Originally posted by: justme_12
I want to say in the very beginning that my comment is not meant to hurt you in any way. I am commenting as an average reader. oh yikes...why do i feel like this is going to get me riled up again 😕
I guess I am one of those very few who did not want Geet to go back to Maan ever. May be forgive him but no reconciliation. that group is growing...😆
So, I was totally hooked to the story till a point where Geet behaved strong and professional. Adi-Geet story was wonderful as well. the way you phrased your comment makes it seem like you dont like Geet being strong and professional...you said you were hooked until that happened...so im confused...
But, the best character you have created in this story is of Sameera. My point is does Maan deserve a life with her? why not...one mistake should make maan be miserable the rest of his life?
Your story started with "karma is a bitch", so what happened to Maan's karma in the story? first of all story isnt over yet...there is a lot left...secondly, Maan never purposfully hurt anyone...Geet just happened to be a casualty from the situation his sister gave rise to (which he has no idea about)...yes...he hurt Geet...but that doesnt mean that he didnt hurt as well...just cuz he proposed a contract marriage to sam but that didnt mean he just up and moved on like geet was nothing...that was the whole point of this update...
I know its your story, you have every right to direct it the way you want to, but I request you to understand the average reader's sentiments as well. Almost every member here breathes Maan and Geet together. Them being separated under circumstances is fine, them not getting together ever is also fine, but please understand, together or not we expect Maan-Geet interaction. well...the average reader has come to understand by now that this isnt your average run-of-the-mill Maneet story...because Maan and Geet are tied to other people...those relationships take precedence over everything else...and the average reader seems to be doing fine without the Maan and Geet interactions because the story is nowhere near finished...and they also understand why such interactions would be difficult and why they arent coming up...their lives are no longer tied together like the used to be...Maan is simply the brother of a patient that geet is treating...thats all...she's kept him up to date as needed...she doesnt need to buddy up with him
Maan-Sameera love story depicts Maan being happily settled in life, this is something I just cannot accept given the circumstances. I guess you have noticed from most comments that Adi-Geet are accepted and loved, but not Sameera and Maan. accept it or not it is what it is...i feel with those readers...it wouldnt matter what justification i give...for them Maan is the culprit and will always be...i can say maan had a brain tumor that effected his judgment and people wont care...so i cant cater to everyone
I request you to do an introspection as a writer and decide.
I know people might find me mad writing so much, and come out with the solution : DONT READ, WHO IS FORCING YOU. seriously...thats my take as well...as a writer i dont want to read about the pit falls of my stories and how unrealistic they are for the "average reader"...like ive said a gazillion times...im not a professional writer...im totally amateur...you cant expect things to be perfect like you might want...
But I am sure you understand, once you start reading a story, it becomes difficult to detach no matter what. You are a wonderful and gifted writer, but I request you a final consideration. there are a lot of stories i've read where i cant understand the plot or the stories just stop to entice me...so i just stop...and there is nothing to be considered...the story will play out like i've always had planned
Maan and Sameera is just not happening. No Maan-Geet, thats fine.
Most importantly, in the last few updates its all about Sameera, wasn't Geet supposed to be the protagonist? i dont know what story you are reading but part 14 was ENTIRELY based on Geet...this story is about Maan and Geets lives after their break up...that life includes other people...so those people deserve their dues...
Had this story was written on an open forum, things would have been different. Please understand this, we love Geet Maan as our protagonist. and i dont know how many times ive said it for this story...BUT THIS STORY ISNT LIKE THAT!! i can yell it from the roof tops but people dont get it...and i dont know why!! its so damned frustrating...if you cant deal...like you said...dont read
Maan Singh Khurana should actually be left alone to regret his lack of trust. He does not deserve the life he is leading with a lady like Sameera after he did what he did with Geet. you're seriously telling me that a person who made a bad judgment call...or made a call he thought he had to make...deserved a life of solitude...with no love...i know the world is cruel but even the worst people get second chances
And if talk about redemption, then why not Maan and Geet together. but why...people are so fast to point out how horrible Maan is...and how he doesnt deserve any happiness...but they are just as quick to ask for Maan and Geet together...does Geet deserve to be with a man who didnt trust her at the time? and to answer your question...why cant maan and geet be together...because i said so...simple
Dont get mad at me. I am a loyal Geet fan as everyone here, so its actually painful and borderline frustrating, hope you understand where I am coming from. dont read is all i can say...why torture yourself...and get frustrated reading something that riles you up? i dont get it...i dont get why people come and complain about how they dont understand the story...how the story has pit falls...how the story isnt progressing as they want ti...so why come back and read!!