3 IDIOTS - Ek Be-daag Rishta!

311578 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Index of links to the analysis done beyond page 3.

Imraana's take on page 7
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/34477801

aditi123_78's take on page 11
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/34479030

sksg's take on page 23
https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/34483023

Edited by dolphinUSA - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

413

Views

15.4k

Users

22

Likes

937

Frequent Posters

311578 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Idiots' Tantra Mala

Chamatkar ya Balatkar'idiots ki tantra mala....

Considering that we are all idiots and we need some semblance for we have a pool of writers, analysts and observers, who contribute to increase, improve and help our understanding Geet the serial, characters, plot and other aspects and symbolism in the story. We have people who find elements like water, color and let's not forget inanimate objects like dupatta in their analysis.
So here is the tantra mala for those who don't understand so much Hindi it is a system well it is not idiot proof for it is for idiots..

Tantra

1. The first post is the index and Spoiler links

2. The second post Tantra Mala and Rota

3. The Third post is for the person opening the thread

4. The first three pages are for analysis ONLY as it gets lost in the pages later on. We have received requests for this.

5. The chat thread would be the previous day's thread. So feel free to express anything and everything there.

6. Once the reserve of spot is done within say the first hour, the thread is then open for discussion and replies.

7. Anyone who misses the boat on first three pages to analyse the episode, should send a pm to the opener to index the link so that people find it easy to read your take.

8. We want maximum people to read the analysis and appreciate the effort and time put into watching the episode several time to bring in nuances.

9. The thread will be opened in a rota system and the list will be available on the thread as well.

10. The thread will open at 9:00 pm IST

11. We have opened a Chat Club http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1495244 Please feel free to join this and discuss everything under the sun, moon, stars' anything related to the episode, doubts, different pov, should be done on the main thread let everyone get to know what you are thinking'

Rota Tantra


Next week starting October 4th

Monday ' Pooja

Tuesday ' Shivu

Wednesday ' Viji

Thursday ' Nihu

Friday - Nags

Week starting October 11th

Monday ' Param

Tuesday ' Sann

Wednesday ' Rev

Thursday ' Anisha

Friday ' Sann(nupsie)



Anyone wanting to open the thread please send pms to the founding members, RushTrip, Revv and Nargis



IDIOT Assignments:

Aamir Khan ... Rancho - Nargis
Kareena Kapoor ... Pia - dolphinUSA (Dol)
Madhavan ... Farhan Qureshi - RushTrip (Vrush)
Sharman Joshi ... Raju Rastogi - MaaneetDD (Rev)
Boman Irani ... Viru Sahastrabudhhe - Viji
Omi Vaidya ... Chatur Ramalingam aka 'Silencer' - mysterygurl1427 (Shivani)
Javed Jaffrey ... Ranchoddas Shamaldas Chanchad - Yasu09
Mona Singh ... Mona - blueangle13
Rahul Kumar ... Millimetre - MM - SIGMA (Pram)
Ali Fazal ... Joy - NanditaSingh
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre - Neha
Rajeev Ravindranathan ... Lead Ragging Senior - pooja83
Akhil Mishra ... Librarian Dubey - Maneetforever (Amerra)
3 IDIOT Audiance - aditi123_78 (Aditi)
Mona(Geet's) Unborn Baby - --sann-- (Nupur)
Shoaib Ahmed ... Chote - jamoshi2507 (Neha)
Meghna Bhatia ... Raju's Wife - pickle6586 (Soumya)
Amardeep Jha ... Raju's Mother - macho_muffin
Malvika Singh ... Mona's Baby - Star Struck- Anisha
Chaitali Bose ... Raju's Sister -LavZ


The Open positions are:

Parikshat Sahni ... Farhan's Father
Jayant Kripalani ... Campus Interview Panel Head
Chandrashekhar ... Airlines Ground Staff 2
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre
Achyut Potdar ... Machine Class Professor
Atul Tiwari ... Minister in Auditorium
Arun Bali ... Shamaldas Chanchad
Supriya Shukla ... Matron in Hospital with Pia
Farida Dadi ... Farhan's Mother
Omi ... Chatur - pondicherry boy
Pooja Goswami ... Air Hostess
Harvinder Singh ... Mr. Dhillon
Nishi Singh ... Maid at Pia's House
Dinesh Kumar ... Mona's Husband
Aakash Dabhade ... ICE Student 2
Pitobash ... Junior 1
Rakesh Sharma ... Minister at Shyamaldas' Funeral
Michael Joseph ... Exam Hall Professor
Captain A.S. Duggal ... Pilot
Dr. Praful Kulkarni ...Doctor startled by scooter in hospital
Sarvanna ... College Security Guard
Trilok Sadhwani ... ICE Student 4
R.S. Kodange ... Doctor at Airport
Mukund Bhatt ... Raju's Father
Tanveer Ahmed ... Professor in Induction Motor Class
Hitesh Tak ... Ragging Senior 2
Sitaram Sharma ... Manager at Pia's Wedding
Raghunathan ... Professor in Corridor
Vaidyanathan ... Professor Vaidyanathan
Rajendra Patwardhan ... Govind
Sanjay Sood ... Peanut Vendor at Shimla
Annapurna Kaul ... Airlines Ground Staff 1
Pandit Prayag Raj ... Panditji at Pia's Wedding
Dr. Kishor Patil ... Doctor in Ambulance with Raju
Dayal Sharma ... Caretaker at Shyamaldas' House
Shankar Sachdev ... Ambulance Driver
Dharmendra Bhurji ... Airport Cab Driver
Apul Jaisinghani ... ICE Student 3
Shailaja Dhar ... Lady at Mona's Wedding
Saurabh Agnihotri ... Housekeeping Boy at Pia's Wedding
Kumar Veer Singh ... Waiter at Mona's Wedding
Sonu ... Library Clerk
Dileep Desai ... Priest at Joy's funeral
311578 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
This guy is so filled with love, that he can outdo the love combined from all men in the world. So much love was hidden under his tough exterior that no one even got a glimpse of it, leave alone the question of getting it. Geet is really very lucky and she deserves every bit of this shower of love from him. She has suffered too much.

Now I'm curious to know what was it that Sameera did to turn a gold hearted Maan into iron. I'm sure it must have been something terrible because he turned black from the pure white that he is...now that he's with Geet. I really want to know what caused him to close out completely.

Maan understands and knows Geet too well. I hope he will soon understand the torture she will go through after seeing Dev. I don't want him not to know about Dev for a long time. They are building their relationship on truth and trust, and I'd be very upset if she lies to him again. But to come to think of it, Maan has done a little too much for Geet in making sure she is comfortable and loved. I wonder what will Geet do for Maan. That is going to be a real test for her. I hope she doesn't stay quiet.

The show has somehow become more focused on Maan than Geet for the time being and it's understandable. I'm not complaining. I'm wondering what's coming next...what's going to happen to shift the focus back to Geet.

I hope Geet decides to tell Maan the truth herself, rather than hiding. And then she can do something for Maan - she can ask him to stay quiet about the whole affair when he decides to put Dev in jail. This will be her biggest sacrifice for Maan...she will save his image...Khurana khaandaan's image from being hampered. I hope something like this happens. I would hate for Maan to find out Geet lied to him yet again.
Edited by dolphinUSA - 14 years ago
--Revv-- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Your smile
by Jenny

Thinking about you,
Makes my day,
Every moment,
In every way,
Your smile melts my heart,
Like no other,
Especially,
When we stare at each other,
Your face gives me butterflies,
Whenever I look at you,
It makes me want to blurt out,
I Love You,
But what turns me on,
Is not just you face and your smile,
It's your personality,
And the times when we talk awhile,
Being with you makes me happy,
All the time,
That I wished you were forever mine,
But you have someone else
Which hurts my heart,
Every time I think about it,
It tears me apart,
I understand,
If you love another and not me,
Because the truth is,
I just want you to be happy,
But what pains me the most,
Is when we talk to each other,
And all you can talk about,
Is her,
If she makes you smile,
If she makes you glad,
I don't want to get in the way,
Because I'm not like that,
But to tell you the truth,
When she goes,
I just want to tell you,
I love you more then you'll
Ever know

Today for me here is no best scene... The whole epi was magnificient and the diags were terrific!! I understand the CVs are cramping us with lovey dewy scenes so our chuha hearts can take in the next few teary epis!!! Someone advised me today to live in the moment!! so thats what I am gonna do... So no predictions... only symbolisms!!

The hospital scene.. The 1st frame where he walks in worried as the check up took a long time... For me it symbolized that even if Maan keeps away from Geet on purpose, the separation wont be for long... He just cant be without seeing her!!👏👏

When he stopped Geet from speaking up in front of the doc, for me it meant that though Geet may want to tell the truth about the child, he would take it upon himself to ensure that all think the child is his..Even declaring himself as her hubby just symbolized the same for me 😊😊
The intertwined hands just symbolized oneness in their relationship!!
Maan is very perceptive, he realized Sasha was taking a dig at Geet when she spoke about change and thats why he danced... And Dadi saying Maan's desert like life has flowers in them cos of Geet 😆😆😆..Both their faces was worth seeing 😆😆
And the diag where he says that when ur footsteps bring u towards me, there would be no lies!!! But I feel there would be the serpent called Dev between them!!!!
The jewellery scene has been dissected enuff I guess... 😉😉😉..
If I have missed anything.. dont feel free to shoot me 😛😛😛😛
Edited by --Revv-- - 14 years ago
_Invincible_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
meri duniya hai tujh mein kahin
tere bin main kya kuch bhi nahi..............
more closer u look at him d deeper u fall in love wid him.................
maan is a perfect brainteaser.......................too simple yet too difficult to figure out.........
a lot of positive symbolisms today....................nice epi..............
maan took up all d lecture of doc with patience.........................
i guess can b related to wen daadi will come to know abt geet's truth den daadi will blast him but he will b patient and try to assure and convince daadi........
d way maan held her hand wen geet was abt to say sumthing to doc seemed like he was assuring her dat he is ready to listen to whole world's allegations 4 baby and she doesnt need to speak up and clarify things to any1..........
like for d first time dev pronounced myra's name well..................
so for d first time devil dev has realized his sin was too horrible and may take d right step in right direction now..............
maan let her to go first so dat dey r not questioned............
even wen dev 's truth will come out to him he will talk to geet and support her so dat people dont point fingers at geet regarding baby........
maan spoiled sasha's smirk....
poor sasha smirking thinking dat geet would b let down by maan.....................but sasha baby as u urself said dat change is a rule of life ................so cant ur dimwit brain figure out dat maan has changed....................similarly wen sasha's misdeeds towards geet will come out her evil smirk will b wiped off 4ever................lolz
myra stopping dev at right time...............
she will alwz guide him to do right things at right time not to spoil maneet's happiness due to his evil deeds.............
maan removed artificial jewellery...................
geet was made to wear dat artificial jewellery symbolises her fake marriage to dev but maan made her wear real gold assuring her dat nothing is fake dis time and dey r meant to b together 4 real and r not faking 4 dadi as dey started off wid dat...................
daagdaar chaand but bedaag relation of maneet.....................
dat dialogue just took my breath away.........................chaand mein daag hain but inke rishte mein koi daag nahi......................i agree ..............but maan 4 dat u have to kill dev so dat daag is wiped off................🤣
maan ki selfishness bhi geet k liye hi hai................i m 🤢in maan's love................
DD was looking damn beautiful in dat dress and jewellery which maan put on her........
precap.............
again misleading..................😡😡😡😡
but dev-geet confrontation is around d edge of corner..............😆😆
ye freeze pt. or ye weekend ka deadly combo hai jaanlewa...............🤣
but if dev avted as a show stopper den i m surely booking next flight to india to kill him..............😡😡😡😡...................
funny part
adi ----------maan sir aap aa gaye daantne ,,,,i mean nachne.........😆😆😆
adi's sunglasses.................😆😆😆😆😆
sasha's dress..............😆😆😆😆
my questions...................
why still geet calls him maan sir?😆😆
why didnt dey call a professional mehndi designer for geet's mehndi????????😆😆
Edited by pooja83 - 14 years ago
-honeydew- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Dard bhare episodes ki itni aadat ho gayi hai .. ke itni khushi mujhse hazam nahi ho rahi ... i am all the time tensed and wondering, aagey kya galat hoga .... poor insecure me 😭😭😭

but honestly the episode was sweet ... in places repetitive ... well Maan ko bas ek hi step aata hai kya??? aur fir Geet also ....

i totally loved the hospital scene .. the best was when she slips her hand into his ...!!! and his over concern for her was cute .. where he says .. it got delayed thats why i got worried ...

last scene had its significance ... he made a promise ... that nothing between them will ever be fake again, including a piece of jewellery on her ...i love the moon and the moon light hence anything under it is a treat to watch ... but those lights meant he would glow her life up with brightness and warmth ...

Dhrasti looked soooooooooooooooo pretty ...

Maan is soooooooooooooo adorable ... he actually wore the taveez.... and flaunted it .....!!!

Edited by -honeydew- - 14 years ago
nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
but i want a 'bolti' band episode...but khushi - khushi wala😉

❤️i love Maan❤️


EDITED:-


finally i made up my mind..aaj nahi toh kabhi nahi...eww! i'm bad at melodrama...so <jump> straight to the point & point is i'm writing after making a hat-trick of going speechless in row ..... hmm! like a baby's attempt with trying to figure out & try to speak ...me making my attempt...bear with me



1> I Fear Nothing...

If Only
---A. Chudinov
If only i was one of your tears,
i would start in your eyes,
live on your lips and die on your cheeks,
and if you was one of mine,
i wouldnt cry for the fear of losing you.

Hmm! Maan in context to Geet's comment that Hospital environment makes him all nervous & fearful...'ghabhraahat' , but Maan refused it saying he fears nothing....'mujhai kise bhi cheez sai ghabhraahat nahi hoti' was his defensive answer to it....But he does fear...when it comes to his loved ones, be it Daadi maa fainting or Geet going for her first check up....hence he cannot wait & rushes inside the cabin ..Geet too is surprised to see him all anxious for her...nor does the Doc fail to see his love & concern


2>Responsibilities ...

Ah! I again pray to see men like Him walk the earth so that no women ever has to suffer any grief or pain....but be protected , loved & cared...
He said to her the other day that he understands her responsibilities & is to share them with her ... as his own...Being a man of action he dint wait for The D-day to pass ...
he took her to the hospital for her first check up...He knew for various reasons she must have sure skipped it & how essential it is for her in her present state...
With no thoughts about what this may lead to, that is if Daadi comes to know of it etc...he thinks of nothing but Geet & baby's health....


3> Unconditional Love...

Once in a lifetime comes a love,
So sweet, so pure, so rare;
A flashing, brilliant, blinding light,
Like a comet through the air.

A love without rhyme or reason,
That knew no space or time;
Wrapped itself around my soul,
And captured this heart of mine.

There was something there so special,
Mere words cannot explain;
The way our hearts were intertwined,
And how that still remains.
-Allison


a girl who had once accused him 'Aap apne baaton main itni kaadvahat kaise ghol patai hain?' is now forced to ask him ...'itna pyaar aap nai kaha sai paya?'
How can one help and not fall in love with a man like Him...❤️


4> Selfish ...

Maan as we see is set to redefine everything & upset our emotional & mental balance..
First he redefined Love ...His ' I Hate U'.. still stirs my soul with its passion & pain....
Date...since i'm a big time unromantic..i don't much like the concept of date, why ? don't ask me i've no answers....But he made me to wish..wish for a date like this..
Redefined Expression of Love...I so don't ever want to hear a ILU now....it has lost its charm for me.....
And now he redefined Selfishness....'Mera swart hai kai main tumhai humesha khush dekhun, Kyunki tum khush ho toh mere zindagi shant hai..tumharai hoton mein muskurahat hai toh mere duniya muskurati rehti hai'
I was all tears ..dint you all cry...proud of him


5>'the gaps in between your fingers were made for me to fill'

You fill me up when I am empty,
Like no one else has done;
Pour warmth into my spirit,
Like rays from summer sun.

Like rain upon the desert,
On a dry and barren land;
You cause my soul to blossom,
With touch from gentle hands.



Finally she did not stop herself from taking his hands in her own , his love gave her the courage & now she knew she can hold on to him , always.


6>One Look..

Though splendor does surround me,
It never will replace;
The beauty that my heart does see,
When I behold your face.


Since all my gyaani friends talked of Maan not wanting to embarrass her ...asked her to enter the house alone & that he will follow her in a little later..i will rather skip it & talk of next frame after that....
When he stops her for one look..one look of her smiling face & to make her blush.....to assure her that he is always with her...



7> Perfect Dance...

Even though it's just a dream,
Of dancing quietly with you.
If I close my eyes and I hear the song,
A dream, almost come true.


Having answered this many times here...all i want to say is its his imperfection in 'bhangra moves' that actually made the moment perfect....it stressed on the fact that for her he is ready to try anything-everything that he never did till date....
if not my words then atleast Daadi maa ki baat toh manogai na...
'Kya baat hai Geet! Maangaye aapko aapne reigistan main phool khila diyai'
As for her she was only trying to match her steps with his....what can be more perfect than this.....



8> Purity of Love...

Across a sky of indigo blue,
On a cold and lonely night;
Two twinkling stars hung silently,
Just out of each other's sight.

Each star looking wistfully,
At a moon that turned to blue;
Wishing on a another star,
To find a love so true.
-Allison


What can be more pure & sacred than unconditional love that only believes in giving & for taking from you..he takes away all your sorrows & pain..
Love that can be compared to devotion & a lover to God...for he is always there when you need him to hold you , protect you, love you & expect nothing in return...
The Moon, the stars , the whole nature bows to love in its divine form...

.........
Love You Maan....more than anything else love you for giving us a dream...a hope , a prayer that someday each of us may find someone like You....
You are so special that,
I wanted you to know
I truly, completely love you so.



love
Nandita


Edited by nanditasingh - 14 years ago
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Maaneet-Ek Pakheeza Se Rishta

Kya Likhoon…..

Likhne Layak Chodega Toh Kuch Likhoongi Na….😍

Maan Singh Khurana I want to ask you the same questions Geet asked you

"Aapka Ithna Bada Dil Kyu Hai???….Ithni humdardi Kahan se Laathe Ho Aap"

Damn It guys…..This Guy really has a Heart of GOLD…..and it reflects in everything he does and says…How How How???? How does he manage to leave us speechless every time??? Why Why Why???? Why is there No Maan in the real world???

Okay i dont know if i will be making any sense

kyu ki main saala kaam se gayi😆

**Symbolisms and Analysis**

The way Maan listens to all the scolding of the Doctor with out letting her speak:

Shows That in times when Geet has to take up stand and responsibility of something like in this case Maan is not one bit responsible for the fact that Geet never had routine check-up but he does not allow her to speak up or take up the scoldings from Doc…instead he intervenes and takes the whole thing upon him….So hopefully in future also when such a situation comes up Maan will take up the whole thing without hurting Geet…..Well some how I connect this to Dadi's Reaction when the whole Preg+Dev Track is Out even if Geet tries to speak up….Maan will not allow or stand it when Geet is under questions….

The way Geet and Maan Hold Hands

Before Leaving the Hospital Maan and Geet Hold Hands and did you notice how Geet uses both her hands and clutches Maan's hand….It showed how she was not going to let go off Maan at any cost…..it showed the Vulnerability and fear3of an 18 year old and the stubbornness of a woman in love who was not ready to let go of the Man who means the world to her at any cost…..

Meera and her actions:

As I have said a million times before, I still repeat the same….Meera will be the one factor who will be guarding Maaneet's Happiness and will do everything in her will to not let things spill in such a way that it would leave everything scattered…..

Meera is Dev's Friends so she had to tell him the truth she came across…..But at the same time I don't think she will let Dev take any step which would foil everything making it in repairable for life…….

Nature and Maaneet Bonded for Life:

I really want to thank Nissar for this wonderful expressions he uses in the form of Nature…..all important Maaneet moments from the beginning had Nature and Nature alone as its sole witness…river, rain, Moon etc…..and when doing this we realize how special Maaneet is to God… It's always nature who witnesses and blesses them in the journey of their relationship….MAKING IT STRONGER AND DEEPER

From where Meera leaves, Maan picks it up:

Well today's ending part showed Dev to reach Maaneet, obviously it would be to tell him the entire truth….But I am sure yet again something will come up….one thing is for sure ki Maan will make Geet leave before Dev catches up and Geet sees him…..Dev either being blocked by some one before he can tell the truth or meet Geet or meet Maan shows that his path is a Dead end….His fate will be the same which ever route he takes…..A Dead End.

Dev-A Devil who Robbed Geet of Everything she had 😡

and

Maan-A messiah who would not stop at any cost until he sees the smile on her face😍


"Tum Khush Ho toh meri Zindagi Shaanth Hai

Tumhare Hoton par Muskhurahat hai tih meri Duniya Bhi Khushiyon se bhar jaayegi"

(Sorry Dialogues would be corrected later)

Loads of Love Viji

Edited by rickks - 14 years ago
rickks thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
For all My sweet and Crazy Idiot Family....Feel free to use....

A blushing Maan
😳




The Raam Avatar in Maan


--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️Loved it!!!!❤️


I don't have the time to write an analysis today.................but here are some beautiful words that express who Maan is and why I love him so....................

Teri ek hasi pe ye dil qurbaan kar jaoo,
Aitraaz na ho agar to tera dil chura le jaoo,

Na behne du kabhi in aakho se aansu,
Tu kahe to tere saare sitam sah jaoo.

Hasta hua rakhu tere labo ko hamesha,
Chumkar jinhe woh pyaari muskaan de jaoo,
Seene se laga ke rakhu tumhe,
mann to karta hai tujhme sama jau.

Sunti hi rahu tumhari dhadkano ko,
aur apne dil ki har baat kah jau,
gum ko kabhi kareeb na aane du,
aur tumhe zindage ki khushiya tamaam de jaoo


Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".