the only new thing she added was that she and her baby need him...

so...i dont think geet's reply was in any way complete or perfect....maan's worry about the future still remains unanswered....

i think barry and nissar sir shud work on this...

barry has done wonderfull job with maan's dialogues...but somehow he missed the vital point in geet's speech...

and geet saying that she and her baby need him...also sounded a bit crude...as if she needs him to give the baby a father's name...

i agree this last sentence made maan reply that he is ready to accept this relation....but somehow i felt this sentence cud hv been worded differently....

i dunno how many of u will agree with me...but this is just my POV....

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

I was wondering one thing..let me pen down here...

now that all MU is cleared...i dont want to delve into it anymore...but i wonder if geet's apology was complete in the true sense...

i think dialogues of maan in video conference room had much more depth and was more meaningful....he was saying that he is not the right man for geet because his own bro is responsible for geet's horrible past....he blames himself for carrying the same name as dev and as such he has begun to hate his own family....

he said that he will always be a mirror of past events to geet and that he will never be able to forget the past suffering of geet...

therefore he thinks that geet may not forgive him for being dev's bro...

but wen geet read out the letter of apology...it contained apology only for wat she did on that horror friday...she was only mentioning that watever hapnd was due to circumstances....she mentioned that for that event maan was in no way responsible and as such both of them r right for each other....she also said that she and her baby need maan because if he is not there for them then their life will be in darkness....

wen geet started off with saying sorry and that she was wrong that day....maan replied that he already knows that...it clearly implied that maan was expecting some other assurance from geet....

maan's dialogues implied the future uncertainties in their relationship...he thinks that since he is bro of dev therefore both of them can never forget the past....but maan did not get any assurance from geet on this point....

on wednesday's epi geet had already apologised for friday and maan had forgiven her for that....but on thursday too she did the same thing...the only new thing she added was that she and her baby need him...

so...i dont think geet's reply was in any way complete or perfect....maan's worry about the future still remains unanswered....

i think barry and nissar sir shud work on this...

barry has done wonderfull job with maan's dialogues...but somehow he missed the vital point in geet's speech...

and geet saying that she and her baby need him...also sounded a bit crude...as if she needs him to give the baby a father's name...

i agree this last sentence made maan reply that he is ready to accept this relation....but somehow i felt this sentence cud hv been worded differently....

i dunno how many of u will agree with me...but this is just my POV....

beautiful thought you have expressed here i agree...

yes it was not complete..it only answered one aspect however..the implication of her needing him...would mean that him carrying the same name as the person who victimised her does not bear..any weight with her.

yes it can be made clearer..and yes...if it is explicit..it would help...lets see if they do have that coming to us..in next few days...also...

to her he needs to forgive himself for bearing the same name and know that being from same family does not mean that all are painted with the same brush...yes...she could have been wary..but the things he has done for her have left no doubts as to what his intentions towards her are or the baby...
she is...sure..she needs him and only him and that was said in that apology speech...
hope this helps...

Originally posted by: -RushTrip-

beautiful thought you have expressed here i agree...

yes it was not complete..it only answered one aspect however..the implication of her needing him...would mean that him carrying the same name as the person who victimised her does not bear..any weight with her.

yes it can be made clearer..and yes...if it is explicit..it would help...lets see if they do have that coming to us..in next few days...also...

to her he needs to forgive himself for bearing the same name and know that being from same family does not mean that all are painted with the same brush...yes...she could have been wary..but the things he has done for her have left no doubts as to what his intentions towards her are or the baby...
she is...sure..she needs him and only him and that was said in that apology speech...
hope this helps...

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

i hv no doubt that geet loves maan and needs him and her baby needs him too...also i agree that she has convinced maan that he is not same as his bro....just the way she is not the same as brij....remember how maan once accused geet of being as violent as brij but then instantly repented for saying it...he is not worried that geet will see him in the same bracket as dev....

Aditi, I loved the way you brought out Geet/Brij Vs Maan/Dev relationships angle. Thank you for this insight.

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

i hv no doubt that geet loves maan and needs him and her baby needs him too...also i agree that she has convinced maan that he is not same as his bro....just the way she is not the same as brij....remember how maan once accused geet of being as violent as brij but then instantly repented for saying it...he is not worried that geet will see him in the same bracket as dev....

maan's point was that since he shares the same name as dev...therefore geet's past will always be reflected in their relationship...maan is worried that however much they try but they will not be able to forget the past because of dev's presence in their life....

even if maan keeps no relation with dev...still thru business or other family occassions dev will always be connected to them and so will their past....

geet shud convince maan that dev's presence in their life will make no difference whatsoever...geet shud convince maan that their future will be as secure as maan wants it to be....

aditi your point was very much valid given Geet didnt have Dev child....but when she will be mother of....baby which was automatically related to Dev and whole office knows about it....rather whole world know about it......She anyway cant forget.....Dev anymore...she should learn to live with and fight with it.....If she chose that path.....she has to go on that path.......even if Maan was not related to Dev......That kid will remind her of Dev....and Now world knows about it.....and there is dearth of charcter like sasha in real world...who make mockery of other miseries....She cant forget her past.easily.......because one or other will remind her. or may be remind her baout baby.......Better she should start afresh with it......and be strong with truth..............

Originally posted by: kuls11

aditi your point was very much valid given Geet didnt have Dev child....but when she will be mother of....baby which was automatically related to Dev and whole office knows about it....rather whole world know about it......She anyway cant forget.....Dev anymore...she should learn to live with and fight with it.....If she chose that path.....she has to go on that path.......even if Maan was not related to Dev......That kid will remind her of Dev....and Now world knows about it.....and there is dearth of charcter like sasha in real world...who make mockery of other miseries....She cant forget her past.easily.......because one or other will remind her. or may be remind her baout baby.......Better she should start afresh with it......and be strong with truth..............

koi hai yaarrrrrrrr

Originally posted by: killerkinrul

koi hai yaarrrrrrrr

bad news misscarriage is going to happen woh bhi i think isi week

amu heyyyy

sbs said ke yes miscarriage is happening...