#*Devil's Den#* It's all about getting DITCHED! - Page 63

Originally posted by: swatichowdhury

Opti he could have told her during the jungle date, after all d misunderstandings n fake issues were settled.. Both had confessed their love n commitment to each other...He knew they were going to be engaged, y not get that out as well???? He could have told her during the fountain scene, when geet asked him if her past is bothering him... Or after comming out of the hospital...MSK getting engaged to geet while hiding bout his marriage n aborted child is really creepy n questions Maan's views on truth...

You have a valid point here. The only reason I could give to it is that maybe the guy can process only one information or matter at a time, especially if it involves the heart. Men are not known to be multi-taskers. We have seen that Maan is a little slow on the uptake. He takes time to process information. Even yesterday we saw that he had realised Geet was disturbed when she called him, only much later. The occassions you are mentioning all involve high drama relating to Geet's life. The guy was busy trying to sort out the issue and reassure her of his support. He could have thought that it was not the best time to bare his heart and reveal of his painful past when Geet herself was in pain. Its not easy to say 'Hey, dont worry, I too have a past which is similar to yours."

Even b4 geet revealed her pregnancy status, MSK told her bout truth being the foundation of all relationships.. He knew or thought that geet was going to confess, y din't he tell her bout it b4 the pee-loo seq???

Precisely. Truth was important to him and he would have revealed his past to her had she confrimed her love for him in the Pee loon segment. It is the absence of truth and trust which broke his relationship with Sameera. If Sam had aborted the child without his knowledge, would it not tantamount to viloation of truth and trust? Remember this scene about the truth and trust came after Geet said to her love meant life long commitment. Maan immediately said that this would depend on how strong the foundation is. Later he tells her that for him love meant trust and truth. So I think this is with reference to his relationship with Sameera. It has to be something more than a casual fling or an engagement for him to expect this from her. He had also mentioned that after Sameera he had not let any woman come close to him. This also shows that what he shared with Sameera was not so transient.The reference to strong foundation for life long commitment also suggests that maybe he was married earlier.

If not tell, atleast a small self talk showing maan thinking of revealing bout his marriage n aborted child should have been shown..Then i would have agreed.. But none of it happened...

Why did he not have a self talk? I guess the CVs could have wanted to maintain the secrecy regarding Sammy. With so many experts in the forum who can dissect every expression and word of the leads, they may not have wanted to take a chance to spilling the beans before they were ready to.

Regarding maan questioning geet b4 the engagement, he was in a very romantic mood, check out his husky voice n actions closly...If he wanted to discuss his marriage n aborted kid, that was defo not the body lang or a way of starting a convo bout them..

Yes, his voice was seductive but one should not forget that the request came immediately after his reference to his own past to his bro. He knew Geet had overheard the entire conversation. The fact that he exhibited no anxiety before revealing his truth could be because his past no longer plagues him as it did before. He is in a state of bliss where he can share even painful things with his beloved without getting perturbed by it for he knows she will understand him as he understood her.

Originally posted by: lghosh

Smita however they show it the feelings can't be so foreign to him! And he was grown up when it happened so it can't be that he never realised it. That is why I am feeling this unease over his character consistency!

@Lana: Finally i found someone who agrees with me completely n with whom i agree completely... Lana u stole my words n thoughts when u wrote bout Sameera causing character assasination of MSK... I have been fighting this battle all alone from morning with the devils... I too completely feel the same... I had long back, months back to be precise wrote the same thing when ppl were linking NT to Maan n when the sameera fiasco came into pic... I really don want her to Come... I was praying that they scrap the whole sam issue...

U have no idea how happy i am to have finally found some1 of my wavelengh... I was soo depressed that none agreed with me... U know ppl here hopping n speculating that Maan wasa married to Sam n had a kid with her too which she aborted... I mean, W*F...Everybody was going on n on with it n i was left alone to defend ma munda.. If they show such shit i'll surel stop watching geet...

I too drool over MSK like there is no tomorrow... I think u have seen my emo's.. They describe my Maan obsesssion perfectly...